We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 849: The Narrator

849: The Narrator

2024/12/15
logo of podcast This American Life

This American Life

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
H
Hannah Jaffe-Walt
Topics
Banias: 作为叙述者,Banias主要讲述了她日常生活的细节,包括玩耍、游戏、与朋友相处等,很少直接提及战争的残酷。她展现出超乎年龄的成熟和对生活的热爱,即使在面临撤离等困境时,也保持着乐观的态度。她对战争的认知较为简单,将战争视为敌对双方的对抗,并受到周围环境的影响,例如庆祝伊朗对以色列的导弹袭击。 Hannah Jaffe-Walt: 记者试图了解战争对Banias的影响,但她更关注日常琐事。Banias的叙述与成年人的叙述不同,展现了孩子独特的视角。她对战争的关注度有限,更关注日常琐事。记者试图从战争的角度解读Banias的生活,但Banias却试图从日常生活的角度来讲述她的故事。 Maram Humeid: 作为Banias的母亲,Maram解释了Banias对战争的看法,以及她自身在战争中的经历。她表示Banias的乐观和积极是她在残酷环境中生存的方式。她对女儿在面对战争时的反应表示理解,并指出Banias的乐观和积极是她在残酷环境中生存的方式。她还谈到了自己童年时期在战争中的经历,以及对加沙儿童持续性创伤的担忧。 Banias: Banias的叙述充满了细节,展现了她对周围环境的敏锐观察力。她用生动的语言描述了自己的日常生活,包括玩耍、游戏、与朋友相处等。即使在面临撤离等困境时,她也保持着乐观的态度,并试图用积极的方式来应对战争带来的压力。她对战争的认知较为简单,将战争视为敌对双方的对抗,并受到周围环境的影响,例如庆祝伊朗对以色列的导弹袭击。 Hannah Jaffe-Walt: 记者的叙述视角是客观的,她记录了Banias的日常生活,以及她对战争的看法。她试图理解战争对Banias的影响,并通过与Banias的对话,展现了战争对儿童心理和生活造成的伤害。她还采访了Banias的母亲和心理学家,从多个角度探讨了战争对儿童的影响。 Maram Humeid: Maram的叙述主要集中在Banias的情绪和心理状态上,以及她对战争的看法。她解释了Banias为什么很少提及战争,以及她如何应对战争带来的压力。她还分享了自己在战争中的经历,以及对加沙儿童持续性创伤的担忧。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Banias take the phone from her mother during the initial call with the reporter?

Banias took the phone because she wanted to narrate her own life and share her experiences, showing a natural confidence and a desire to be heard.

Why are children in Gaza not allowed to leave the war zone?

Children in Gaza are not allowed to leave the war zone because they are displaced inside Gaza, stuck in the violence and with their families in crowded rooms or tents.

Why does Banias prefer to talk about her daily activities rather than the war?

Banias prefers to talk about her daily activities because she is more interested in her immediate experiences and games, and she uses these topics to create a sense of normalcy and control in her life.

Why did Banias and her family not move into a tent when they received the evacuation order?

Banias and her family decided not to move into a tent because the dangers of moving could be worse than staying in their current location, where they had some semblance of safety and shelter.

Why does Banias celebrate when she hears about attacks on Israel?

Banias celebrates when she hears about attacks on Israel because she views Israel as an enemy that has caused harm to her and her community, reflecting the complex and traumatic environment she lives in.

Why does Dr. Iman Farajallah argue against using PTSD to describe the condition of children in Gaza?

Dr. Iman Farajallah argues against using PTSD to describe the condition of children in Gaza because the trauma is continuous and ongoing, with no post-traumatic phase for recovery, and children are in a constant state of coping.

Why did Banias and her family move to a new apartment a couple of miles from Derbala?

Banias and her family moved to a new apartment because it was less crowded, offered more privacy, and was a temporary but quieter place, even though it is not their home.

Why is the Netzerim Corridor significant in the context of the conflict in Gaza?

The Netzerim Corridor is significant because it is a militarized zone that cuts across Gaza, separating the north from the south, preventing people from returning to their homes, and raising concerns of ethnic cleansing or genocide.

Shownotes Transcript

Banias is an 8-year-old kid living in Gaza. And she has a story to tell — many stories, in fact.

Visit thisamericanlife.org/lifepartners) to sign up for our premium subscription.

  • Prologue: While on the phone with reporter Maram Hamaid in Gaza, producer Chana Joffe-Walt gets interrupted by Maram’s daughter––Banias, eight, who grabs the phone from her mother and starts telling us about her life. The narrator arrives. (8 minutes)
  • Part One: Banias, an 8-year-old in Gaza, tells us about her life––her friends, the games she plays, the things she cares about. Everything but the war going on around her. (25 minutes)
  • Part Two: Banias talks about the war. (20 minutes)

Transcripts are available at thisamericanlife.org)

This American Life privacy policy.)Learn more about sponsor message choices.)