cover of episode 56 许纪霖、刘擎:不卷不躺,2025如何抵抗虚无

56 许纪霖、刘擎:不卷不躺,2025如何抵抗虚无

2025/1/6
logo of podcast 许纪霖的播客

许纪霖的播客

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
刘擎
华东师范大学紫江特聘教授,主要研究西方思想史和现代政治哲学
许纪霖
Topics
许纪霖:本书从‘前浪’‘后浪’视角研究知识分子群体,探讨其在时代变迁中的精神状态与应对方式。文章分析了晚清、五四、改革开放以来不同时代青年一代面对虚无主义的共同点与差异,并提出‘用行动克服虚无’的观点。作者认为,虽然不同时代青年克服虚无的方式不同,但核心都是寻找可依傍的信仰或目标,并通过行动赋予人生意义。在当代,年轻人更多通过爱情、社群活动、碎片化体验等方式来应对虚无,这与以往时代相比,呈现出更加个人化和碎片化的特点。 许纪霖还借鉴钱永祥的观点,分析了‘重欲’与‘虚无’的关系,并提出四种应对虚无的方式:纵欲、精神重欲、自杀、隐世。他认为,鲁迅式的‘积极的虚无主义’值得借鉴,即在看透虚无后依然热爱生活,积极行动,在过程中寻找人生价值。许纪霖最后总结,人生需要平衡,要找到适合自己的‘卷’与‘躺’的平衡点,并鼓励年轻人去爱、去体验,在不同的人生阶段寻找不同的意义。 刘擎:刘擎对许纪霖的观点表示赞同,并补充说明了当代年轻人虚无感的特点。她认为,当代中国已经进入‘后城邦哲学’时代,年轻人与国家命运的联系日益松散,更加关注个人幸福和快乐。因此,他们更多地采用‘situation shape’即情景化的、临时性的方式来应对虚无,例如参加演唱会、玩游戏等。这与五四一代和八十年代一代相比,更加强调个人化和碎片化。 刘擎指出,当代年轻人克服虚无的方式与以往不同,他们不再追求宏大的现代主义叙事和完整的信仰体系,而是采用后现代的、碎片化的应对方法。这种方式虽然能带来短暂的快乐,但未必能提供长久的意义感和满足感。她认为,‘深度’的生活需要完整的价值观和信仰体系,而‘肤浅’的生活容易陷入对快乐的永无止境的追逐。最终,刘擎强调,每个人都可以选择适合自己的方式来应对虚无,关键在于找到平衡,在‘卷’与‘躺’之间找到适合自己的节奏,并鼓励年轻人去尝试,去体验,在过程中寻找人生的意义。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What is the main theme of Xu Jilin's new book '前浪后浪'?

The main theme of Xu Jilin's new book '前浪后浪' is the generational transition and evolution of Chinese intellectuals, focusing on the dynamics between older and younger generations. Xu explores the concept of '前浪' (older generation) and '后浪' (younger generation), emphasizing the continuity and changes in intellectual thought across different eras.

How does Xu Jilin describe the role of intellectuals in Chinese society?

Xu Jilin describes intellectuals as pivotal figures in shaping Chinese society, particularly through their ideological and cultural contributions. He highlights their role in navigating the complexities of political and social changes, and how they influence generational shifts in thought and values.

What historical periods does Xu Jilin focus on in his book?

Xu Jilin's book spans several key historical periods in China, including the late Qing dynasty, the May Fourth Movement, the Cultural Revolution, and the post-Cultural Revolution era. He examines how intellectuals from these periods responded to societal changes and contributed to the evolution of Chinese thought.

What is the significance of the May Fourth Movement in Xu Jilin's analysis?

The May Fourth Movement is significant in Xu Jilin's analysis as a pivotal moment of intellectual awakening and cultural transformation in China. He explores how the movement's emphasis on science, democracy, and individualism influenced subsequent generations of intellectuals and shaped modern Chinese thought.

How does Xu Jilin address the concept of 'resisting nihilism' in his book?

Xu Jilin addresses the concept of 'resisting nihilism' by examining how intellectuals throughout Chinese history have sought to find meaning and purpose in times of societal upheaval. He highlights the importance of action, belief, and community in overcoming existential crises and maintaining a sense of direction and hope.

What does Xu Jilin suggest about the relationship between the older and younger generations?

Xu Jilin suggests that the relationship between the older and younger generations is one of both continuity and conflict. He emphasizes the need for mutual understanding and dialogue, as older generations pass on their experiences and values, while younger generations bring new perspectives and challenges to traditional norms.

How does Xu Jilin view the role of intellectuals in contemporary China?

Xu Jilin views contemporary Chinese intellectuals as crucial in navigating the country's rapid modernization and globalization. He argues that they must balance traditional values with modern ideas, and play a key role in addressing societal issues such as inequality, environmental degradation, and cultural identity.

Chapters
本期节目探讨了从民国时期至今,知识分子如何抵抗虚无主义的历程。从五四运动到改革开放,再到当下年轻一代,不同时代的人们面临着不同的挑战和困境,但对意义和价值的追寻却始终贯穿其中。节目中,嘉宾们分享了各自的观察和思考,探讨了多种应对虚无的方式,并对当下年轻一代的生存状态进行了深入分析。
  • 从民国到当下,知识分子抵抗虚无的方式多种多样,从行动到信仰,从纵欲到隐世,不一而足。
  • 当下年轻一代的虚无感与过去几代人有所不同,更加个人化和碎片化,他们更多地通过情景化关系和短期目标来应对虚无。
  • 抵抗虚无的关键在于找到一种平衡,在卷与躺之间找到适合自己的节奏,在深度与浅度之间找到适合自己的方式。

Shownotes Transcript

2024年12月29日,在许纪霖的《前浪后浪》新书发布会上,刘擎与他在上海建投书局有一场精彩的对话,从民国谈到当下,从新书谈到现实,从爱情谈到抵抗虚无