We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 哪些建议看似有益实则“有毒”?可以大众但不能从众...

哪些建议看似有益实则“有毒”?可以大众但不能从众...

2024/11/3
logo of podcast 一席英语·脱口秀:老外来了

一席英语·脱口秀:老外来了

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
F
Flora
Topics
Flora和Erin讨论了生活中一些看似积极,实则可能造成负面影响的常见建议。他们认为“做你自己”这一建议忽略了自我认知和对他人的尊重的重要性,片面理解可能会误导人们;“做出点成绩来让他们看看”这一心态可能导致人们以寻求外部认可为目标,而非真正为自身价值而努力;“明明有值得高兴的一切,为什么要难过呢?”这种说法忽略了情绪的复杂性,试图用理性压抑负面情绪可能会适得其反;“跟随你的激情”这一建议可能过于理想化,忽略了现实的职业稳定性和经济保障;“失败不是选项”这一说法不切实际,人们应该将失败视为学习和成长的一部分。 Erin 则补充了对这些建议的批判性思考,并提出了更健康、更现实的应对方法。她强调个人成长需要自我提升,而非仅仅接受现状;成功的动力应源于自身,而非外部认可;情绪是复杂且有效的,需要被承认和处理,而非被忽视;职业规划需要在追求兴趣和现实之间取得平衡;失败是不可避免的,也是学习的一部分。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

为什么说‘做你自己’这句话可能是有毒的建议?

这句话忽略了前提,即你已经建立了自我意识和对他人的尊重。它暗示任何时候的你自己都是完美的,而忽视了个人成长中的改进和转变。片面理解这句话可能会让人误入歧途,因为它没有鼓励自我提升。

为什么‘做出点什么让他们看看’这种建议可能是有害的?

如果你的动力仅仅是为了向别人证明自己,那么你的成功并不是真正为了自己。这种心态可能会让你忽视自己的内在动机,导致成功变得空洞。更健康的做法是追求自己的目标,因为它们对你有意义,而不是为了报复或证明别人是错的。

为什么‘明明有值得高兴的一切,为什么要难过呢?’这句话可能是有问题的?

这句话贬低了别人的情绪,暗示外部环境应该控制你的情绪。情绪并不是可以被理性化的,它们是自然的反应,值得被承认和处理。忽视或不尊重自己的真实感受只会积累更多问题。

为什么‘跟随你的激情’这句话可能是有误导性的?

并不是每个人的热情都与稳定的职业生涯或技能相一致,这可能导致挫折。追求激情固然好,但有时更实际的做法是找到一个既能满足兴趣又能兼顾收入和工作前景的平衡点。

为什么‘没有失败这个选项’这种说法可能是不现实的?

失败是几乎不可避免的,试图假装它不存在不仅不现实,也不会增加成功的几率。接受失败作为学习过程的一部分,反而能帮助你更好地应对挫折,并从中成长。

Chapters
本节讨论了流行建议“做你自己”的局限性。它指出,只有在具备自我认知和对他人的尊重的前提下,这一建议才有效。片面理解可能会误导人们,更好的建议是追求“最好的自己”。
  • 盲目'做自己'可能忽略自我提升
  • 建议应建立在自我认知和尊重他人的基础上
  • '做最好的自己'比'做自己'更实际

Shownotes Transcript

 主播:Flora(中国)+ Erin(美国)  歌曲: I Count on Me 今天我们要聊一个非常有趣并且比较深刻的话题,关于一些看似流行但其实可以被视为toxic (有毒) 的建议。 Today, we’re unpacking some of these popular “toxic” suggestions and exploring a healthier, more realistic way (更健康、更现实的方法) to approach them.  This isn’t to say all advice is bad (并不是说所有的建议都是不好的), but it’s crucial to recognize when advice doesn’t quite apply to your own situation.  01. “Just be yourself.” 做你自己。

It sounds positive. 但是这句话省略了一个非常重要的premise(前提)that is you’re already self-aware and respectful of others (你建立了自我意识和对他人的尊重). The problem with this advice is that it implies any version of yourself is perfect (任何时候的你自己都是完美的) just as it is. But personal growth is about identifying areas where we can improve, not just accepting everything at face value (从表面上看). Growth is about learning, progress and transformation (转变) and going beyond yourself. 片面地理解这句话可能会lead you astray (让你误入歧途)。 So, instead of using “be yourself” as a blanket excuse, think of it as “be the best version of yourself (做最好的自己).” Ask yourself, “Am I truly living up to my potential (发挥了我的潜力吗)? Is this really my best self?” 02. “Show them what they’re missing.” 做出点什么让他们看看。

This is the idea of proving others wrong by showing them you can succeed. 但是如果你的动力是建立在向别人证明自己的基础上,actually the mindset can become toxic. If your motivation is solely to get validation (仅仅是为得到认可) or prove something to others, then your success isn’t really for you (你的成功不是真正为了自己), is it? Live for yourself, guys. If you think their assertions (断言) are ridiculous and toxic, just stay away from them. Not all people are careful with their words (审慎发言), but you don't have to take responsibility for their mistakes. 一种更健康的说法是“Achieve your goals because they matter to you, not as a form of revenge or validation.” Let your accomplishments be something that fulfills you—not something that proves a point (而不是证明观点的东西). 03. “Why are you sad? You have everything to be happy about.” 明明有值得高兴的一切,为什么要难过呢?

