Trapped in Their Own Story
48:15 Share

None of the voices in this series are ongoing patients of Esther Perel. Each episode of Where Should We Begin is a one-time counseling session. For the purposes of maintaining confidentiality, names and some identifiable characteristics have been removed, but their voices and their stories are real.

Vitamin water was born in New York because New Yorkers wanted more. Like more flavor to go with all the flavor. A refreshing drink after climbing six flights of stairs to a walk-up apartment or standing in the subway station in 100 degree heat. Drink vitamin water. It's from New York.

On September 28th, the Global Citizen Festival will gather thousands of people who took action to end extreme poverty. Join Post Malone, Doja Cat, Lisa, Jelly Roll, and Raul Alejandro as they take the stage with world leaders and activists to defeat poverty, defend the planet, and demand equity. Download the Global Citizen app today and earn your spot at the festival. Learn more at globalcitizen.org.com.

I just remember her saying like, "Well, if you knew the truth, you wouldn't even be able to handle it." They've been together for almost two decades. We met each other when we were in eighth grade and we got together our senior year. Pretty much been together ever since. They've been disconnected from each other for a long time. It's always kind of been rocky. It's always kind of had its ups and downs. And it felt like I was one of his priorities.

They each are acutely aware of how they wanted something more from the other, more attention, more desire, more affirmation. And after years of complaining about the lack of affirmation, they each found other people to give them the attention they so much craved. So it was like a total of maybe six infidelities, I guess you could say.

Mine happened a year after discovery of hers. At that point, I was in such a dark place to hear someone actually tell you that you're good enough. Here we are right now, almost four years later. They're not in the grip of it, but they are still dealing with everything that led to it. I feel like he's disconnected and he doesn't want to talk to me or he's afraid to talk to me.

I keep trying to improve myself to be able to be the person that I feel like she needs. And maybe that's the part that hurts the most is I just feel like I'm always trying to improve myself for her. And I just feel like it just never measures up. I feel like he doesn't like to share things with me, doesn't like to communicate. More so now as the years have gone by, I feel like I withdraw a lot more when I feel him being distant.

So if he withdraws, you withdraw. And when you withdraw, then? We're just basically like roommates, I'd say. Like we just are parents and there's like no real romantic connection. I've realized that I really do need that. Like I, you know, but I just don't want it to be fake or forced. On your part or on his part? His part.

I don't want to tell him. I don't want to say, you know, I don't want to be the one to say, hey, like you didn't come and kiss me. But yet I still do. Is that part of a broader expectation that you are to be the pursuer and she can respond? I think of one line she always uses is like, I shouldn't have to tell you. You should know. So, yeah, I think a lot of times it is like she expects me to.

fully pursue her. I feel like I've used the word kind of like shut down. It's probably accurate. After like everything that happened, I was like, well, why would you like open yourself up to that possibility again? Can I just ask you for a moment, give me a bit of background so I know what we're talking about. Well, the infidelity on both of us, like both of us

had affairs but I guess like I've been thinking about it a lot late a lot lately and to me I feel like there has been infidelity from the beginning with his porn addiction and I don't even know if he considers it an addiction it was just something you know guys do like it's just a guy thing guys do this to me that was that was betrayal and I let him know that and I

he would just reassure me that it's just a guy thing. The betrayal for you? Tell me about the betrayal. Him watching porn, him being okay with it and trying to convince me that it was okay, even though I voiced to him that I wasn't okay with it. The betrayal was that he was watching porn

watching more than you cared for, watching other women and rejecting you, making you feel that there was something wrong with you for judging it or being uncomfortable with it. Where was the betrayal for you? There's lots of pieces to this. So I want to make sure that I really know what you're experiencing. Yeah. Um,

I would say him watching it and me feeling like that was what he wanted and I wasn't able to fulfill his fantasies. And part of it was you didn't care for it. You were not at all attracted to the same kind of play.

You thought he's trying to put a different thing on me that has nothing to do with me? Yeah, I wasn't ever really into it. I just went along with it because I thought that's what he wanted. So, you know, when he would ask if we could watch, you know, I would agree to it and I would feel gross after and...

