We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 6

The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 6

2022/3/18
logo of podcast Serial

Serial
AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
B
Brian Reid
H
Hamza
Topics
Brian Reid：作为记者，我回顾了对伯明翰学校"特洛伊木马事件"的调查过程，特别是Peter Clarke的报告。我发现该报告证据不足，缺乏客观性，存在许多事实错误和偏见。例如，报告中关于恐怖主义视频、学生会充当道德警察、集会反美等指控，都缺乏充分的证据支持。此外，报告忽略了政府授权下对学校的接管，以及一些关键证据的缺失。总而言之，Clarke报告未能提供令人信服的证据来证明存在有组织的阴谋，其结论不可靠。政府对该报告的依赖，以及由此引发的对教师的指控和处罚，都暴露出政府行为中的缺陷和不公正。 我与Hamza在报道过程中存在分歧，主要体现在对客观性和中立性的理解上。Hamza的强烈情绪和对官方叙事的质疑，源于他对种族主义和对穆斯林的偏见根深蒂固的担忧。虽然我理解他的感受，但我认为记者应该保持客观，让事实引导结论。 Hamza：我参与了对伯明翰学校"特洛伊木马事件"的调查，我的动机是作为一名穆斯林，揭露事件背后的不公正和偏见。我认为Peter Clarke的报告存在严重的缺陷，它未能充分考虑穆斯林社区的观点和担忧，并利用媒体偏见来歪曲事实。报告中许多指控缺乏证据，甚至存在蓄意歪曲。政府利用该报告来打击穆斯林社区，这体现了种族主义和对穆斯林的系统性歧视。 我与Brian在报道过程中存在分歧，主要体现在对客观性和中立性的理解上。我认为，在面对系统性种族主义和偏见时，单纯的客观性和中立性是不够的，我们必须积极发声，揭露真相。

Deep Dive

Chapters
The chapter explores tensions between Hamza and his colleague regarding journalistic ethics and biases, as well as Hamza's personal reflections on his approach and beliefs.
  • Hamza faced criticism for his strong opinions and approach towards the Trojan Horse investigation.
  • His letter expressing disbelief in official narratives caused internal conflict and suspicion of bias.
  • Despite frustrations, Hamza insists on pursuing truth and admits his journalistic journey is evolving.

Shownotes Transcript

Hamza takes a long, hard look at what the government found when it investigated more than 20 majority-Muslim schools in Birmingham. And our two reporters have a confrontation – with each other. To get full access to this show, and to other Serial Productions and New York Times podcasts on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, subscribe at nytimes.com/podcasts.

To find out about new shows from Serial Productions, and get a look behind the scenes, sign up for our newsletter at nytimes.com/serialnewsletter.

Have a story pitch, a tip, or feedback on our shows? Email us at [email protected]