Her dog was left alone in the apartment for days without food or water, which was out of character for her. Additionally, there was no sign of a struggle inside the condo, and her car was missing.
The phone pings showed movement in the Asheville and Swannanoa areas, leading investigators to focus on a specific location on the outskirts of Asheville. This area became a focal point of the investigation.
A pair of women's underwear with Bethany's DNA and a male DNA was found in the car. The male DNA was in the system, and the man admitted to having sex with Bethany but claimed he didn't know her whereabouts.
She experienced a spiritual awakening and became involved in Illuminati Facebook groups and fringe podcasts. She believed someone was breaking into her house, cutting her hair, and poisoning her dog, among other things.
The internet provided her with communities and literature that reinforced her belief in being targeted. She actively researched conspiracy theories and connected her experiences to online content about gang stalking.
The safes and the $39,000 settlement money from a car accident were never found. Bethany had hidden the money at home due to her distrust of banks, and the disappearance of both raised suspicions.
The case has been reclassified from missing persons to homicide, though no concrete evidence of foul play has been found. Investigators are treating it as a potential homicide and continue to pursue leads.
The hurricane diverted resources to disaster relief, temporarily slowing the investigation. Jolinda feared that human remains could have been washed away or buried under mud, complicating the search for Bethany.
The shooting raised questions about whether Bethany could have been caught in the crossfire or involved in a drug-related incident. However, no direct connection between the shooting and her disappearance has been established.
Bethany's relationships often seemed to trigger emotional and mental health challenges. Some of the men she was involved with were considered questionable, and her mother believed one man, AJ, knew about the hidden money and may have been involved in her disappearance.
Last week, you heard Part 1 of Bethany Collins Buckles’ story. You learned about her life, struggles, and sudden disappearance just as she planned for her mother’s Thanksgiving visit. Jolinda had expected to hear from Bethany, but she grew concerned when the call didn’t come. At the time, Jolinda was in Atlanta, hours away from Bethany’s condo in Asheville. She contacted the Asheville Police Department, requesting a welfare check. Officers reported that no one was home, and Bethany’s car was missing.
When Jolinda finally arrived in Asheville, she discovered something even more troubling—Bethany’s dog had been left alone in the apartment for days without food or water, which was out of character for her daughter. Yet, there was no sign of a struggle inside the condo. Jolinda immediately reported Bethany missing, and the investigation began. Authorities traced Bethany’s phone, which appeared to be moving around the Asheville and Swannanoa areas before going radio silent.
Then, months later, in February 2022, a break in the case came when Bethany’s car was found in a grocery store parking lot not far from her Asheville condo and near where her phone had been pinging in late November. But the mystery deepened; whoever had left the car there managed to avoid detection, and no one had seen anything.
This week, we will dive deeper into the mystery of what happened to Bethany and explore why she may have been targeted. What were the circumstances leading up to her disappearance, and who might have been involved? We’ll examine the details surrounding the car’s discovery and the investigation that followed, as we search for answers to this puzzling case.
If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Bethany Collins Buckles, please contact Detective Kevin Taylor from the Asheville Police Department at 828-259-5945.
If you have a missing loved one that you would like to have featured on the show, please fill out our case submission form).
Follow The Vanished on social media at:
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy) and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info).