Flora thinks, to a certain extent, the person who said it is demeaning other people's emotions (贬低别人的情绪). Because no one can fully empathize with someone else (完全感同身受), we never have the right to judge how they really feel. It implies that external circumstances should control your emotions (意味着外部环境应该控制着你的情绪). 但是情绪并不是这样运作的。This kind of advice can make people feel ashamed of their sadness. But it’s just a natural emotion. So don’t ignore and disrespect your true feelings. We should recognize that it’s okay to feel down even if things seem fine on the surface. Emotions aren’t something you can rationalize away (合理化)—they’re valid and deserve to be acknowledged (值得被承认). Instead “Allow yourself to feel what you feel without judgment. Acknowledge it and give yourself the space to work through it.” Then your emotions feel taken care of. Sometimes you think that ignoring your emotions will save you more time, when in reality it will only accumulate more problems (积累更多的问题). 04. “Follow your passion.” 跟随你的激情。

Sounds good, right? But sometimes, this advice can actually be misleading (误导性的). Flora has heard a lot of successful entrepreneurs say this. It’s often well-intentioned (出于好意的) but it always seems like the reason why people find this quote valid isn't because all those who follow passion can be successful, it's that those who follow passion and aren't successful don't have a voice (而是那些追随激情而不成功的人没有发言权). 并不是每个人的热情都与一个stable career(稳定的职业生涯)或他们的技能相一致,这可能会导致很多frustration(挫折)。 Pursuing your interests is great, but sometimes it’s more practical to look for a balance—finding a job that’s fulfilling but also realistic in terms of earning potential and job prospects (收入潜力和工作前景). 梦想和热忱是要有的,但也要建立在生活的基础之上。

Sometimes we discover new passions while working in a field. You might start out in something practical, and then realize you love certain aspects of it that you wouldn’t have considered otherwise (意识到你喜欢某些你不会考虑的方面). This gives you the chance to enjoy what you do while also having stability (稳定).“Life is like a box of chocolates, you never know what you’re going to get.”

Maybe what you felt was against your heart is exactly what you love. There are some things that you don't appreciate until you do them. 有些领域是真正接触后才会感受到它的魅力。所以关键就在于你有没有真正踏实去做。 So, rather than blindly following passion, maybe the better advice would be to find purpose in what you do and keep space for personal growth outside of work too (也为工作之外的个人成长留空间). You might find a mix of stability and interest that actually works better in the long run (把兴趣和稳定性相结合才是长远之计). 05. “Failure is not an option.” 没有失败这个选项。

没有失败这个选项,也就是只许成功不许失败了。听起来有一种破釜沉舟的决心。 It sounds so determined and tough (坚定而强硬), but if we’re honest, failure is almost always an option—and often the most available one. Flora doesn't believe there should be anyone in the world who hasn't had a failure. Failure is something that is so common that if we don't allow ourselves to experience it, then it can be a huge blow (巨大的打击) to you when it does happen. 因为你假设自己能够成功但是却没有为失败做任何准备。

As Steven Crowder once said, failure is usually “the easiest and most readily available option.” Trying to pretend it doesn’t exist just isn’t realistic (试图假装它不存在是不现实的), and it doesn’t make you any more likely to succeed (这也不会让你更有可能成功). A better way to look at it might be, “Failure is likely, but the odds of success increase when you try (失败很有可能,但如果你尝试,成功的几率会增加).” Flora also has a favorite quote that is very similar to this one: the opposite of success is not failure, it's doing nothing (成功的反面不是失败,而是什么都不做). 总之也是鼓励大家不要惧怕失败,只要尝试就会有成功的可能。

Accepting failure as part of the process can actually be motivating. When you recognize that success often takes multiple tries (成功往往需要多次尝试), failure just becomes part of the learning curve, not some terrible end. Knowing this will bring you closer to the truth, rather than being deceived by the lies you create (被自己的谎言欺骗). And that’s a mindset shift that helps. It turns failure into something manageable, rather than something you avoid at all costs (而不是一些你不惜一切代价避免的东西). So, next time you hear popular advice, take a moment to consider how it applies to you. Just because advice sounds good doesn’t mean it’s always good.

Popular advice may be very eye-catching (引人注目的), but it may not always be right for you (不一定是适合你的). That’s the key—make sure advice aligns with your values and goals. It’s okay to question (质疑) what you hear and even to reject advice if it doesn’t feel right for you. 树立自己良好的values(价值观)会让我们更有判断力,不会人云亦云、随波逐流。 Remember, the best guide for your life is your own informed perspective (你自己的知情视角). Thanks for joining today! Until next time, keep thinking, keep questioning.