We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 声生不息·大湾区季:情怀拉满的港乐季2.0,再将好歌献给你!

声生不息·大湾区季:情怀拉满的港乐季2.0,再将好歌献给你!

2024/12/8
logo of podcast 硬核说

硬核说

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
a
ad
阿甘
Topics
阿甘:本节目延续了港乐季的成功,在嘉宾阵容、舞台制作、题材选择和歌曲选择上都有提升,但与第一季相比,后续的宝岛季和嘉年华季质量有所下降。港乐曾辉煌一时,如今相对没落,大众对港乐的了解有限,节目对港乐的挖掘具有意义。芒果台在国内音乐综艺制作方面处于领先地位,舞台设计和声光效果出色,节目选取经典港片OST,引发全民回忆。 节目中,谭咏麟的开场表演精彩,展现了港乐黄金时代的辉煌,也表达了对张国荣、陈百强、梅艳芳等巨星的致敬。陈慧娴和梅艳芳的世纪大和解令人感动。回春丹的《头发乱了》改编独特,方力申的《浪漫樱花》勾起回忆。李宇春的表演虽然粤语略有隔阂,但舞台魅力十足。其他歌手的表演也各有千秋,但整体而言,第一期节目更注重情怀的表达。 第二期节目以香港电影OST为主题,开场交响乐团的演奏和电影片段剪辑令人震撼,但节目中出现了一些错误,例如将电影《流水落花》的片名写错,以及将《暴风女神》的来源电影错误标注为《飞鹰计划2之龙兄虎弟》,这些细节上的错误影响了节目的整体观感。 ad:方力申的主持表现超出预期,普通话流利。阮兆祥和李思捷主持的《声生不息港咪嘢》单元,分享港乐和香港文化知识,第二期关于龙虎武师的内容做得很好。节目中也探讨了港人北上消费的现象,引发了对香港经济和文化现状的思考。 在歌手方面,谭咏麟的表演依旧精彩,展现了其强大的舞台掌控力和感染力。陈慧娴和梅艳芳的歌曲串烧,以及与谭咏麟合唱的《讲不出再见》,都非常经典。其他歌手的表演也各有特点,但整体而言,第二期节目在歌曲选择和舞台呈现上略逊于第一期。节目中出现的一些错误,例如电影片名和歌曲来源的错误标注,以及对一些电影的评价,都反映了节目组在细节处理上的不足。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did the hosts decide to focus on the 'Sheng Sheng Bu Xi: Greater Bay Area Season' after skipping previous seasons?

The hosts skipped the 'Treasure Island Season' and 'Carnival Season' because they felt those seasons lacked the star power and cultural depth of the first 'Hong Kong Music Season.' The Greater Bay Area Season, however, brought back the nostalgia and grandeur of Hong Kong music, with a strong lineup of artists and a focus on the 50-year history of Cantopop, making it more compelling to cover.

What makes the 'Sheng Sheng Bu Xi: Greater Bay Area Season' stand out in terms of production quality?

The season stands out due to its use of a four-sided stage, immersive lighting, and high-quality sound design, which rivals top-tier concerts. The integration of film clips during performances enhances the emotional impact, creating a cinematic experience. Additionally, the show benefits from government support, allowing for a lavish production budget.

How did the hosts describe the significance of the '80s Hong Kong music scene in the show?

The hosts highlighted the '80s as the golden era of Hong Kong music, featuring iconic artists like Leslie Cheung, Anita Mui, and Alan Tam. The show pays tribute to this period by revisiting classic songs and exploring the intense rivalry between Alan Tam and Leslie Cheung, known as the 'Tam-Cheung Feud,' which shaped the Cantopop landscape.

What was the emotional impact of Alan Tam's performance in the first episode?

Alan Tam's performance was deeply moving, as he sang Leslie Cheung's 'The Wind Blows On' and Danny Chan's 'A Lifetime of Asking.' His ability to convey emotion despite his age resonated with the audience, evoking nostalgia for the '80s Hong Kong music scene. The inclusion of Leslie Cheung's archival footage added to the emotional weight of the performance.

Why did the hosts criticize the second episode's handling of the film 'Raging Fire'?

The hosts criticized the second episode for incorrectly labeling 'Raging Fire' as 'Project Eagle 2: Armour of God,' which is factually inaccurate. This error showed a lack of attention to detail and historical context, especially in a show that aims to honor Hong Kong's cultural legacy. Such mistakes undermined the credibility of the tribute.

What was the hosts' opinion on the adaptation of classic songs in the show?

The hosts appreciated the fresh takes on classic songs, such as the band Re-TROS's psychedelic rock version of 'Hair in Disorder.' They emphasized the importance of innovation in keeping these songs relevant, while also acknowledging that some adaptations, like Li Yiting's softer rendition of 'Grey Trajectory,' fell short of the original's intensity.

Chapters
本期节目主要讨论了《声生不息·大湾区季》的节目内容、嘉宾阵容和舞台效果,并与前四季进行了比较。节目制作精良,舞台效果出色,嘉宾阵容强大,但主题相对集中在港乐方面。
  • 节目在芒果TV独家播出
  • 节目时长101分钟
  • 节目嘉宾包括谭咏麟、陈慧娴、周慧敏等
  • 舞台采用四面台形式

Shownotes Transcript

诚意制作感谢收听本期节目时长:101分钟本期节目录制主播:阿甘、ad进群加:jackielygt本期节目关键时间轴如下:00:00  开场与本期节目缘起,讨论《声生不息》系列综艺每季的长短处09:40 《声生不息大湾区季》信息简介与主持人介绍:方力申,阮兆祥,李思捷,以及节目子单元《声生不息港咪嘢》18:20  谭咏麟第一期开场环节点评28:00  80年代港乐三王一后张国荣,陈百强,梅艳芳致敬环节点评42:20  回春丹《头发乱了》,方力申《芭啦芭啦樱之花》,陈小春《相依为命》,李宇春《今夜你会不会来》,卫兰《她整晚在写信》,薛凯琪《离开以后》56:05  李昊,黄子弘凡点评,古巨基点评70:20  第二期香港电影ost开场点评以及节目中的谬误吐槽84:30  李治廷《岁月神偷》,陈小春队《无间道》,薛凯琪、周笔畅《TheWayYouMakeMeFeel》,陈小春《蝶变》,容祖儿《终身美丽》点评94:00  《暴风女神》点评与节目收尾