Deep Dive
What happened to Charles and Shirley Chick at Winding Stair Campground in 2003?
Charles and Shirley Chick were found dead at Winding Stair Campground in Ouachita National Forest on July 11, 2003. Both had been shot multiple times in the head with a small-caliber firearm. Their bodies showed signs of decomposition, indicating they had been dead for about 24 hours. The crime scene revealed no firearm, ruling out a murder-suicide, and their camping gear was still set up, suggesting they were not in the process of leaving.
Who was the primary suspect in the murder of Charles and Shirley Chick?
Edward Leon Fields Jr. was identified as the primary suspect. He was linked to the crime through a tip from his ex-partner, Carol Lamb, who reported he owned a .22-caliber rifle and a homemade camouflage suit. Investigators found burlap fibers at the crime scene matching the suit, and ballistics confirmed the bullets matched his rifle. Fields was arrested on July 18, 2003, and later confessed to the murders.
What evidence connected Edward Fields Jr. to the murders?
Edward Fields Jr. was connected to the murders through multiple pieces of evidence: a .22-caliber rifle matching the bullets found in the victims, a homemade camouflage suit made of burlap fibers that matched fibers at the crime scene, and his confession. Additionally, his ex-partner testified that he had admitted to stalking and killing the couple while wearing the suit.
What was Edward Fields Jr.'s motive for killing Charles and Shirley Chick?
Edward Fields Jr. initially claimed he killed the couple for financial gain, admitting to stealing $340, a credit card, a camera, and binoculars. However, prosecutors argued that the robbery was staged and that Fields had premeditated the murders as part of a fantasy to live out a 'sport killing' scenario, evidenced by his homemade ghillie suit and camouflaged rifle.
What was the outcome of Edward Fields Jr.'s trial?
Edward Fields Jr. pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder, two counts of using a firearm during a violent crime, one count of robbery, and one count of automobile burglary. He was sentenced to death by a federal jury in 2005, becoming the 41st person on Oklahoma's death row. However, in December 2024, his sentence was commuted to life without parole by President Joe Biden.
What role did mental health play in Edward Fields Jr.'s defense?
Edward Fields Jr.'s defense argued that he suffered from chronic depression, bipolar disorder, and organic brain damage, which impaired his judgment. They claimed that the antidepressant Effexor, which he was taking at the time, caused a 'manic flip' leading to the murders. Despite this, prosecutors rejected the argument, and the jury sentenced him to death, though his sentence was later commuted to life without parole.
Why was the Ouachita National Forest significant in this case?
The Ouachita National Forest was significant because it was the location of the murders, marking the first homicides in the forest since its establishment in 1907. The secluded nature of the forest allowed Fields to stalk and kill the couple without immediate detection, highlighting the risks of dispersed camping in remote areas.
What was the significance of the ghillie suit in the case?
The ghillie suit was a critical piece of evidence, as it allowed Edward Fields Jr. to blend into the forest environment while stalking and killing the couple. The suit, made of burlap fibers, matched fibers found at the crime scene. Prosecutors argued that the suit was part of a premeditated plan to carry out a 'sport killing,' emphasizing Fields' transformation into a predator.
- Charles and Shirley Chick found murdered at Winding Stair Campground
- No weapon found at the scene
- Victims identified through dental records
- Cause of death: multiple gunshot wounds to the head
Shownotes Transcript