The case went cold due to a lack of significant leads and the assumption that Barbara may have run away, a common conclusion for missing teens at the time. Over the years, many people who might have had crucial information have passed away, making it harder to piece together the timeline and facts.
Barbara was described as very trusting, sensitive, and thoughtful. She was considerate of others' needs and had a loyal, down-to-earth nature. She was also quiet and easygoing, though she could be athletic and enjoyed activities like Chinese jump rope.
The lack of modern technology like the internet and cell phones at the time of her disappearance makes it difficult to document and track leads. Additionally, many people who were around in 1981 have since passed away, complicating the process of verifying timelines and separating facts from assumptions.
Barbara had been butting heads with her mother and had plans to move out once she turned 16. She was also saving money for that purpose, leading some to believe she might have left on her own. However, she left behind her savings, cigarettes, and other belongings, which her family and friends say is unlike her.
While DNA technology wasn't available in 1981, advancements in forensic science have given hope to families of long-missing persons. Cases that were unsolved decades ago are now being solved, which has encouraged efforts to revisit Barbara's case with modern investigative tools.
Barbara came from a large, tumultuous family where her father was an alcoholic and there was frequent fighting. Some siblings were sexually abused by their father, including Barbara. This environment likely influenced her quiet, reserved nature and her eventual drift from some family members as she grew older.
Barbara and her mother had been having disagreements, particularly over Barbara's desire to move out and grow up faster. However, her mother reported that they had a good interaction the night before Barbara disappeared, suggesting a temporary resolution to their conflicts.
Barbara left behind her savings, a carton of cigarettes, and other personal belongings. Her friends and family believe she would not have left without preparing, as she was a loyal person who valued her family and would not have left them hanging without contact for 40 years.
Initially, many in the community believed Barbara had run away due to her disagreements with her mother and her plans to move out. However, as time passed and no contact was made, the community began to question this theory and rallied behind efforts to find her, including the creation of a billboard to raise awareness.
The podcast host, James Wallner, took an interest in Barbara's case after seeing it listed as a cold case on the North Dakota Attorney General's website. He worked to gather information, interview those close to Barbara, and piece together the timeline, bringing renewed attention and hope to the case.
On April 11, 1981, 15-year-old Barbara Cotton vanished without a trace from Williston, North Dakota. Her mother, Louise, immediately began contacting Barbara’s friends, hoping to learn to find her. When no one had seen her, Louise reported her daughter missing to the Williston Police Department and passed along any tips she received. However, as the weeks and months passed, there was no sign of Barbara, and the case went cold. To those closest to her, it seemed as though little was being done to locate her, fueling their suspicions that the investigation was stagnant. The prevailing assumption at the time was that Barbara may have run away, a common conclusion for missing teens in that era.
However, decades later, the case remains unsolved, and there is now a renewed push to uncover the truth behind Barbara Cotton’s disappearance. Many questions remain unanswered, and the search for answers continues.
If you have any information about Barbara Cotton’s disappearance, please contact the Williston Police Department at 701-577-1212.
You can follow Barb’s story on social media at Find Barb Cotton. You can find more information at FindBarbCotton.com), and check out Dakota Spotlight) wherever you get your podcasts.
Support us by supporting our sponsors!
If you have a missing loved one that you would like to have featured on the show, please fill out our case submission form).
Follow The Vanished on social media at:
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy) and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info).