We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
A
Adnan Syed
A
Aisha Pittman
B
Becky Klein
S
Sarah Koenig
控
控方
控方：Adnan因Hae与他分手而感到愤怒和羞辱，认为这是其杀害Hae的动机。控方认为Adnan在与Hae恋爱期间背叛了家庭和宗教，在Hae分手后，这种负罪感和羞辱感达到顶峰，最终导致他杀害了Hae。控方还强调了Adnan父母在返校舞会上对他的斥责，以及Adnan在Hae失踪后前后矛盾的证词，作为其犯罪的证据。
Adnan：Adnan否认自己对宗教虔诚，并表示与Hae的分手是相对平静和理性的。他承认分手后感到悲伤，但否认自己怀有杀害Hae的愤怒和报复心理。Adnan还指出，他在与Hae分手后与其他女孩约会，这表明他并没有被分手事件困扰。Adnan对控方关于他在返校舞会上受到父母斥责后产生的愤怒导致他杀害Hae的说法表示否认，并认为这只是件好笑的事情。
Sarah Koenig：Sarah Koenig对控方提出的杀人动机表示质疑，认为没有证据表明Adnan在分手后行为异常或怀有杀意。她通过采访Adnan的朋友和老师，试图还原Adnan和Hae的恋爱关系和分手经过，并对控方证人Jay的证词的可信度提出质疑。Sarah Koenig还指出，Hae在分手后仍然与Adnan保持联系，这与控方提出的Adnan因分手而怀有杀意的说法相矛盾。
证人们：Adnan的朋友和老师普遍认为Adnan在分手后表现得很悲伤，而不是愤怒或报复。他们回忆说，Adnan在分手后仍然与其他女孩约会，这表明他并没有被分手事件困扰。Hae的朋友Aisha则回忆说，Adnan对Hae过度关注，这让她感到困扰。但是，Hae的日记中并没有表达对Adnan分手后行为的担忧。
Deep Dive
Shownotes Transcript
Their relationship began like a storybook high-school romance: a prom date, love notes, sneaking off to be alone. But unlike other kids at school, they had to keep their dating secret, because their parents disapproved. Both of them, but especially Adnan, were under special pressure at home, and the stress of that spilled over into their relationship. Eventually Hae broke up with Adnan. And then, depending on who you ask, Adnan was either understandably sad and moping around, or full of rage and plotting to kill her.