Captain Coward and the Blame Game
Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford
Deep Dive
What caused the Costa Concordia to tilt and eventually capsize?
The Costa Concordia struck a rock, which tore a 150-foot gash in its side, causing it to flood and tilt. The ship eventually capsized due to the extensive damage and flooding.
Why was Captain Francesco Schettino criticized for his actions during the disaster?
Captain Schettino was criticized for delaying the evacuation order, abandoning the ship before all passengers were rescued, and failing to communicate effectively with the Coast Guard. He also claimed he 'accidentally fell' into a lifeboat, which further damaged his credibility.
How did the local deputy mayor, Mario Pellegrini, assist during the crisis?
Mario Pellegrini boarded the ship to assess the situation, helped passengers evacuate, and organized rescue efforts. He also intervened to prevent chaos during the evacuation, such as stopping a crowd from endangering a child.
What role did the cruise company play in the disaster?
The cruise company was criticized for allowing ships to deviate from official routes for 'salutes' to islands, inadequate training of crew members, and poor communication protocols. They paid a €1 million fine but faced minimal consequences compared to Captain Schettino.
How many people died in the Costa Concordia disaster?
32 people died when the Costa Concordia capsized. Most fatalities occurred during the final capsize of the ship.
What was the Coast Guard's reaction when they discovered Captain Schettino had abandoned the ship?
The Coast Guard was shocked and demanded Schettino return to the ship. Their iconic phrase, 'Vada a bordo, cazzo!' (Get the fuck on board!), became widely known after the incident.
Why was Captain Schettino sentenced to 16 years in prison?
Schettino was sentenced for manslaughter, causing a shipwreck, and abandoning his ship. His actions, including delaying the evacuation and leaving the ship before all passengers were rescued, were deemed criminal negligence.
What were the consequences for other crew members involved in the disaster?
Five other crew members, including the first and third officers and the helmsman, entered plea bargains and received short prison sentences. However, due to a technicality, they did not serve any time.
What was the public's perception of Captain Schettino after the disaster?
Schettino was widely vilified as 'Captain Coward' in the media. His personal life, including his affair with a younger crew member, and his actions during the crisis contributed to his negative public image.
What lessons can be learned from the Costa Concordia disaster?
The disaster highlights the importance of proper training, adherence to safety protocols, and clear communication during emergencies. It also underscores the dangers of deviating from planned routes and the need for accountability at all levels of an organization.
- Costa Concordia cruise ship ran aground near Giglio Island.
- Initial reactions of islanders and passengers.
- Captain Schettino's actions before and after the collision.
Shownotes Transcript