Because then anytime anything that I would see and then if he would try that in the bedroom like it just kind of shut me down You're shaking your head. Tell me what you're saying. Yes. I just said like if you ever Brought anything into the bedroom. Where did you learn that? Where did you see that? What have you been watching? What have you been doing? Yeah to keep it very Manila

Because anything outside the ordinary was, it would like, I think instantly kind of be a trigger for her. And she'd start putting up the walls and you could feel that separation of kind of like, well now you're kind of like, okay, I'm going through with this, but I really don't want to be here anymore because now I'm thinking about what you've been doing. - And what were you into that we're talking about? Just so I have a sense. - I think for her, like she came from like a very conservative family.

Mine was a little bit more open. So I experienced like sexual damages and stuff like really young, like around like eight years old. And I think I pretty much like introduced her to all of that stuff. I didn't ever really have anything. I was like, oh, that's my thing. Like, I love that. So anytime you would try to bring anything to the bedroom and kind of like excited or change it up a little bit.

I said it was usually met with, "Well, where did you see that?" or "Where did you get it from?" And so we just kind of learned over the years, like, "Yeah, I can play with it up here in my mind," but you can't really act on it. But you were eager to bring all kinds of things to the bedroom and less curious about her? No, I think at first I was more interested in seeing what we could do together.

There was a lot of eroticism in there, excitement of like, oh, because we're both pretty much new to this, except for what I had seen. And then instantly, though, it was kind of shut down. Yeah, that's gross. And again, it was something I could play with in my own mind, but it wasn't something I was ever then comfortable with bringing back. And that's when you feel that he began to lie? No, I think he...

I don't even remember when I found out about his problem. But is there an agreement that this was a problem? Or was the problem that you wanted to share certain fantasies with her and that that was not at all what she wanted to explore with you and therefore you took it underground? Where was the problem? He would do it by himself, like...

And he would even say, like, "I just do it for the end result." The conversation about sex and sexuality instantly devolves in a conversation about porn. They grew up with attitudes towards sexuality that were often negative, filled with shame, filled with guilt, filled with an idea that sex should be preserved for marriage, that it should be missionary, clean,

and fertile. It is not unusual for people to grow up with negative messaging around sexuality. For them, it was rooted in their Christian Mormon background. And so much of what they've experienced for years is the consequence of ignorance, negative attitudes towards sex, and the inability to communicate about it. And so it became a silent sexual rut.

And as far as, you know, not wanting to do things with him, I feel like he was already experienced and I wasn't. I'm wondering if he really had much experience. He had very little experience. He had experience with himself and his own fantasies, jerking off by himself. That is not communication. That is not being with a partner. No, that's not. And he has always said that that was his escape and that was his way out.

of love to feel love or to feel wanted. You always felt like if somebody loved you, they would want to do that with you. My thought was more like, if you really love me, you'd want to be sexual with me.

Yeah, but she didn't feel that you wanted to be sexual with her. No, she didn't. You think you were trying to be sexual with her and intimate with her. I understand that. And on some level, it makes a lot of sense. From where she was, you're coming there with your bucket of play that you had done by yourself all those years that had very little to do with her and didn't ask her anything about herself. Didn't feel like any particularly curious move on your part.

Every experience with her was to be with her. And I think that's something I tried to explain to you a lot of times. It's like, you always thought like, oh, you want me to be like her, to look like her, to look like this? Like, no, like I didn't, I didn't need you to be anyone other than yourself. And like the only things I ever did bring in was because like anything I watched was like, the only thing that actually turned me on about watching it was like, oh, I would love to do that with you.

I didn't ever watch it and be like, oh, I want to do that with her. It was no, like, oh, like how great would it be to do that or experience that with you? I think that got lost probably somewhere in translation a couple of times, or maybe you didn't even want to believe that, but that was conversations we'd had before. So you just watched this sort of like a research episode?

