We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 1108: Sound Healing | Skeptical Sunday

1108: Sound Healing | Skeptical Sunday

2025/1/26
logo of podcast The Jordan Harbinger Show

The Jordan Harbinger Show

AI Deep Dive Transcript
People
J
Jordan Harbinger
M
Maddox
Topics
Jordan Harbinger: 我认为声音疗法声称的益处缺乏强有力的科学证据。虽然一些研究表明声音冥想对减轻压力有适度益处,但声称可以治疗严重的疾病是没有根据的。此外,声音和振动实际上可能对身体造成伤害,研究已经证明某些频率和长时间的暴露会损害神经、循环系统和其他系统。许多声音疗法从业者将合法的科学概念与伪科学主张混合在一起,经常歪曲像爱因斯坦这样的科学家的言论,并对量子物理学和细胞振动做出未经证实的陈述。声音疗法的缺乏监管也令人担忧,尤其是在孕妇和儿童等弱势人群中。FDA只对补充和替代医学提供一般指导。然而,声音疗法如果作为放松工具适当地使用,可能是有效的。研究表明,它与冥想结合使用时,可能有助于减轻压力和焦虑。对声音疗法感兴趣的人可以尝试声音冥想课程或声音浴,同时对益处保持现实的期望,并继续任何规定的医疗治疗。 Maddox: 声波疗法从业者通常使用声称与我们体内特定共振频率相调谐的水晶碗和音叉。声波疗法的一个经典特征是声称只有他们自己知道如何做,这是一种伪科学的标志。许多伪科学不仅陈述其主张,还掺杂神秘主义和垃圾科学,例如量子纠缠和脉轮。并非所有声波疗法从业者都夸大其词,有些只是声称用碗发出舒缓的声音来放松人。五元素的概念不是科学概念,它起源于公元前300年的中医,声波疗法从业者经常依赖古代智慧。声波疗法网站经常错误引用爱因斯坦的话来支持他们的观点。声波疗法的费用可能很高,包括课程费和仪器费。虽然细胞确实有共振频率,但声波疗法声称每个细胞都有独特的频率是没有根据的。除了听力损伤外,声音还会对身体造成各种问题,例如陶斯嗡嗡声。声音被用作平民环境中的威慑工具,例如针对青少年的“蚊子”装置。许多人相信声音疗法,并放弃正规医疗,这很危险,史蒂夫·乔布斯就是一个例子。声波疗法的一个危险信号是使用“毒素”一词,而不具体说明毒素是什么、如何去除。相信不相关的事件可以由外部和不相关的因素引起,这是一种魔法式思维,在医学领域可能会致命。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Are sound healers hitting the right note, or just making noise? Maddox joins us to investigate frequencies, facts, and fallacies on this Skeptical Sunday!

Welcome to Skeptical Sunday, a special edition of The Jordan Harbinger Show where Jordan and a guest break down a topic that you may have never thought about, open things up, and debunk common misconceptions. This time around, we’re joined by Maddox, the blogger behind The Best Page in the Universe) and bestselling author of The Alphabet Of Manliness), I Am Better Than Your Kids), and F*ck Whales: Also Families, Poetry, Folksy Wisdom and You)!

On This Week's Skeptical Sunday:

  • Sound healing's purported benefits lack strong scientific evidence. While some studies show modest stress reduction benefits from sound meditation, claims about treating serious medical conditions are unfounded.

  • Sound and vibration can actually cause physical harm. Research has documented damage to nerves, circulation, and other systems from certain frequencies and prolonged exposure.

  • Many sound healing practitioners mix legitimate scientific concepts with pseudoscientific claims, often misquoting scientists like Einstein and making unsubstantiated statements about quantum physics and cellular vibrations.

  • The lack of regulation in sound healing is concerning, particularly given potential risks to vulnerable populations like pregnant women and children. The FDA only provides general guidance on "complementary and alternative medicine."

  • Sound healing can be beneficial when used appropriately as a relaxation tool. Research shows it may help reduce stress and anxiety when combined with meditation. Those interested can try sound meditation classes or sound baths, while maintaining realistic expectations about benefits and continuing any prescribed medical treatments.

  • Connect with Jordan on Twitter), Instagram), and YouTube). If you have something you'd like us to tackle here on Skeptical Sunday, drop Jordan a line at [email protected]) and let him know!

  • Connect with Maddox at The Best Page in the Universe) and pick up one of his books)!

**Full show notes and resources can be found here: **jordanharbinger.com/1108)

**<a href="https://itunes.apple.com/podcast/id1344999619?mt=2&ls=1"...