We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Here's Why Trump's Executive Orders Have Limits

Here's Why Trump's Executive Orders Have Limits

2025/1/24
logo of podcast Here's Why

Here's Why

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Adriana Lowenkron
Topics
Adriana Lowenkron: 我认为行政命令是具有法律约束力的指令,它们指导各机构如何执行现有的联邦法律。但是,至关重要的是,行政命令的合法性取决于其是否与国会通过的法律相符。如果行政命令与现行法律相抵触,它可以被法律挑战,甚至被法院宣布为非法。行政命令不能用来赋予行政部门超越现有法律的权力,也不能绕过国会立法这一既定的权力制衡机制。行政命令的效力,取决于其是否是对现有法律的合理解读,而不是创造新的法律或权力。 行政命令可以被那些直接受其影响的个人或团体提出法律挑战。例如,针对特朗普总统试图终止出生公民权的行政命令,移民团体已经提起诉讼。法院将根据法律依据来裁决该命令是否与现行法律或宪法相抵触。 国会虽然不能直接推翻行政命令,但可以通过立法来削弱行政部门执行命令的能力,从而构成对行政命令的制衡。 总统在就职第一天签署大量行政命令的情况并不少见,尤其是在总统与前任总统来自不同政党的情况下,这通常是为了推翻前任总统的政策。然而,这种做法也容易受到批评,因为它可能被视为一种临时性的、容易被撤销的议程推进方式,并且可能绕过传统的权力制衡机制。 如果总统的政党在国会没有多数席位,总统可能会更多地依赖行政命令来推动其政治议程。这种做法也招致批评,因为它被认为绕过了美国体制中由国会负责制定法律的传统权力制衡机制。因此,行政命令的有效性和合法性,关键在于其必须是对现有法律的解释,而不是创造新的权力。

Deep Dive

Chapters
Executive orders are legally binding mandates that direct agencies on implementing existing federal law. They are limited; they cannot grant the executive branch additional power or create new laws, only interpret and carry out existing ones. They can be challenged in court if deemed inconsistent with congressional statutes.
  • Executive orders are legally binding mandates.
  • They direct agencies on implementing existing federal law.
  • They cannot grant the executive branch additional power.
  • They can be challenged in court if inconsistent with congressional statutes.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

With Amex Business Platinum, your dental clinic can really sparkle. With a flexible spending limit that adapts with your business, that's the powerful backing of American Express. Not all purchases will be approved. Terms apply. Learn more at americanexpress.com slash amexbusiness. Your customers are important to you, but they won't feel that way if they're messaging a clunky chatbot or waiting on hold. Please hold. Estimated wait time is 25 minutes.

Now you can deploy a Sierra AI agent to delight customers and solve tough problems in real time. Always friendly. Always helpful. Always ready. Visit Sierra.ai to learn more. That's Sierra.ai. Bloomberg Audio Studios. Podcasts. Radio. News.

I'm Stephen Carroll and this is Here's Why, where we take one news story and explain it in just a few minutes with our experts here at Bloomberg. Donald Trump started his presidency with a bang. Today I will sign a series of historic executive orders. With these actions we will begin the complete restoration of America and the revolution of common sense. The next item here is the withdrawal from the Paris Climate Treaty.

He signed dozens of executive orders, some in front of a crowd of thousands at the Capital One Arena in Washington, and others with reporters watching on in the Oval Office. They covered everything from energy to immigration to withdrawing the United States from the World Health Organization. But here's why Trump's executive orders have limits.

Our White House reporter, Adriana Lowenkron, joins me now for more. Adriana, first of all, what can executive orders be used for? Adriana Lowenkron

Well, essentially, executive orders are really legally binding mandates, and essentially they direct the agencies on how to implement existing federal law. So this is an important distinction. An executive order only is legal, and of course it can be challenged, and we'll get into that later, if it's consistent with the law that Congress has passed.

OK, so my logical next question then is what can't executive orders be used for? They can't be used to essentially give the executive branch additional power. So this is not their opportunity to try to pass a new law and kind of skirt the current system of checks and balances that we have, which is that Congress has the authority to pass the laws. So this is for them to really interpret

the law that has already been given and carry out that to the agencies. And again, they can really be sued and declared illegal by courts if someone affected by that order challenges it and the court says it is inconsistent with a congressional statute. So let's get into some of those potential challenges then, or maybe checks and balances, we could describe them on executive orders.

How can these orders be challenged? If there is an individual or a party who is directly affected by an order, for example,

One of President Trump's executive orders is an attempt to end birthright citizenship. So in the immigrant community, they have the ability to file a lawsuit. In this instance, one immigration group already has filed a lawsuit on Monday evening challenging the order. And the courts can take it up if they agree that there is legal ground. And essentially,

can decide that the order is inconsistent with the current law in place or what the Constitution says. What about Congress? Does it have a role in checking these sort of executive orders?

So Congress can't overrule whatever the executive order is, but it can undermine the executive branch by then later on passing their own legislation that makes the execution of the order difficult or even impossible. So if there's a new program or an audit,

We've talked about this long list of executive orders that Donald Trump signed on his first day. Is it normal for a president to do something like that, sign so many executive orders in just the first day? Absolutely.

Absolutely. There really has been a tendency for presidents to issue this flurry that we're seeing. And particularly when a president comes into office and it's part of a different party than the previous

holder of office, which we're seeing here. And that's because a number of the day one actions is actually reversing the actions that their predecessors had ordered. This is something that goes back and forth depending on who is in the executive office and as such has garnered some criticism for being too easily revoked

and a temporary way to pass an agenda. Well, let's talk a bit more about those criticisms. This isn't necessarily a universally liked instrument of governing.

Right. And sometimes there's a tendency for presidents to focus on executive action if their party doesn't have a majority in Congress and they are unable to get legislation passed through that system. So there has been some criticism for this idea that this is the way to get the agenda passed.

skirting the traditional checks and balances of the U.S. system in which, you know, Congress is supposed to be the branch responsible for making the laws. So the criticism comes from, you know, it being temporary, it flipping back and forth, and also this idea that kind of skirts the checks and balances. But again, the importance here in terms of whether the executive orders can be properly done and legally work

is they have to be the interpretation of current law. It can't be a new power. It can't be something that is not already existing as a congressional statute. Okay, Adriana Lowenkron, our White House reporter, thank you very much for joining us. For more explanations like this from our team of 2,900 journalists and analysts around the world, search for Quick Take on the Bloomberg website or Bloomberg Business app.

I'm Stephen Carroll. This is Here's Why. I'll be back next week with more. Thanks for listening.

In 15th century Florence, the great inventor Leonardo da Vinci dreamt of creating a flying machine. But something kept getting in his way. Admin. Piles of it. Luckily, Leo used the smart buying tools on Amazon Business, so he could work more efficiently. With the extra time, he not only invented the flying machine, but actually built it. Magnifico. Incredibile. Splendido. Whoa, easy there, Leo. Splendido.

Amazon Business, your partner for smart business buying. Dreamed of exploring the world? Road Scholar invites you to turn that dream into reality. As a leader in educational travel for adults 50 and older, Road Scholar offers enriching adventures in more than 100 countries and across the United States. With Road Scholar, you're not a tourist. You're an active learner, immersed in inspiring experiences. To learn more, visit roadscholar.com.

RhodesScholar.org slash Discover25. Rhodes Scholar, celebrating 50 years of learning, adventure, and friendship in 2025.