We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Our Favorite Things, 2024

Our Favorite Things, 2024

2024/12/23
logo of podcast Strict Scrutiny

Strict Scrutiny

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
K
Kate Shaw
L
Leah Littman
M
Melissa Murray
Topics
Kate Shaw: 对首席大法官约翰·罗伯茨的评价褒贬不一。有人认为他去年展现了他并非制度主义者的真实面目,在"特朗普诉美国"和"洛珀·布莱特"案中的判决,揭示了他真实的政治立场。也有人认为他是世界上最精明的政治家,因为他成功地重新掌控了法院,展现出高超的政治策略和手腕。此外,还有人欣赏他的发型。 对克拉伦斯·托马斯的评价:有人认为他因为个人原因短期内不会离开最高法院;有人认为他公开接受额外收入的做法很坦率;也有人认为他擅长暗示并获得自己想要的东西。 对塞缪尔·阿利托的评价:有人认为他是她们的"反派",也有人认为他保养得比较好,并且支持妻子。 对索尼娅·索托马约尔的评价:有人敬佩她即使在同事们陷入疯狂时,仍然认真负责地完成工作,对每一个案件和当事人都给予了充分的关注;也有人欣赏她在去年的一个具有争议性的判决中写下的异议意见;还有人认为她总是试图在她同事身上寻找优点。 对艾琳娜·卡根的评价:有人欣赏她的俏皮和坦率,也有人欣赏她对同事和下级法院法官的愚蠢和拙劣行为表达的沮丧之情,以及她激励人心的写作风格。 对尼尔·戈萨奇的评价:有人认为他为法院带来了地域多样性,并且他的自满情绪使其成为讽刺的对象;也有人认为他写了一本书,值得写一篇精彩的批判性书评。 对布雷特·卡瓦诺的评价:有人认为他在口头辩论中努力讨好别人的行为有时可能会有用;也有人认为他在缺乏真正天赋和智慧的情况下取得了成就,这令人鼓舞;也有人认为他是一位优秀的运动员。 对艾米·科尼·巴雷特的评价:有人欣赏她一丝不苟的工作作风,也有人认为她对同事的幻想令人赞赏。 对凯坦吉·布朗·杰克逊的评价:有人认为她是第一位登上百老汇舞台的最高法院大法官;也有人认为她能够很好地平衡积极性和愤怒;还有人欣赏她丈夫对她无条件的爱戴。 Melissa Murray: 对首席大法官约翰·罗伯茨的评价:认为他在"特朗普诉美国"和"洛珀·布莱特"案中的判决,揭示了他真实的政治立场,并认为他公开接受额外收入的做法很坦率。 对克拉伦斯·托马斯的评价:认为他公开接受额外收入的做法很坦率。 对塞缪尔·阿利托的评价:认为他是她们的"反派"。 对索尼娅·索托马约尔的评价:认为她对每一个案件和当事人都给予了充分的关注,并总是试图在她同事身上寻找优点。 对艾琳娜·卡根的评价:欣赏她对同事和下级法院法官的愚蠢和拙劣行为表达的沮丧之情。 对尼尔·戈萨奇的评价:认为他写了一本书,值得写一篇精彩的批判性书评。 对布雷特·卡瓦诺的评价:认为他在缺乏真正天赋和智慧的情况下取得了成就,这令人鼓舞。 对艾米·科尼·巴雷特的评价:认为她对同事的幻想令人赞赏。 对凯坦吉·布朗·杰克逊的评价:认为她能够很好地平衡积极性和愤怒。 Leah Littman: 对首席大法官约翰·罗伯茨的评价:欣赏他的发型和政治策略。 对克拉伦斯·托马斯的评价:认为他因为个人原因短期内不会离开最高法院。 对塞缪尔·阿利托的评价:认为他保养得比较好,并且支持妻子。 对索尼娅·索托马约尔的评价:欣赏她在去年的一个具有争议性的判决中写下的异议意见。 对艾琳娜·卡根的评价:欣赏她的俏皮和坦率。 对尼尔·戈萨奇的评价:认为他为法院带来了地域多样性,并且他的自满情绪使其成为讽刺的对象。 对布雷特·卡瓦诺的评价:认为他是一位优秀的运动员。 对艾米·科尼·巴雷特的评价:欣赏她一丝不苟的工作作风。 对凯坦吉·布朗·杰克逊的评价:欣赏她丈夫对她无条件的爱戴。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is Chief Justice John Roberts no longer seen as an institutionalist?

