cover of episode Trump's Plan to Abolish the IRS (What This Means for Your Money)

Trump's Plan to Abolish the IRS (What This Means for Your Money)

2025/4/18
logo of podcast George Kamel

George Kamel

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
主持人
专注于电动车和能源领域的播客主持人和内容创作者。
Topics
我分析了特朗普总统废除国税局并用其他税收体系替代所得税的提案。该提案包括用关税取代所得税,以及用全国销售税(公平税法)取代所得税等多种税收。经济学家认为,用关税取代所得税不可行,会损害经济增长。公平税法提案建议用23%的全国销售税取代所得税,但这实际上相当于30%甚至更高的税率才能维持目前的收入水平。 废除所得税会导致商品价格上涨,对低收入家庭影响最大,尽管公平税法包含预付现金回扣以补偿低收入家庭。公平税法可能促进储蓄和投资,但也可能抑制消费支出。此外,公平税法可能有助于防止逃税,但也可能导致更多地下交易。公平税法可以从外国游客和非美国公民那里征收更多税收。 总的来说,公平税法对不同收入群体的经济影响不同。高收入者可能受益,而低收入者可能受到不成比例的负面影响。废除国税局可能带来新的问题,需要周全的计划才能使其有效运作。无论国税局和所得税的未来如何,做好财务准备始终很重要。建议大家偿还债务,储蓄应急资金,量入为出,并进行投资,因为个人财务规划比政府政策更重要。

Deep Dive

Chapters
This chapter introduces President Trump's proposal to abolish the IRS and replace income tax with tariffs. It clarifies the video's nonpartisan approach and sets the stage for exploring the potential consequences.
  • Trump's proposal to abolish the IRS and replace income tax.
  • Nonpartisan analysis of the proposal.
  • Acknowledgement of the political context but focus on potential effects on individuals.

Shownotes Transcript

Imagine a world where your paycheck is entirely yours with no income tax whatsoever. Well, that's President Trump's bold proposal. And it sounds incredible, but could it really work? How would we fund the government with no income tax and what would be the ripple effects? Well, in today's video, we'll dive into this proposal to abolish the IRS and look into what it means for you. But before we jump in, click those like and subscribe buttons and drop a comment below telling me five things you did last week or I'll consider it your resignation from this channel.

Elon? Yeah. We did it. No, they just unsubscribed. They didn't care. All right. Talk soon. Love you. Bye.

What was the last part? Okay, before you start accusing me of getting political, that's not what I'm doing here. And yes, all of this has to do with politics, but this is just a nonpartisan look at Trump's plan for taxes and how they might affect you, whether you voted for a donkey, an elephant, a brain worm, or Pedro. Don't forget Pedro. Pascal, and one huge tiny caveat here. We're recording this a few weeks in advance, so don't at me if by the time you watch this, the IRS is already MIA.

But as of right now, DJ Trump wants to get rid of the IRS and replace the income tax with what he calls the most beautiful word in the dictionary, tariffs. Tariff. Would you name a kid tariff? Shout out to all the folks named Tariff out there. They're going through it right now.

Although they might go by Tarif. I might be like, no, no, it's not Tarif. I know what it looks like, Tarif. It's actually Tarif. It is a family name. But here's the deal. Economists warn that this would be incredibly damaging to economic growth and not really feasible. According to analysts at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, quote, it is literally impossible for tariffs to fully replace income taxes and

End quote. And by the way, there's evidence showing that American firms and American consumers were the hardest hit by Trump's tariffs during his first term, not the foreign exporters. So it would seem that tariffs are not the key to eliminating the income tax, but they might be the key to eliminating America's ability to afford an egg. But there is a more plausible way Trump and the Republicans could eliminate the income tax and abolish the IRS. And that's by replacing the federal income tax with a national sales tax.

Essentially, instead of Uncle Sam taking a chunk of your paycheck, the government would get its money from a tax on what you spend. This idea is often referred to as the Fair Tax, and it's not really that new. Some politicians have been pushing for this since the early 2000s. The latest version is known as the Fair Tax Act of 2025.

It's a bill introduced by GOP lawmakers that seeks to abolish the IRS and repeal all personal and corporate income taxes, plus the gift tax, payroll tax, and the death tax. Because even dying isn't free in America. Well, that just makes me sad. Now, under this proposed plan, instead of paying, let's say, 22% of your income in taxes, you'd pay something like a 23% national sales tax when you buy stuff.

