cover of episode Two Wigs and A Gun Pt 2

Two Wigs and A Gun Pt 2

2025/1/9
logo of podcast 48 Hours

48 Hours

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
B
Betty Roundtree
D
Detective Chuck Hanna
D
Detective Colby Kelly
J
Jerry Walters
K
Kathy Molly
K
Kevin O'Keefe
M
Mack McClanahan
M
Marty McVeigh
M
Megan McCreary
M
Michael Jablin
P
Paige Aiken
P
Piper Roundtree
P
Piper Roundtree的律师
P
Piper Roundtree的律师Murray Janis
T
Tina Roundtree
一位评论员
一位调查人员
一位酒吧服务员
旁白
知名游戏《文明VII》的开场动画预告片旁白。
检察官
检察官Wade Kaiser
陪审团
Topics
Megan McCreary: 我是Fred Jablin的邻居,我亲眼目睹了他死在我的车道上。他的死因不明,但他的前妻Piper Roundtree是主要的嫌疑人之一。 一位酒吧服务员: 我认识Piper Roundtree,案发时她看起来很伤心,我认为她没有杀害Fred Jablin。 旁白: 警方掌握了大量的证据,包括手机记录、乳胶手套、化妆品、两顶假发,以及一张在弗吉尼亚州的ATM机上使用的银行卡。这些证据指向一起不寻常的谋杀案。 Detective Colby Kelly: Jerry Walters的银行卡被用于支付与Fred Jablin谋杀案相关的费用,包括机票和假发。 Jerry Walters: 我是Piper Roundtree的前男友,案发当晚她给我打电话,说Fred Jablin死了,她很慌张。我的银行卡在她不知情的情况下被盗用,用于支付与谋杀案相关的费用。 一位调查人员: Piper Roundtree与Fred Jablin离婚后,失去了孩子的抚养权,这可能是她杀害Fred Jablin的动机。她可能在失去孩子抚养权后开始策划谋杀。 Piper Roundtree的律师: 我的当事人Piper Roundtree没有杀害Fred Jablin。检方没有直接证据证明她出现在犯罪现场,也没有动机。真正的凶手是她的姐姐Tina Roundtree。 Piper Roundtree: 我没有杀害我的前夫Fred Jablin。案发时我在德克萨斯州,我有不在场证明。我爱我的孩子们,我不会伤害他们。 检察官Wade Kaiser: Piper Roundtree杀害前夫Fred Jablin的动机是由于经济纠纷和抚养权问题。她欠前夫大量的抚养费,并且对失去孩子的抚养权感到愤怒。 Piper Roundtree的律师Murray Janis: 检方关于动机的解释站不住脚,并且没有目击证人能够证明Piper Roundtree出现在犯罪现场。 Kathy Molly: 我在机场卖给了一位自称Tina Roundtree的女士一张机票,现在我认出她就是Piper Roundtree。她当时是金发,并且携带一把枪。 Detective Chuck Hanna: Piper Roundtree的手机记录显示她在弗吉尼亚州的一个酒店订购了比萨饼,这表明她案发时在弗吉尼亚州。 Tomiko James: 我在酒店见过Piper Roundtree,她当时自称Tina Roundtree。 Raymond Seward: 我在机场附近见过Piper Roundtree,她当时看起来很匆忙。 Mack McClanahan: Piper Roundtree在谋杀案发生前几天和我一起去过射击场,她练习使用过与谋杀案中使用的同类型武器。 Kevin O'Keefe: 我之前误以为在谋杀案前一天晚上在Volcano酒吧见过Piper Roundtree,但实际上我没有。 Marty McVeigh: 我在谋杀案发生当天在办公室见过Piper Roundtree。 Paige Aiken: Marty McVeigh告诉我Piper Roundtree是在谋杀案发生后的第二天来过办公室。 Michael Jablin: 我确信Piper Roundtree有罪,这让我非常伤心。 Betty Roundtree: 我不相信我的女儿有罪,她是一个善良的人。 Bruce Ladd, Joel Howell, Timothy James: Piper Roundtree在法庭上的表现令人不信任,她的证词缺乏说服力。手机记录是导致她被定罪的关键证据。 Tina Roundtree: 我不在乎我的名字在审判中被提及,我认为这是一个愚蠢的辩护。 一位评论员: 陪审团认定Piper Roundtree有罪,因为他们不希望她再回到孩子的生活中。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What key evidence linked Piper Roundtree to the murder of Fred Jablin?