I guess that's a way of looking at it. It's just like, that's a new one. That's interesting. I wonder what that would be like. But knowing that I was not okay. Which is why I didn't ever bring it in. No, that I was not okay with you watching. With me watching it, yes. But I think the reason I kept watching was because that was the only place I could live it out. I voiced how it made me feel. And he wasn't

willing to you know stop for me or to even be honest about it with me like I think you know if he were to come to me and say hey I'm struggling you know that would have made a world of difference it's a sad bind that you both got yourself in because he wanted to share it with you

And then once he knew that you were not open to it and turned off by it big time, he took it privately in order not to impose it on you and felt, okay, it'll be my personal sexual world. I'll have one world with you and one world with myself. And he didn't mean to not tell you, but when he told you,

there was not a good consequence so in a way he may have lied but there also was a lying invitee there was a person who said don't tell me I want you to tell me but don't tell me and then I don't know if he thinks it's a problem he thinks he found a solution I kept it to myself I didn't impose it on you I didn't ask you anymore any of this stuff what more do you want

He says, if you had loved me, you would have done this with me. You say, if you loved me, you would have stopped watching porn. Each one said to the other, if you really cared about me, you wouldn't be doing what you're doing. And how many years of this? What are we coming up on? Together? 18. 18? That's good. And I don't think he really ever explained to me why he did it. I think that's where it, to me, became the problem.

I probably didn't even fully understand it at 18, 19. I don't think I had any understanding of myself that deeply. And what did you come to understand over time? Growing up, like I never saw a lot of examples of relationships, really. I very early in my life connected sex with love. I always felt like nobody was ever going to want to be with me anyway. I literally, I can remember multiple times as a child, like,

thinking I was going to grow up alone. I never thought I was going to have a girlfriend, let alone a wife. That seemed absolutely impossible to me. Why so? As a kid, I always felt different. I don't know how to use the word. Different outside. I grew up in a very interesting family dynamic. I'm literally described as being literally the black sheep of the family.

My parents are white, all my siblings are white, cousins are white, like everyone in my family is white. And then there was just me. And so like as a kid, I just, I didn't understand why I looked different. Just knew that I was, and not that my family ever made me feel like I didn't belong or that I was an outcast, but I think I just kind of put that on myself just because I look so differently. And when you start to get friends and they come over and they,

they see you and then meet your parents and your siblings and stuff, they kind of like, "What? How does this all work?" And so I think at that point, then I started to recognize that I'm different. I go to a friend's house and everyone looks the same and come to my house and I'm just like blob. I'm not blob. I'm black, they're white. Yeah, like I'm literally the speck in like the snow. He describes being one of very few Black people in his entire community

church and school. And he also describes an entirely white family in which he is the only black person. The family has organized around a secret so much so that he knows not to ask. He knows he's black. He doesn't know why.

There was a scene, I can remember being eight years old and watching Beauty and the Beast and hearing the very first opening line of Beauty and the Beast was like, for who could ever love a beast? And I remember crying in the middle of the movie at eight years old, thinking that that was me. No one's ever going to love me because I'm this beast. And so when I found porn and everything else, I was like, oh my gosh, here's the thing where

There's black guys and white girls and everything else. There's all these different mixes and anything you can think of, it's there for you. And people are just willing and totally into it. And so it allowed me to go somewhere where I could fantasize about being accepted to that level. And so for me, it instantly became kind of a place where I could go when I didn't feel accepted, when I didn't feel loved.

Don't think I ever had it to a point where it overtook me, though, to where it's like, oh, I've got to do it. I'm doing it multiple times in a day. Hold on one moment and ask her, since she wanted to understand what was this for you, ask her how she just heard what you said. Out of all of that, what did you hear? You saw porn as love.

So to you, attraction, you know, if someone is attracted to you, they, you know, they love you. Like it's like to me, that was me. That's mainly like on a physical level. So, but to, but to me, like, and I don't know if I'm, you know, the only one who feels this way, but porn is, is not love. It's purely just people feeding others fantasies. So like you said, you can find anything you want and that's not connection. Yeah. Yeah.

She began by listening to him and then she brought the focus back onto her experience very quickly. And so as a result, she heard him talk about love, but she didn't hear him talk about the underlying, much more fundamental need, which was to be accepted. When you think of yourself as the beast, you think of places where perhaps there are others like you. Support for Where Should We Begin? comes from Squarespace.

