We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Are we in a constitutional crisis?

Are we in a constitutional crisis?

2025/2/11
logo of podcast Consider This from NPR

Consider This from NPR

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Amanda Frost
A
Ari Shapiro
J
J.D. Vance
P
President Trump
无发言人
Topics
Ari Shapiro: 我提出了美国是否正面临宪法危机的问题,以及如果总统拒绝遵守法院命令,司法部门的权力何在。我希望通过与法律专家的对话,探讨行政部门与司法部门之间的权力制衡问题。 Amanda Frost: 我认为,宪法危机是指一个政府部门,通常是行政部门,公然且经常地超越其宪法授权,而其他部门无法或不愿阻止这种情况。目前,特朗普政府正试图扩大行政权力,这已经对宪法构成了压力测试。虽然法院可以减缓这种扩张,但如果国会和人民不接受,法院也无法阻止。我个人认为现在美国还未进入宪法危机,但是行政部门确实有滥用职权的倾向,需要警惕。 J.D. Vance: 我在2021年表示,特朗普应该解雇所有中层官僚,并像安德鲁·杰克逊一样对抗法院。我认为法院不应该控制行政部门的合法权力,行政部门应该有更大的自主权来执行政策。 President Trump: 我认为法官应该只做裁决,不应该指挥国家如何运作。他们不应该干涉行政部门的决策,而应该专注于解决法律纠纷。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

President Trump's blizzard of executive orders has run into a snowplow of legal challenges. There are dozens of cases challenging the White House's actions. Judges all over the country have found that the White House acted illegally.The challenges, and the rulings, continue to pour in. But Trump's team is punching back. After a judge blocked Elon Musk's DOGE team from accessing personal data and other Treasury department systems, Musk referred to him as "a corrupt judge protecting corruption" and called for his impeachment.Vice President JD Vance made the controversial claim on Sunday that quote, "judges aren't allowed to control the executive's legitimate power." Comments like these suggest Trump's circle may be willing to ignore court orders and defy judicial authority.So what happens if the executive branch ignores the judicial branch? Is that a constitutional crisis? Is the United States already in one?For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org)Email us at [email protected])Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices)NPR Privacy Policy)