Key evidence included cell phone records placing Piper in Richmond, Virginia, near the crime scene; a blonde wig purchased with a bank card linked to her; hotel records showing she stayed under her sister's name; and eyewitness testimony identifying her at a gas station and rental car agency. Additionally, she was seen practicing with a .38 caliber revolver, the same type used in the murder, days before the crime.

Why did Piper Roundtree's defense team try to shift suspicion to her sister, Tina?

Piper's defense team argued that Tina Roundtree had access to a .38 caliber gun and that Piper had purchased a blonde wig to disguise herself as Tina. They suggested Tina could have been involved, but no direct evidence tied Tina to the murder. The defense aimed to create reasonable doubt by implicating Tina.

What was Piper Roundtree's motive for killing Fred Jablin?

Piper was motivated by her desire to regain custody of her three children after losing them to Fred in a contentious divorce. She was also struggling to pay child support and was over $9,700 in arrears. Prosecutors argued she killed Fred to eliminate the financial burden and regain control of her children.

How did Piper Roundtree attempt to disguise her involvement in the murder?

Piper used her sister Tina's name to book an airline ticket, stayed at a hotel under Tina's name, and purchased a blonde wig to resemble Tina. She also used a bank card under Jerry Walters' name, which she claimed was stolen, to make purchases related to the murder. These actions were intended to frame Tina and obscure her own involvement.

What role did Jerry Walters play in the investigation?

Jerry Walters was Piper's former boyfriend who opened a bank account at her request to hide assets from Fred. His bank card was used to purchase the airline ticket and wigs linked to the murder. Walters testified that he had no knowledge of the card being used in Richmond and believed it had been stolen.

What was the outcome of Piper Roundtree's trial?

Piper Roundtree was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison. The jury deliberated for less than an hour before reaching the verdict. She became eligible for parole in 2020, but her first petition was denied.

How did Piper Roundtree's actions affect her children?

Piper's actions left her three children without both parents. Fred Jablin was killed, and Piper was sentenced to life in prison, effectively removing her from their lives. The children were placed in the custody of Fred's brother, Michael Jablin, and faced the emotional trauma of losing their father and mother.

What was the significance of the cell phone records in the case?

Cell phone records were crucial in placing Piper in Richmond, Virginia, near the crime scene. Calls made from her phone to Papa John's Pizza and hotel records confirmed her presence in the area. This evidence directly contradicted her alibi and linked her to the murder.

What was Tina Roundtree's involvement after the trial?

Tina Roundtree was convicted of tampering with evidence related to Fred Jablin's murder and sentenced to nine months probation. She died in 2020. While she was implicated by Piper's defense, no direct evidence tied her to the murder itself.

How did Piper Roundtree's testimony impact the jury's decision?

Piper's testimony was unconvincing and damaged her defense. She struggled to explain key evidence, such as her presence at the gun range and the use of her cell phone in Richmond. Her emotional and inconsistent responses led the jury to view her as guilty, solidifying their verdict.

Chapters
The episode begins with the discovery of Fred Jablin's body in his driveway. The investigation quickly focuses on his ex-wife, Piper, and her relationship with Jerry Walters, whose bank card was used around the time of the murder. The investigation uncovers a complex web of relationships and hidden assets.
  • Fred Jablin's murder in Richmond, Virginia
  • Piper Roundtree as a suspect
  • Jerry Walters's bank card used in Richmond
  • Piper's relationship with Jerry Walters
  • Hidden assets and the bank account

Shownotes Transcript

Part two of the investigation into the murder of Fred Jablin. In 2004, Fred Jablin was murdered in the driveway of his Virginia home. Details of a nasty divorce and purchases including airline tickets, a gun, and two wigs would lead police to arrest Fred's ex-wife, Piper. But as Piper was about to stand trial, her defense team tried to steer suspicion away from her and on to her big sister, Tina. “48 Hours" correspondent Harold Dow reports. This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 8/25/2007. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays, and stream on demand on Paramount+.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy) and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info).