Squarespace is an all-in-one platform that you can use to build a website and help people find your ventures. Whether you're seeking a location for your podcast, teaching language courses or selling handcrafted ceramics, Squarespace has all the tools you need to create a home on the web. You can create a polished, professional place that connects people with whatever you are excited about.

Squarespace also supports all forms of connecting with those people. Whether you're selling products online or in person, or offering memberships, you can make your website look exactly how you want it to be. They even have tools that help you create a custom logo. And they make it easy to create a place where people can schedule an appointment with you, browse your services, or learn more about why you do what you do.

Visit squarespace.com slash Esther for a free trial. When you're ready to launch, use offer code Esther to save 10% of your first purchase of a website or domain. Vitamin Water was born in New York City because New Yorkers needed a drink that can do it all. Because we can do it all. Like walk 30 blocks in under an hour, follow four of the city's sports teams at once, and spend all day in the Chinatown arcade. Drink Vitamin Water. It's from New York.

On September 28th, the Global Citizen Festival will gather thousands of people who took action to end extreme poverty. Watch Post Malone, Doja Cat, Lisa, Jelly Roll, and Raul Alejandro as they take the stage with world leaders and activists to defeat poverty, defend the planet, and demand equity. Download the Global Citizen app to watch live. Learn more at globalcitizen.org slash Vox. I felt like...

And I, to this day, tell you that if I don't feel connected to you on a higher level, like a more emotional level, I'm more withdrawn with the sexual part of it. Well, you told me just after the affairs, I think we had sex once a few weeks later or whatever. And you told me this is the first time I've ever felt connected with you when we've had sex.

And I was like, oh my gosh, like, how is that possible? Because for me, like sex for me then, like that was how I was able to connect with you. That was a blow to me. I was like, oh my God, like how? Like we've been together at this point, what, 12, 13 years? And like, this is the first time now after 12 or 13 years that you're saying like, now I feel connected to you. But that was after the affairs and we're re-spending 24 seven with each other.

Free. Well, for the first few days now. We were having deep, meaningful conversations. We were connecting on the level that I needed from the beginning. I'm like realizing right now that we kind of went backwards. Like we went, we started with sex and being, you know, that being like number one thing over versus sex.

conversation and deep meaningful connection that I needed. I feel like I was crying out the whole first, what, 15 years of our relationship to just be wanted by you other than sexually and also sexually because, you know, to me, like you were watching porn, you were looking at the pictures to me that just told me that I, I wasn't,

what you wanted, I was shut off. Not that I wanted to be, I just, I guess in a way I did it to protect myself. I don't know. - I think that was part of why like the affairs hurt me so much, was 'cause like I said, 'cause I connected. - Can I ask you to try something? 'Cause you've just listened to her and she explained to you something very, very important.

And if you hear it and you respond the way you're about to do, it still is you with yourself. I did what I did because I felt what I felt because I. And I want you to do the same exercise I asked you to just before. What did you just hear? Because your wife just said something that if you listen to it carefully, you'll actually understand her behavior over almost two decades.

Yeah, I did. I did hear one of the things you said that was kind of like an ah for me just now was like you said, like, I wanted the communication. Like, I wanted you to want me, but I wanted you to want me for like the communication. Like, I wanted you to want me for a connection, but not in a sexual sense, but like the communication. I hadn't heard it put that way before. Like, I'd heard you say like,

All I'm good for is my body and like, all you want me for is this, but I had never heard it or thought of it. Like, I want you to want me for my communication. I want you to want me for my, my conversation. I never don't know why I didn't like. Did he get it? Yeah. Yeah. For me connection. Like I wanted, you know, like a friendship and then, you know, like we talk and like,

connect on the emotional level first that was your way of showing me that you loved me but I didn't receive it that way

But you also added, it's not just I wanted you to just talk with me. I wanted you to be interested in me. But you were so busy making sure that I would be interested in you. You were so busy making sure to confirm that you will be wanted. You are lovable. That you didn't realize that you were rejecting her. Yeah. I wasn't ever doing that saying in my own head. I wasn't ever doing anything that I was viewing as like, oh, I'm choosing this over her.

but are not comfortable bringing that to you for like what it will bring up in you that, you know, like I'll just do it quietly over here. You see, you both have been operating from your own internal logic and it's been so powerful. It's been so many years, each of you consistent with your own logic, interpreting everything the other person does from that logic. And it makes sense.