So you wouldn't get taxed when you earn, just when you spend. In theory, you would keep most of your paycheck, and the government would still get its money when you go shopping and buy things like this electric butter spreader, Lincoln Bio. Sounds pretty straightforward, right? But would it really work? Well, it could in theory if the national sales tax were high enough. If the Fair Tax Act of 2025 is enacted, the national sales tax rate would be 23% as of the 2027 tax year. But that's the tax-inclusive rate. Without

Without going into too much boring detail, that 23% tax rate effectively amounts to about 30%. And one economist has suggested it would actually take a tax rate of at least 44% to maintain the current revenue brought in by the income tax. That's a huge jump, and that's not the only thing that would change. There would be all kinds of other ripple effects if we got rid of the income tax.

Let me show you what I mean. Let's pretend we live in a world where Trump actually pulls this off. That means no more IRS, which means no more filing tax returns, no more audits, and no more worrying about whether you claim the right deductions for the home office that doubles as a guest room slash playroom slash movie room. And yeah, your paycheck is yours, 100%. Loving this hypothetical future so far.

But now we've got this massive national sales tax to make up for all the revenue the government lost when they abandoned the income tax. So in theory, your groceries, gas, and big dumb Stanley cups would cost 30% more. That would mean a $20,000 car just became a $26,000 car.

and your go-to $10 Chick-fil-A meal is now $13. And they still won't let you order your fries well done like they did in the good old days. I guess it wasn't their pleasure after all. Sorry I don't want soggy fries. I like my boys crispy. Is that a crime in America today? To want some crispy, boys? Just bitter.

disappointment, and almost sadness. Okay, now before you get your taxes in a wad, check this out. People in favor of the fair tax argue that things actually wouldn't cost that much more than they do now. Here's why. If you went to Target today and bought, I don't know,

A $10 bag of Sour Patch Kids, you can assume that almost a quarter of the cost of that bag, 22%, is taxes that the business owner is passing on to you, the consumer. Well, under the fair tax, all the taxes would be eliminated from the tax code, meaning the business owner would no longer need to pass those costs on to you. So in theory, the price would come down, the 23% national sales tax would be added, and the cost of that bag of kids would still be roughly the same. Maybe a few cents more than it would be today. You okay there, kids?

I think blue number two is a little hurt. You're a monster. Now, if you ask me, it's awfully optimistic to assume big corporations are just going to voluntarily pass all their tax savings on to you. And even if they do, things are still likely to cost at least a little more. So now on top of the high prices caused by inflation, tariffs, and whatever's killing the chickens out there, we've got even higher prices. And who do higher prices affect the most? Lower income households. Now the Fair Tax Act suddenly doesn't look quite so fair.

Big sound effects there, guys. Big sound effects. Don't tell me what to do! But to offset the impact of low-income households, the fair tax would include a pre-bait, or a pre-paid cash rebate, to ensure that no American pays federal taxes on essential goods and services up to the poverty level. But even with the pre-bait, critics argue that a sales tax would still disproportionately affect lower-income families. Back when this idea was first getting some traction, economist William G. Gale at the Brookings Institution had this to say about it. Quote,

So great news for the billionaires in Trump's cabinet, not so much for the rest of us. And the ripple effects continue. On the other side of the coin, the fair tax might boost savings and investing. Since

Since you only get taxed when you spend, people might be incentivized to save and stash away more money in their retirement accounts where they could take it out tax-free. But on the other hand, this could put a damper on consumer spending because if everything costs more, even if it's just a little bit, people might spend less, which could slow down the economy. And that wouldn't be fun for consumers or business owners. Imagine trying to explain to your loyal customers why their $5 raccoon cross stitch is now $6. I know those ladies, they're not gonna stand for it, mostly 'cause they're sitting, crotcheting.

crocheting. But on the plus side, some argue that the fair tax would help prevent tax evasion. Under the current income tax system, people who work off the books, drug dealers, cash workers, and general tax evaders avoid paying federal taxes. With the fair tax, they would pay taxes when they spend their money, making it harder to avoid taxation. Although, people would likely find ways to avoid the sales tax by buying and selling goods under the table or just trading bread for rare Pokemon cards.