John Roberts demonstrated his true colors by not only joining but writing major decisions like Trump v. United States and Loper Bright, which revealed his political instincts and long-term machinations.

What is significant about Justice Thomas's recent behavior regarding his tenure on the court?

Despite expectations that he might step down to make room for a younger appointee, Justice Thomas's ego and secure alternative funding from billionaires have likely kept him on the court.

Why is Justice Sotomayor's approach to her job admirable?

Justice Sotomayor is known for her meticulous attention to detail and every litigant, even as her colleagues descend into madness. She also writes powerful dissents, such as her immunity decision, which remain impactful.

What makes Justice Kagan's writing and persona so energizing?

Justice Kagan's writing and demeanor during oral arguments are both cheeky and profoundly frustrating, which can be invigorating. Her way of both eviscerating and lifting up advocates makes her a compelling presence on the court.

Why is Justice Jackson's approach to the court unique and positive?

Justice Jackson brings a balance of energy and positivity to her oral arguments while maintaining a sense of righteous indignation towards her colleagues' actions. She also secures and discloses tickets to highly sought-a such as Beyoncé fter events,concerts.

What are some recommended alternatives to Amazon Prime for online shopping and delivery?

Local grocery delivery apps like Mercado and consignment stores like The RealReal offer alternatives to Amazon Prime. Mercado supports local businesses, and The RealReal provides luxury items at a discount.

Why are group chats important in digital life according to the hosts?

Group chats are important because they provide intimate, fulfilling spaces for communication among friends and family, free from the scrutiny of strangers and the pressure of public platforms.

What are some highly recommended books to read during the holidays and in 2025?

Books recommended include 'Vigilante Nation' by John Michaels and David Knoll, 'The Interbellum Constitution' by Alison LaCroix, 'Anti-Democratic' by David Daly, 'Bright Young Women' by Jessica Knoll, 'The Beautiful Poetry of Donald Trump' by Rob Sears, and 'King, A Life' by Jonathan Eig.

What are the hosts' favorite podcasts to listen to?

The hosts recommend 'Ear Witness,' a podcast about an innocent man on Alabama's death row, and 'Less Radical,' a documentary about Dr. Bernie Fischer, who revolutionized breast cancer treatment. They also mention 'Yacht Rock' as a fantastic Netflix documentary.

Why are the hosts grateful to their listeners?

The hosts appreciate their listeners for their support, especially in challenging times. They empower listeners to be court watchers and provide a sense of community and hope in the face of legal and political challenges.

Chapters
The hosts of the Strict Scrutiny podcast share their opinions on each Supreme Court Justice, highlighting both their positive and negative attributes. Their comments range from serious observations about judicial behavior to more lighthearted remarks about appearances and personal lives.
  • Positive and negative attributes of each Supreme Court Justice are discussed.
  • The discussion includes both serious and lighthearted observations.
  • The hosts' opinions are subjective and based on their own observations and interpretations.

Shownotes Transcript

In the spirit of the holidays, Leah, Kate & Melissa force themselves to say something nice about each Supreme Court Justice. Yes, all of them. Then they take a break from the tomfoolery at One First Street to share their favorite things. Whether you’re doing some very last-minute holiday shopping, looking to indulge yourself, or craving a good book or podcast, there are ideas for everyone. 

Programming note: we’re taking a break next week, but will be back on January 6, 2025 with a very special–and timely–episode on the presidency.