What makes a true Christmas movie?
Consider This from NPR
Deep Dive
What are the three tiers of Christmas movies according to NPR producer Marc Rivers?
The first tier includes movies where Christmas is the subject, and removing it would eliminate the movie (e.g., 'Elf,' 'A Christmas Story'). The second tier features movies where Christmas instigates the plot but isn't essential (e.g., 'Home Alone,' 'It's a Wonderful Life'). The third tier consists of movies where Christmas is ornamental, providing atmosphere without influencing the plot (e.g., 'Eyes Wide Shut,' 'The Apartment').
Why does Marc Rivers classify 'It's a Wonderful Life' as a second-tier Christmas movie?
Marc Rivers argues that while 'It's a Wonderful Life' culminates in a Christmas Eve celebration, the core themes of self-reflection and community could occur on any significant day, such as a birthday or New Year's. Christmas adds emotional garnish but isn't essential to the plot.
How does Marc Rivers justify 'Die Hard' as a Christmas movie?
Marc Rivers places 'Die Hard' in the second tier of Christmas movies because the plot revolves around a Christmas party. However, the story could function with any type of work party, making Christmas a backdrop rather than a central element.
What makes 'Elf' a first-tier Christmas movie according to Marc Rivers?
'Elf' is a first-tier Christmas movie because Christmas is central to its plot, featuring characters from the North Pole and themes directly tied to the holiday. The movie's sentiment feels earned and relatable, blending holiday magic with everyday struggles.
What is an example of a third-tier Christmas movie, and why does it fit this category?
An example of a third-tier Christmas movie is 'The Apartment,' where Christmas is ornamental and doesn't influence the plot. The holiday provides a cozy backdrop, reflecting how most people experience Christmas—present but not central to daily life.
Why do some people consider movies like 'Lord of the Rings' or 'Harry Potter' as Christmas movies?
Movies like 'Lord of the Rings' or 'Harry Potter' are considered Christmas movies by some because they evoke a sense of magic and nostalgia, aligning with the fantastical and intergenerational spirit of the holiday season. Families often watch them together during Christmas, creating personal traditions.
Shownotes Transcript