A loaf of fresh sourdough for a holographic squirtle, my good fellow? Acting classes are paying off, guys. Just saying. Worth every cent of that $400 per class. Hope he kept the receipt. We love a good barter, but there's a chance this could cause more under-the-table deals and evasion.

But here's another pro. The fair tax would collect more tax revenue from foreign visitors and non-U.S. citizens who would pay the same national sales tax as Americans when they buy goods and services. So all in all, there are pros and cons to the fair tax, and it's hard to know the full impact unless it's actually put into place. But it does seem to be a more viable option than just replacing the income tax with tariffs. Now let's get down to brass tacks. That's T-A-C-K-S, not T-A-S.

How would abolishing the IRS and replacing the income tax with a national sales tax affect you? I'll break it down based on how much you earn. And while we're talking about earning, let's talk about how much you're earning in a savings account. If you're stashing a lot of cash in a regular old savings account earning dismal interest, it's time to look into a high-yield savings account like the one offered by Laurel Road.

Okay, back to the question.

If we move from the federal income tax to a national sales tax, how would all this affect you? Well, it depends on how much you earn and how much you spend. If you're a high earner, you'd love this. More money in your pocket and you can afford the higher sales tax. If you're middle class, it depends. You'd have more take-home pay, but you'd feel the pinch with every purchase. And you probably wouldn't feel much wealthier. And if you're lower income...

Not great. Essentials would be more expensive, and you'd lose out on tax credits like the Earned Income Tax Credit. So is abolishing the IRS a good idea? Well, it sounds nice in the sense that it's much simpler than what we have now, but most advanced economies use a mix of different types of taxation like

income tax, corporate tax, sales tax, property tax, to balance efficiency, fairness, and stability. So abolishing the IRS would likely create a whole new set of problems, and we'd need a solid plan in place to actually make this work. So what should you do about it? Well, here's the deal. No matter what happens with the IRS and the income tax, it's always a good idea to be prepared for a financial storm. So how do you do that? I'm going to tell you, and to make it easy on you, I'm going to do it in 60 seconds or less. So keep up.

Number one, pay off your debt. The credit cards, car loans, student loans, all of it. And from now on, avoid debt like bird flu. 'Cause debt is a thief. It's stealing from your income. Number two, you gotta save for emergencies. I recommend three to six months of expenses set aside in that high yield savings account. You need a buffer between you and life.

Number three, live on less than you make. You gotta make sure you have financial margin so that you don't feel the pinch when it comes to spending. And for what it's worth, EveryDollar is the best budgeting app out there. I'll drop a link below. And lastly, keep investing. I recommend setting aside 15% of your income toward retirement as long as you're in a financial position to be investing. You can do that in a company 401k or a Roth IRA. You do that long enough, you're not gonna be worried about what's going on in the White House. Boom, how'd we do? Still got time to kill.

Elon? No, I'm just bored now. What are you doing? No way. You fired how many people? That's crazy. No, you hang up first. I'm fired. Who saw that coming?

I did. Ultimately, no matter what tax system we have, the best financial plan remains the same. And if you're living paycheck to paycheck and struggling to get ahead, don't count on the government to solve any of your financial problems. The only real path to financial security is the one you create for yourself. And no matter how you voted, here's the bipartisan truth I want you to remember. What happens in your house matters way more than what happens in the White House.

So instead of worrying about Washington, focus on your own finances. And while it's fun to daydream about not having to file a tax return, I'm not counting on any of this happening anytime soon. But hey, the way Trump's second term has gone so far, who knows what could happen? By the time you watch this video, we could all be eating $14 eggs at the Gulf of George Camel. A boy can dream. America got one, why can't I? Why does America get everything? - It's really unfair.

If you want a deeper dive on how to build wealth and how to be prepared no matter what comes your way financially, check out my book, Breaking Free From Broke, the ultimate guide to more money and less stress. And if you don't like physical books...

That's okay. Check out the audio book where I read it to you instead. I'll drop a link in the description below. And just for kicks, keep watching this next video to see what Dave Ramsey said when I asked him if he'd ever consider running for office or use the link in the description to watch it next. Thanks for watching. We'll see you next time. Trump, give me Elon. Elon, hear me out. We got George Washington on the dollar bill. Swap it out with another George. Who's gonna know? He's had a good... It's been hundreds of years.