Episode 628: The Murder of Nancy Evans Titterton
Morbid
Deep Dive
Why was Nancy Titterton's murder considered a significant case in the history of forensic science?
Nancy Titterton's murder was significant because it marked an early example of science and law enforcement working together to solve a seemingly unsolvable case. The use of forensic techniques, such as fingerprint analysis and the identification of unique fibers, played a crucial role in identifying the killer.
What was the key piece of evidence that linked John Fiorenza to the murder of Nancy Titterton?
The key piece of evidence was a single horsehair found on Nancy's bedspread, which matched the horsehair used in the upholstery of the love seat delivered on the day of the murder. This suggested that Fiorenza had the horsehair on him during the assault, linking him directly to the crime.
How did detectives initially narrow down their suspects in the Nancy Titterton murder case?
Detectives initially focused on four painters working in the building and Theodore Kruger, the upholsterer who delivered the love seat. Fingerprints found in the apartment were traced to these individuals, but alibis and further investigation cleared them as suspects.
What role did the cord found in the bathtub play in solving the case?
The cord found in the bathtub was traced to the Hanover Cordage Company, which identified it as a type commonly used in upholstery. This led detectives to Theodore Kruger's upholstery shop, where John Fiorenza worked, ultimately pointing to him as the prime suspect.
Why did John Fiorenza's defense team attempt to argue that he was insane during the trial?
Fiorenza's defense team argued insanity to avoid the death penalty, as a guilty verdict for a sane person would result in execution. They presented evidence of his unusual behavior and psychiatric evaluations to support their claim, but the prosecution successfully refuted these arguments.
What was the final verdict in the trial of John Fiorenza for the murder of Nancy Titterton?
The jury found John Fiorenza guilty of first-degree murder and rape. Despite his defense team's efforts to argue insanity, the jury concluded that Fiorenza was aware of the nature of his actions and sentenced him to death in the electric chair.
How did the media sensationalize Nancy Titterton's murder, and how did it affect the public perception of the case?
The media sensationalized the case by focusing on salacious details, such as Nancy's supposed promiscuity and the lurid nature of the crime. Tabloids even consulted psychics and astrologers to speculate on the killer's identity, which overshadowed the serious investigative work being done by the police.
What was the significance of the Good Friday timing in relation to John Fiorenza's alibi?
Fiorenza claimed he was late to work because he had an appointment with his probation officer, but his probation officer, a strict Catholic, had taken Good Friday off. This discrepancy in his alibi was a crucial factor in his arrest and confession.
How did Nancy Titterton's career and personal life influence the public's sympathy for her case?
Nancy Titterton was a promising writer whose career was just taking off when she was murdered. Her quiet, bookish demeanor and her love for literature made her a sympathetic figure, and her senseless murder drew widespread public outrage and attention.
What was the most chilling detail revealed by the medical examiner about Nancy Titterton's death?
The medical examiner determined that Nancy was still alive when her attacker placed her in the bathtub, where she eventually died from asphyxiation. This detail highlighted the brutality of the crime and the attacker's intent to prolong her suffering.
- Nancy Evans Titterton was born in 1903.
- She pursued a literary career in New York City.
- She achieved success with her short story "I Shall Decline My Head" and her first novel.
Shownotes Transcript