From where you come from, it makes sense. And part of what I hear him say is, I'll satisfy myself. That way that's taken care of. So I don't have to come to you to be rejected by you and feel what I felt my entire childhood growing up, that nobody's going to want me. She said it much better than me. Answer that. That was what I was trying to say. The sad part is that each of you lives for 20 years feeling rejected by the other.

So after years of his finding acceptance in his own private erotics, she began to travel with his sister. They'd go to clubs. She'd hook up with strangers. They were a string of one-night stands. She makes a strong point of saying there was no penetrative sex. But hey, where does sex actually start?

What was clear is that everybody had found their own source of acceptance and it wasn't with each other. And at that moment, the conversation moved from talking about porn to talking about cheating, infidelity and betrayal. What did you learn through those experiences? What did you learn as a woman? I mean, I knew that I was craving his attention and I, you know,

I knew that that's something that I needed. And so, you know, going on these trips and getting that attention, I felt like, like it just gave me a sense of like, I still, I still do have it. Like I still do have that attraction. Like I am attractive to certain men. Like I just, cause I did not feel it from him. I more oftentimes think back of like, you know,

how ashamed I am of myself for letting, letting myself do that. Because to me, like it didn't mean anything. Like it was always a one time thing there. There was drinking involved, you know, like intoxication. I went into it fully expecting, you know, to just get a break and to get some time, you know, away from the kids and just to myself. And I remember, um,

leaving the trips just so upset that I you know that I didn't get that like that's not what it was and I think I even came home and would tell you like please don't let me go on another trip with her like just say no next time so I don't have to because anytime I would say no it was you know a push a manipulation of like oh I'll pay for it I'll pay for everything and I'm not like you know giving excuses or anything of you know why I did what I did because I

I know I had my free agency, but I was just in a vulnerable state. And I feel she knew that. And she, in a way, preyed upon that, I guess. You experienced the same with your husband as with your sister-in-law. That on some level, your sexuality ends up in the hands of the other person. Oh, yeah, I guess, yeah.

And I also feel bad because, you know, like in a way, like we both betrayed him. Like that's his sister. How could she do that to him also? What she tells is the plight of many women who don't own their sexuality and who find themselves in an experience where they feel preyed upon, where the other is the predator. Even her sister-in-law, she never really...

could own and say what she wanted. At best she tried to say what she didn't want. And part of her process now is to reclaim her sexuality and become the owner of her own eroticism. Do you see your whole experience as a negative experience? I mean, no. Like I think we were kind of stuck.

in our relationship and what I was doing wasn't working talking about it like talking about my needs and I how I felt you know that I wasn't a priority you know wasn't getting anywhere um not saying that it was the best choice to make to get unstuck but it's effective yeah um and then also like I mean somewhat of a good thing is that he learned his story from it because we

went to his parents and told them. And so I don't know if that would have ever happened. Tell me. That I was a product of an affair. And that's why I was always different. They kept that. They didn't ever want me to feel like I wasn't theirs. So they never told me growing up. They always had some of the story of like, well, we just have more Indian in our family. And I just got like the more Indian blood or whatever else. So yeah.

It took them 32 years before they finally told me. Because I went to my dad after finding out about her. And I was like, Dad, I just don't know what to do or how I handle it. He kept telling me, you stay with her. You continue to love her. I was like, Dad, I don't know how I can do that. I feel so hurt. How would you handle it? And he just basically went, well, how do you think you got here? I don't think my parents would have told me.

Otherwise, I'm pretty sure they would have both taken it to their grave. I've just been left to figure out whether it was true. What did it do to you to have them actually spell it out? I guess there's like a childish part of me that was like still wanted to hold on to like maybe I'm just this miracle baby because my dad was an incredible man. He never once made me feel like I wasn't his own son. Beautiful. And mom? Mom the same way. Like they're...

They both loved me unconditionally. But you're the one traveling around life wondering why people will never love you. Yeah, yeah. And how do you square one and one? I didn't really have any evidence to back up that I didn't belong because my family never made me feel I didn't. I think I got the, I'm different and no one's going to want to be around me more from my friends. And from the secret. Yes.

