Deep Dive
Why did investigators initially suspect Wesley Earnest in his wife's death?
Investigators found Wesley Earnest's fingerprints on the suicide note, which was typed and not signed by Jocelyn. This, combined with his financial struggles and the contentious divorce over their lake house, made him a prime suspect.
What was the significance of the lake house in Wesley and Jocelyn Earnest's marriage?
The lake house was a multi-million dollar property that Wesley considered his prized possession and a status symbol. Jocelyn wanted to sell it to alleviate their financial troubles, but Wesley refused, leading to a major point of conflict during their divorce.
What evidence suggested that Jocelyn Earnest's death was not a suicide?
The bullet wound was found at the back of her head, not the temple, indicating she was shot from behind. Additionally, the scene was staged to look like a suicide, with a typed suicide note and the thermostat set to 90 degrees to make it appear she died earlier.
How did Wesley Earnest's financial situation contribute to the investigation?
Wesley was over $1 million in debt, with significant loans and a $6,000 monthly mortgage on the lake house. His financial desperation, coupled with his refusal to sell the house, was seen as a potential motive for murder.
What role did Jocelyn's journals play in the case?
Jocelyn's journals detailed her fear of Wesley and her struggles in the marriage. However, the journals were ruled inadmissible as evidence because they were considered hearsay. Despite this, they were accidentally taken to the jury room during deliberations, leading to a mistrial.
What happened to the lake house after Jocelyn's death?
Fifteen months after Jocelyn's death, the lake house mysteriously burned down while Wesley was out on bond awaiting trial. The fire was inconclusive, but it eliminated the debt on the house and left Wesley with the valuable land.
How did the relationship between Jocelyn and her friend Marcy Shepard impact the trial?
Marcy Shepard claimed to have a romantic relationship with Jocelyn, which was used by the prosecution to suggest Jocelyn was not suicidal. However, the defense argued that their relationship was not serious and did not contribute to Jocelyn's death.
What was the significance of the mistrial in Wesley Earnest's case?
The mistrial occurred because the jury accidentally read Jocelyn's journals, which were inadmissible as evidence. This led to the verdict being overturned, and Wesley was granted a second trial.
How did the prosecution attempt to link Wesley Earnest to the murder during the second trial?
The prosecution presented evidence that Wesley had altered Jocelyn's handwritten timeline, suggesting he had impersonated her. This, combined with his financial motives and the staged crime scene, was used to argue his guilt.
What was the final verdict in Wesley Earnest's case?
Wesley Earnest was found guilty of first-degree murder in the second trial. The jury recommended a sentence of life in prison plus three years, which the judge upheld.
Shownotes Transcript