OKC’s Revenge, NBA Cup Nitpicks, and NFL Season Fun Grades with David Jacoby, Kirk Goldsberry, Kyle Brandt, and Craig Horlbeck
The Bill Simmons Podcast
Deep Dive
Why is OKC the team to beat in the West?
Their defense is on a different level, creating frustration and turnovers. They're athletic, fast, and have a true go-to weapon in SGA, a leading MVP candidate.
Why is Bill Simmons flummoxed by the new NBA CBA trade rules?
The rules are too complex and restrictive, making it difficult to even construct hypothetical trades, limiting player movement, and impacting trade deadline activity.
Is the NBA Cup working?
While it provides meaningful games in December and potential catapult moments for up-and-coming teams, some contenders prefer rest to extra games, raising questions about its overall effectiveness. It's suggested the Cup could be improved by using divisions for groupings and adding incentives like Elam endings or rule experimentation.
Are the Milwaukee Bucks legitimate contenders?
They've improved significantly after a rough start, with Giannis putting up MVP-caliber numbers and the supporting cast providing efficient three-point shooting. However, defensive concerns and questions about the Giannis-Lillard fit remain.
Why is Orlando a dangerous team despite injuries and poor three-point shooting?
Even without key players, their defense is formidable, making them a tough playoff matchup. They've shown resilience and unexpected contributions from players like Suggs, while the development of players like Anthony Black adds to their long-term potential.
What's going on with Joel Embiid?
Chronic swelling, lack of communication about availability, and tardiness raise concerns about his professionalism and long-term health, casting a shadow over the Sixers' prospects.
Who are some of the most impressive rookies?
Ausar Thompson (Detroit) is praised for his two-way play and potential, while Victor Wembanyama (San Antonio) shows defensive prowess and an edge. Bilal Coulibaly (Washington) also receives positive mention.
Which team is the most disappointing this season?
While the Pacers and Timberwolves have underperformed, the Phoenix Suns are a major disappointment given their all-in trade for an aging, injury-prone Kevin Durant and a poorly constructed roster.
Why is Josh Allen playing so well?
He's in a great place mentally and emotionally, with a strong supporting cast, a good run game, and a solid offensive line. His confidence and happiness are translating to on-field success.
Are the Kansas City Chiefs in trouble despite their record?
Their offense has been inconsistent, relying on one good drive per game, and their overreliance on Travis Kelce is a concern. Despite their success in close games, they might be vulnerable in the playoffs.
Why aren't the Pittsburgh Steelers getting more credit?
Despite their strong record and improved offense under Kenny Pickett, they often get overlooked. Their defense, coaching, and reliable kicker make them a legitimate contender.
Are the Philadelphia Eagles as good as their record suggests?
Despite winning nine straight, there are concerns about Jalen Hurts' consistency and the team's overreliance on the run game. Some players and fans seem disgruntled, raising questions about team chemistry and playoff potential.
Why are the Minnesota Vikings a risky bet despite their success with Sam Darnold?
Many doubt Darnold's long-term viability as a franchise quarterback, attributing their success to their talented supporting cast and coaching system. There's a belief that Darnold's performance is unsustainable and that the Vikings are likely to regress.
How has Russell Wilson performed in Pittsburgh?
He's been surprisingly good, consistently making big plays and showing renewed confidence. However, questions remain about his long-term viability and whether he can lead the Steelers to playoff success.
Which New York team is more disappointing, the Giants or the Jets?
While the Giants have consistently underperformed and fans are resigned to their struggles, the Jets are a bigger disappointment due to preseason hype and the failed Aaron Rodgers experiment. Their season is considered a complete disaster.
How would you grade the NFL season so far?
Despite some disappointments like the Jets and Bears, the season has been exciting and full of compelling storylines, with several strong teams, impressive quarterback play, and memorable games. Grades range from A- to B+.
Shownotes Transcript