The Blackout Murder of Livye Lewis
48 Hours
Deep Dive
What was the cause of Livvy Lewis's death?
Livvy Lewis died from a rifle shot to the neck. She was found draped over the steering wheel of her car in the early morning hours of Halloween 2020.
Why did investigators suspect Matthew Edgar in Livvy Lewis's murder?
Matthew Edgar was found in a fetal position behind Livvy's car, covered in blood, with a rifle, shoes, and a hat nearby. He claimed to have no memory of the events, but his relationship with Livvy and his erratic behavior at a party prior to the murder raised suspicions.
What evidence linked Matthew Edgar to the crime scene?
A tiny speck of Livvy's blood was found on Matthew's pants, and her phone was discovered in the truck he drove to the crime scene. Additionally, her keys were found at his grandparents' house, handed over by his mother.
What was Matthew Edgar's relationship with Livvy Lewis?
Matthew Edgar and Livvy Lewis had a tumultuous relationship. They began a secret affair while Matthew was still married, and despite Livvy ending the relationship multiple times, Matthew continued to pursue her. The relationship was marked by jealousy, abuse, and manipulation.
What role did Montana Bokel play in the investigation?
Montana Bokel, Matthew's ex-wife, had an unusual friendship with Livvy after their initial animosity. Investigators questioned her involvement due to her close relationship with Livvy and her failure to call 911 after receiving threatening texts from Matthew. However, she was cleared of any involvement in the murder.
What was the outcome of Matthew Edgar's trial?
Matthew Edgar was found guilty of Livvy Lewis's murder and sentenced to 99 years in prison, with the possibility of parole after 30 years. He fled during the trial but was later captured and sentenced.
What was Livvy Lewis's dream and career aspiration?
Livvy Lewis dreamed of becoming a nurse and then a physician's assistant. She was already a certified nursing assistant at a local nursing home, where she was loved by residents and colleagues.
Why did Matthew Edgar flee during his trial?
Matthew Edgar fled during his trial after the battery on his ankle monitor died. He took a gun with him, leading authorities to believe he might harm himself or others. He was eventually captured after an 11-month manhunt.
What was the significance of the texts between Matthew Edgar and Montana Bokel?
The texts between Matthew Edgar and Montana Bokel revealed his anger and jealousy over Livvy's decision to stay at a friend's house. In one text, he threatened to kill Livvy, Montana, and Bobby Ozan, which became key evidence in the case.
How did Livvy Lewis's mother, Darcy Bass, react to Matthew Edgar's release on bond?
Darcy Bass was outraged when Matthew Edgar was released on bond. She confronted him at a local store, throwing items at him and accusing him of killing her daughter. She was later arrested for the confrontation, but the charges were dropped.
- Livye Lewis found dead in her car on Halloween morning.
- She was a 19-year-old nursing assistant with bright future plans.
- The incident took place in Hemphill, Texas.
Shownotes Transcript