And probably from the secret that nobody wanted to talk about. The tragic part here is that in order for him not to feel different, which his parents saw as the ultimate expression of love, they denied his fundamental difference. They tried to make love colorblind rather than accept him with his difference. Do you feel that you are...

more prepared in this moment to take ownership over your sexuality so that you don't find yourself each time in compromised situations of things that you kind of want, don't really want, have to get drunk to explain. What you know is that you don't want what they want, but it's not clear that you know what you want. That makes sense. And I would like to know what I want to take ownership. Mm-hmm.

And how would that look? What would be some steps that you would take for that? That's the thing. I feel like I don't know. We've had conversations about, like I've let him know that I don't feel heard or respected. Stop. Because everything you say is what you don't. It's what you don't.

Yeah. So what you want is not expressed by what you don't want. So this is an affirmative statement. I want. So I want to be heard. I want to be, I want to feel respected by you and the kids. Like I feel like there's a lack, which turns into me losing my cool and yelling to be heard. I feel like that's the only way

that I am hurt as if I'm losing my shit. And I don't, I hate, I hate that. I do not want to be like that because that's how I grew up with my dad. What is your background? I was raised in a pretty strict LDS family. I'm the baby of nine kids, so big family. I had to follow the rules, get in trouble if I didn't. My dad had a

a pretty bad temper and and I was you know I was scared and I don't want my kids to be scared of me and he always tells me that they that they listen to me out of fear and they listen to him out of respect and I just I just I want to know how to get them to listen to me out of respect can I ask you something as the youngest of nine did you learn

to make claims or everybody spoke for you? I believe that everybody spoke for me. I've lost my voice and I'm always, like when I meet people, I'm always super quiet and reserved when in reality I'm super bubbly and funny and, you know, I don't know. I don't feel like people care too much

you know, know me or hear me. My husband doesn't care. My children don't care. New people don't care. His sister doesn't care. You too have a way of seeing the relationship world around you from a very particular lens. None of these people respect me. None of these people listen to me. None of these people pay attention to me. None of these people...

know what I want, and I would love for them to be different with me. And I'm going to invite you to change that. I actually want to ask you something that's a little bit more difficult, is what do you want? Not what you want from others, because even when you yell in order to be heard, you feel like they pushed you to yell. It's everybody's responsible for your actions, but you.

Yeah, I agree. So. Yes. Go ahead. Well, I would rather be more outgoing. I would rather just say what I want to say rather than fear how it's going to be taken or. No, no, no. Oh, sorry. That's the other one. I guess I want to be free of that. I want to feel free to be able to say what comes to my end when it does. Mm-hmm.

I want you to take a pad. I want you to ask her 10 wants so that you develop your curiosity about her. I want to say that too. Me too. Good. You just take notes. You don't breathe down her neck. You just record. If you want it too much, then she won't be able to want it because she doesn't know how to want what you want and still feel that she owns it. I'm excited to hear. I would love to know like 10 things you want. It's what you will do with each other.

It's not just what you're going to promise you won't do with others. Ironically, the only other time they had had a deep, meaningful, honest conversation about their relationship was in the immediate aftermath of their affairs, which is actually not uncommon. This was probably the second conversation, and that in itself beckons for a third.

Esther Perel is the author of Mating in Captivity and the State of Affairs, and also the host of the podcast, How's Work? To reply with your partner for a session for the podcast, or for show notes on each episode, go to whereshouldwebegin.esterperel.com. Where Should We Begin with Esther Perel is produced by Magnificent Noise for Gimlet and Esther Perel Productions.

Our production staff includes Eric Newsom, Eva Walchover, Destry Sibley, Hiwote Gatana, and Olivia Natt. Recorded by Noriko Akabe. Kristen Muller is our engineer. Original music and additional production by Paul Schneider. And the executive producers of Where Should We Begin are Esther Perel and Jesse Baker.

We would also like to thank Nazanin Rafsanjani, Courtney Hamilton, Lisa Schnall, Nick Oxenhorn, Dr. Guy Winch, and Jack Saul.