We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Is The World Getting More Violent?

Is The World Getting More Violent?

2024/12/10
logo of podcast Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
K
Kurzgesagt
Topics
Kurzgesagt: 十年前,我们制作了一个名为《战争结束了吗?》的视频,当时基于上世纪的长期趋势,暴力冲突似乎在减少,世界比以往任何时候都更加和平。然而,过去十年并非如我们所料。本视频将回顾2014年视频中的七个论点,并分析它们在过去十年中的有效性。首先,我们对过去十年的冲突进行了概述,一些在2014年非常激烈的冲突已经结束或显著降温,例如阿富汗战争。也门和利比亚内战陷入僵局,伊拉克和叙利亚的ISIS已被消灭,叙利亚内战也已结束。然而,新的冲突爆发或旧的未解决问题再次升级为暴力冲突,例如埃塞俄比亚的提格雷战争,苏丹、也门和缅甸内战等。非洲多个国家遭受伊斯兰叛乱的困扰,此外还有数十个规模较小的冲突。最令人不安的是,国家间的战争再次出现,例如阿塞拜疆和亚美尼亚之间的战争,以色列和哈马斯之间的战争,以及俄罗斯对乌克兰的全面入侵。俄罗斯对乌克兰的入侵始于2014年吞并克里米亚和顿巴斯战争。2004年至2014年,基于国家冲突的死亡人数约为35万,2014年至2019年下降,2021年急剧上升,2014年至2024年总计约120万人死亡,若包含所有暴力冲突则高达150万人。2022年暴力冲突造成的死亡人数是自1994年卢旺达种族灭绝以来最高的,提格雷战争和乌克兰战争是造成大部分死亡人数的主要原因。从长远来看,我们仍然生活在一个相对和平的时代,但未来十年将决定这一趋势是否会逆转。国家间战争再次出现,我们之前的预测没有成立,但我们仍然处于相对和平的时期。世界上几乎所有武装冲突都发生在20世纪曾受外国占领的国家。民主国家之间没有发生战争,但越来越少的内战通过外交解决。大多数国际边界仍然存在,但仍存在一些领土争端,有些正在加剧。外部势力常常支持战争,例如沙特阿拉伯和伊朗之间的竞争,以及西方对乌克兰的支持和中俄伊朝对俄罗斯的支持。外部势力,包括伊斯兰极端组织、犯罪网络和地方精英,都可能延长冲突。冷战结束后,许多国家期待一个基于规则的世界秩序,但近年来这一秩序受到挑战。世界已成为多极化的,新的联盟正在形成,基于规则的世界秩序受到挑战,中国崛起为新的超级大国。中国有效军事预算已成为美国预算的相当一部分。俄罗斯对乌克兰的入侵打破了禁忌,欧洲开始重新武装,世界正朝着多极化发展。战争并没有结束,未来的走向并不乐观,但我们仍然处于相对和平的时期。获取可靠信息很重要,因为虚假信息和宣传被用作武器。Ground News可以帮助人们比较不同新闻来源的报道,从而获得更全面的视角。通过比较不同新闻来源的报道,可以更好地理解新闻事件的背景和影响。Ground News可以帮助人们识别虚假信息和宣传。Ground News提供个性化新闻订阅服务,帮助用户拓宽视野。Ground News提供工具帮助人们独立思考。我们推出了新的12025年人类纪历。人类纪历代表着我们共同历史的重要组成部分。人类纪历已成为许多人的年度传统和日常灵感来源。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

Ten years ago in 2014, we asked if war was over. Based on long-term trends in the last century, it seemed violent conflict was on the decline and the world more peaceful than ever. Our video began with the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the war between Hamas and Israel. And, well, a decade later, we could start this video exactly the same way. But is the world as a whole more violent today?

In a nutshell, we made seven claims in 2014.

1. We have less conflict deaths than ever. 2. There were almost no more wars between countries. 3. Democracies don't fight each other. 4. Borders are mostly fixed. 5. Most conflicts are in areas that were under foreign control either by colonial states or Soviet dictatorships. 6. More civil wars are ending by diplomacy. 7. We're in the most peaceful period of history.

