We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Are em dashes really a sign of AI writing? 'Caretaker' vs. 'caregiver'

Are em dashes really a sign of AI writing? 'Caretaker' vs. 'caregiver'

2025/6/17
logo of podcast Grammar Girl Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing

Grammar Girl Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
D
Don
J
Jim Norrena
M
Mignon Fogarty
Topics
Mignon Fogarty: 我对社交媒体上流传的“破折号是AI写作标志”的说法感到非常恼火,以至于不得不临时调整编辑计划来驳斥这一观点。我认为这种说法毫无根据,并且正在误导大众。我最近在写作中增加了破折号的使用频率,每次看到相关的社交媒体帖子,我都会更频繁地使用。那些声称破折号是AI写作标志的人,甚至不了解正确的标点符号名称,因此他们的观点不值得信任。社交媒体算法喜欢争议和评论,这导致了相关帖子的广泛传播,但这些帖子下的评论大多是作者们的反对意见。尽管我试图避免谈论这个话题,以免火上浇油,但我现在无法再忽视它。AI工具的写作风格源于对人类写作的训练,因此破折号的使用与AI写作没有直接关联。事实上,早在ChatGPT出现之前,很多人就喜欢使用破折号。虽然有研究表明某些词汇在AI写作中出现频率较高,但这并不意味着看到这些词汇就一定是AI写作。我们不应该因为AI过度使用某些词语而放弃使用它们,也不应该仅凭几个词语就指责别人使用AI。AI检测器的错误率很高,尤其是在某些人群中,因此不建议使用。识别AI写作的一个可能方法是关注写作风格的突然变化,或者留意AI生成的文本介绍是否被意外保留。然而,写作风格的改变也可能源于其他原因,例如参加了写作课程。总而言之,破折号是AI写作标志的观点缺乏证据支持,我们不应该盲目相信社交媒体上的说法。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

  1.  Is the em dash a sign of AI writing? I looked at where the idea comes from, and we have the final answer! Then, we look at the difference between "caregiver" and "caretaker."

The "'caregiver" and "caretaker'" segment was written by Jim Norrena, MFA, who has been writing and editing for more than thirty-five years. He’s the founder of TypoSuction.com), an independent editing/writing service. He's taught grammar and copyediting intensives and professional proofreading workshops at Media Alliance) and served as events coordinator for Bay Area Editors’ Forum (BAEF)). Visit Linkedin.com/in/jimnorrena/) for his complete work history and highlighted projects.

🔗 **Share your familect recording in a **WhatsApp chat.)

🔗 Watch my LinkedIn Learning writing courses).

🔗 Subscribe to the newsletter).

🔗 **Take our advertising survey). **

🔗** Get the edited transcript).**

🔗 **Get Grammar Girl books). **

🔗 Join Grammarpalooza)**. **Get ad-free and bonus episodes at Apple Podcasts) or Subtext). Learn more about the difference). 

| HOST: Mignon Fogarty

| VOICEMAIL: 833-214-GIRL (833-214-4475).

| Grammar Girl is part of the Quick and Dirty Tips podcast network).

  • Audio Engineer: Dan Feierabend
  • Director of Podcast: Holly Hutchings
  • Advertising Operations Specialist: Morgan Christianson
  • Marketing and Video: Nat Hoopes

| Theme music by Catherine Rannus).

| Grammar Girl Social Media: YouTube). TikTok). Facebook).Threads). Instagram). LinkedIn). Mastodon). Bluesky).