Deep Dive
What happened to Emmeline Hausman and her daughter on Christmas Day, 1843?
Emmeline Hausman and her one-year-old daughter, Annalisa, were found dead in their burned house on Christmas Day, 1843. An autopsy revealed they were murdered before the fire started, with Emmeline having a deep stab wound and Annalisa's skull completely fractured.
Why was Polly Bodine suspected of the murders?
Polly Bodine was suspected of the murders because she was the last person seen with Emmeline Hausman, had a scandalous reputation, and was involved in an affair with George Waite. Additionally, valuables from the Hausman home were found in Waite's apothecary, and a note from Polly to Waite saying 'Hide the things' raised further suspicion.
How did the penny press influence the investigation and trial of Polly Bodine?
The penny press sensationalized the case, publishing unverified claims and influencing public opinion. Editors like James Gordon Bennett of the New York Herald pushed narratives of Polly's guilt, including false stories about her character and actions. The press was also allowed to observe witness examinations, further shaping the trial's atmosphere.
What was the outcome of Polly Bodine's trials?
Polly Bodine faced three trials. The first ended in a hung jury due to one holdout juror. The second trial in Manhattan resulted in a murder conviction, but the verdict was appealed. The third trial in Newburgh ended in her acquittal, partly due to public sympathy and the prosecution's weakened case.
How did P.T. Barnum contribute to the public perception of Polly Bodine?
P.T. Barnum created a wax figure of Polly Bodine depicting her as a witch committing the murders, which he displayed in his American Museum. This sensationalized portrayal attracted thousands of visitors and further fueled public fascination and condemnation of Polly.
What role did Edgar Allan Poe play in the Polly Bodine case?
Edgar Allan Poe, then a newsman, followed the case closely and criticized the police for being influenced by newspaper opinions. He believed Polly was guilty but doubted the authorities' ability to handle the case properly, reflecting his interest in using logic to solve crimes.
Shownotes Transcript