So, let's see how our video has held up. First, let's get an overview of conflicts in the last decade. Some of the deadliest conflicts that were glowing hot in 2014 have since ended or significantly cooled down. The war in Afghanistan ended with the victory of the Taliban.

While the civil wars in Yemen and Libya are all still ongoing, they turned mostly into stalemates. The proto-state of ISIS in Iraq and Syria has been wiped out. And, breaking news, the rebels just won the war in Syria last week.

The extremely destructive civil war in South Sudan ended in a fragile peace agreement despite violence still flaring up in the devastated young country. Sadly, the last decade saw a bunch of new conflicts erupt or old unresolved issues turn violent. One of the main claims of our video 10 years ago was that wars today are not between countries and this is still largely true.

Civil wars are by far the most common type of state-based conflict in the world. We'd wager that most of you have never heard about one of the deadliest civil wars in decades, the 2020 Tigray War in Ethiopia. It ended in 2022 with the victory of the Ethiopian and Eritrean government forces against rebel groups. Exact death tolls are unknown, but they may exceed half a million, mostly civilians.

Aside from Tigray, a number of new civil wars have broken out since 2014. Although "new" is a bit misleading, since the underlying issues were brooding at a smaller scale for a long time. The deadliest have been the Sudan civil war, the civil war in Yemen, and the civil war in Myanmar.

Multiple nations in Africa like Mali, Nigeria, Somalia, Burkina Faso and Mozambique are suffering from Islamist insurgencies that destabilize countries and have cost tens of thousands of civilian lives. Lastly, there are nearly 60 smaller unresolved state-based conflicts around the world, many going on for decades, that are smoldering but have a relatively low death toll in comparison. Maybe the worst news is that we've been seeing interstate wars again.

There was the short-lived 2020 war between Azerbaijan and Armenia, which redrew contested borders. Then there's the latest war between Israel and Hamas that turned into a regional crisis. What is certainly the most disturbing new development is the full-scale invasion of Ukraine by Russia. It's the first large-scale interstate war in 20 years, and the first war since World War II where a major power is trying to conquer territory and to subjugate another state.

It followed an eight-year conflict that started with the 2014 Russian annexation of Crimea and the war in the Donbass. Exact casualty rates for the war since 2022 are hard to verify, but they go as high as hundreds of thousands.

Okay, so what about our 2014 claims? If we add up the numbers, we see a few things. Roughly between 2004 and 2014, there were about 350,000 deaths from state-based conflicts worldwide. They were going down from 2014 to 2019 and then rose sharply in 2021.

In total, from 2014 to 2024, we saw about 1.2 million deaths. If we include all violent conflicts like the Mexican drug war, the number rises to 1.5 million, three times higher than the previous decade. Actually, 2022 had the highest death toll from violent conflict since the Rwandan genocide in 1994.

The Tigray War and the war in Ukraine alone were responsible for the majority of lives lost, as both wars involved armies of hundreds of thousands of soldiers, sometimes thrown against entrenched positions in human wave attacks. So, the last three years have been unusually violent. But if we zoom out a bit more, we can put those numbers into perspective. A terrible thing, but nowhere near how bad it can get when the world goes to war.

In the grand scheme of things, we are still living in relatively peaceful times. But the next decade will show if the trend will reverse or if the last few years were an anomaly. Unfortunately, there have been "proper" wars between states again, so our prediction on wars between countries didn't hold up.

What is as true today as in 2014 is that almost all armed conflicts in the world are in countries that were under foreign occupation in the 20th century, either by colonialism or by the expansive Soviet dictatorship. Ethnic groups were split apart or forced together by arbitrary borders, resources unequally distributed, or power vacuums created, which led to conflicts that are in many cases still unresolved.

There have also been no wars between democracies who seem uniquely unwilling to fight each other. So compared to the last century, it's still true that war between nations is still an exception rather than the rule. On the other hand, we see fewer civil wars end by diplomacy. Instead, there's an increase in either victories or stalemates. These often aren't permanent resolutions to the conflict, only pauses in the fighting, because the underlying causes haven't been solved.

