We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Vol.15《卡片笔记写作法》:其实我们不会做读书笔记

Vol.15《卡片笔记写作法》:其实我们不会做读书笔记

2024/3/12
logo of podcast 人生B面

人生B面

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
洛优
飞扬
Topics
洛优:我之前的读书笔记方式很原始,只是在书上划线,在本子上写评论或摘抄,或者用Notion将纸质笔记电子化,但笔记的形式和内容没有本质变化。这些笔记最终变成了一个‘坟场’,很难被利用。读完《卡片笔记写作法》后,我意识到之前的读书笔记方法并不能让我有效地利用知识,而卡片笔记法可以建立知识之间的连接,让我更容易地提取和使用知识。 飞扬:我多年的笔记积累也成了‘思想坟场’,即使使用Notion,也陷入了无限延展的迷宫,很少真正利用笔记。卢曼卡片盒笔记法能将笔记转化为知识集群,为写作做准备。它具有原子性、知识的可见性和信息的可传递性,可以打破时空限制,让知识库连接起来,方便提取信息。 通过实践,我发现卡片盒笔记法能改变思考方式,重塑思考模型和思维方式。Obsidian 通过双向链接解决了笔记之间独立的问题,实现了笔记的串联。卡片盒笔记法需要学习方法论并坚持实践,才能建立知识网络。使用卡片盒笔记法需要循序渐进,先理解方法论和软件,再逐步实践,最终形成庞大的知识网络。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What are the three types of notes in the Zettelkasten (card box) note-taking method?

The three types of notes in the Zettelkasten method are: 1) Fleeting Notes, which capture spontaneous ideas and should be organized within a day or two; 2) Literature Notes, which include summaries and personal thoughts on the content of books or articles, written in one's own language; and 3) Permanent Notes, which are concise and derived from Fleeting and Literature Notes, serving as the foundation for future writing and ideas.

Why is the Zettelkasten method considered superior to traditional note-taking?

The Zettelkasten method is superior because it emphasizes atomicity, visibility, and transferability of knowledge. Each note is a minimal unit of knowledge, making it easy to combine and reuse for various topics. The method ensures that knowledge is visible and easily retrievable, with clear references and context. It also allows for the transfer of knowledge across time, preventing notes from becoming 'graveyards of thought' and enabling future use.

How does the Zettelkasten method change the way people think and process information?

The Zettelkasten method changes thinking by encouraging a bottom-up approach to knowledge organization. Instead of starting with a predefined structure, it allows ideas to emerge naturally from the connections between notes. This method also promotes active engagement with information, as users must break down and internalize content, leading to deeper understanding and more meaningful connections between ideas.

What challenges do users face when adopting the Zettelkasten method?

Users often face challenges such as the high initial learning curve, the complexity of organizing and linking notes, and the difficulty of maintaining consistency. Many struggle with transitioning from traditional note-taking methods to the Zettelkasten system, especially when it comes to breaking down information into atomic units and establishing meaningful connections between notes.

How does Obsidian software enhance the Zettelkasten method?

Obsidian enhances the Zettelkasten method by providing a digital platform for creating bidirectional links between notes. This feature allows users to easily connect related ideas and build a web of knowledge, overcoming the limitations of physical note cards. Obsidian also supports the atomicity and visibility of notes, making it easier to manage and retrieve information over time.

Chapters
两位主持人分享了自己原始的读书笔记方法,并探讨了Notion等工具在提升笔记效率上的局限性,指出这些工具只改变了存储方式,并未改变信息形态。
  • 传统的读书笔记方法停留在划线、摘抄等原始阶段,难以有效利用信息。
  • Notion等工具提升了笔记存储效率,但并未解决信息形态问题,笔记仍然难以有效利用。
  • 读书笔记的根本问题在于信息形态,而非存储方式。

Shownotes Transcript

读书时是不是喜欢在句子下划划线,在空白地方写写评论,就没有然后了?遇到喜欢的文章、视频,是不是收藏完就在文件夹吃灰了?

第十五期,让我们一起来聊聊做笔记时踩的坑,以及如何做面前「未来」得读书笔记。

00:40 你会做读书笔记吗?

04:50 卢曼卡片盒笔记法

07:30 卡片盒笔记法的优势

09:15 卡片盒笔记法带来的启发与思考 

推荐阅读:

《卡片笔记写作法》[德]申克·阿伦斯