Vol.220 和南风公公聊聊《短剧之王2024》
闲聊客听|说说身边事 聊聊身边人
Deep Dive
What were the key changes in the judging panel for the 2024 Short Play King competition?
The key change in the judging panel was the absence of 'that man,' referring to Matsumoto Hitoshi, a long-time influential judge. The panel included previous champions like Yamauchi Kenshi (2017), Kuwata Shunsuke (2011), and Koga Eiji (2012), with the addition of Shirota Jiro (2019) as a new judge.
Why did the format of the Short Play King competition lead to weaker second-round performances?
The format of the competition, which combines scores from two rounds, incentivizes participants to save their best material for the first round. This often results in weaker second-round performances, as participants may not have equally strong material for both rounds. Additionally, the second round's scoring is less impactful, making it less critical for participants to excel in that round.
What was the standout performance in the 2024 Short Play King competition according to the hosts?
The standout performance was by the group 'Nagaboshi Oyaji' (Long Beard Old Man). Their skit, which involved a man trying to buy flowers for a girl, was praised for its natural humor, subtle interactions, and strong character dynamics. The hosts particularly appreciated the nuanced reactions and the way the skit avoided over-the-top comedy, focusing instead on realistic and relatable humor.
How did the cultural context of Japan influence the reception of certain skits in the competition?
Cultural context played a significant role in the reception of skits. For example, a skit about a baseball team struggling to find a practice space resonated less with Japanese audiences due to the overuse of baseball-related humor in Japanese comedy. Similarly, a skit about live-streaming sales, which is a common theme in China, felt fresh to Japanese audiences who are less exposed to this format.
What was the overall sentiment of the hosts towards the 2024 Short Play King competition?
The hosts had mixed feelings about the competition. While they appreciated the high production quality and the dedication of the performers, they also noted that many skits were difficult to understand or lacked clear comedic logic. They felt that the competition often rewarded unconventional or abstract humor, which sometimes left them confused about why certain skits won high scores.
What are the expectations for the upcoming M-1 Grand Prix based on the discussion?
The hosts expressed excitement for the upcoming M-1 Grand Prix, with particular interest in whether the group 'Reiwa Roman' can achieve a second consecutive championship. They also highlighted other strong contenders like 'Vacuum Cleaner' and 'Tom Brown,' noting that the competition is expected to be fierce, with many seasoned and new talents vying for the title.
- 第17届《短剧之王》落幕
- 三位主持人对比赛的整体感受：看不懂高分作品的夺冠原因
- 赛制影响：两轮比分相加，导致选手策略调整
- 评委阵容变化：松本人志退出，年轻化评委阵容带来新变化
Shownotes Transcript