For our claim about borders, we can see that most international borders in the world still hold up and are not challenged, but there are still a few dozen territorial disputes in the world, most of them in Africa and Asia. And some are getting hotter, like the border clash between India and China over Aksai Chin and Arunachal Pradesh. China's claim to Taiwan or Venezuela threatening to annex part of Guyana's oil-rich province Essequibo.

One thing that makes wars so deadly is that they're often supported by external powers. Many countries are providing support or arming up different sides or factions. Like the competition between Saudi Arabia and Iran for hegemony, with Iran being the main supporter for the Houthis,

Hezbollah or Hamas. Or in the Ukrainian war, with the West supporting Ukraine, while China, Iran and North Korea support Russia. But it's not just countries. External powers keeping conflicts alive can also be Islamist groups like ISIS or criminal networks. Or even local elites that benefit from their own country being torn apart and effectively prevent conflicts from ending. The end of the rules-based world.

There's a lot of debate among experts about what factors make the world more or less peaceful, but there are no easy answers. One of the major reasons the world has seen less conflict was that after the end of the Cold War, many countries expected a sort of rules-based world order. And for a time, this worked somewhat.

But things have been changing in the last few years. The world has become multipolar with new alliances forming and the idea of a rules-based world is being challenged. China's manufacturing capacity is now as big as the US and Europe's combined. With its massive economic development, a new superpower has risen. It's common knowledge that the US spends more on its military than any place in the world, but this may no longer reflect the true balance of power.

China doesn't report all of its military spending like the US does, and it gets a lot more done with each equivalent dollar spent. Recent estimates trying to account for these differences tell us China's effective military budget is now a significant portion of the United States' budget.

And with Russia breaking the taboo of launching the first war of conquest by a major power in almost 80 years, Europe has begun the process of rearming. It is slow because, well, Europe is slow, but it is happening. We're in the transition to a multipolar world again, with different nations and alliances claiming spheres of power they want to dominate. In this climate, tensions and conflicts between states have been rising, even if most of them have not turned into wars yet.

So, is war over? The clear answer is no. And the direction we're headed in doesn't seem great. But with all the gloom, it's also true that we are still in a peaceful period of world history and that deaths by war are still at historic lows. The world is at a crossroads. We'll do another update video in 2034. Let's all hope we'll have better news for you then.

Getting reliable information is hard enough, but it gets impossible to know what you can believe when misinformation and propaganda are used as yet another weapon in armed conflicts. It's important to seek nuanced and diverse perspectives, which is why Ground News, who's kindly sponsoring this video, is so important.

In a nutshell, the app and website gather the world's news in one place so you can compare coverage, see the bigger picture, and make informed decisions. Take the reporting on Russia's and North Korea's recent defense treaty. There are hundreds of headlines on this globally, including from many sources on the ground like Korea and Russia. Some report it as a defense deal, others call it an alliance or strategic partnership, which creates very different images.

The interesting insight is how most of the sources are government-affiliated, which presumably affects their choice of framing. Reading the news this way lets you compare different perspectives in one place, see how narratives and possibly public opinion could change.

You also get a sense of the bigger picture and how much weight a story really carries to tell apart reason from racket. Go to ground.news/kin or scan the QR code to check it out. With their Vantage plan, you can even keep yourself in check.

For example, your personalized My News Buyers dashboard gives you insights about your potential blind spots and enables you to broaden your perspectives by actively seeking information outside your typical sources. Sign up through this QR code or our link below for 50% off this unlimited access plan. It's their biggest discount of the year, whether for yourself or as a gift. We think they're doing an important job, especially today.

Check them out to get the tools to think for yourself.

The new 12025 Human Era Calendar is finally here. We think it's the best calendar we ever made and we created it all for you. It's not just the vibrant illustrations, the high quality paper or the shiny cover, it's the fact that it represents such an important part of our shared history. We hope that you'll use it to continue writing history and we know that it will look great on your wall or as a gift for a special burb in your life.

As you've told us in hundreds of reviews, comments and messages, the calendar is very special to you too. For so many of you, getting the Human Era Calendar has become a yearly tradition and a daily source of inspiration. Make 12,025 truly special and join us in celebrating this time-honored tradition. The calendar is available exclusively on our shop. We've also prepared a few bundles with some of our favorite products. Get this piece of our shared history and

an essential part of Kurzgesagt.