We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Ashworth out & Sir Jim Ratcliffe talks to Andy

Ashworth out & Sir Jim Ratcliffe talks to Andy

2024/12/9
logo of podcast Talk of the Devils - A show about Manchester United

Talk of the Devils - A show about Manchester United

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Andy Mitten
C
Carl Anka
K
Karel Dvarov
L
Laurie Whitwell
主持人
专注于电动车和能源领域的播客主持人和内容创作者。
Topics
Andy Mitten: 对Jim Ratcliffe爵士的采访中,他表示曼联犯了一些错误,但尼斯和洛桑的经验使他们在曼联的运营中受益。他承认曼联在票价问题上犯了错误,并表示未来会有更多变化。他评价了Omar Barada和Ruben Amorim,但对Dan Ashworth和Jason Wilcox只字未提。Ratcliffe是一个自信、直接且善于社交的人,他愿意与球迷沟通,并承认俱乐部亏损严重,需要做出改变。 Laurie Whitwell: Dan Ashworth在曼联仅仅工作了五个月就离职,这令人震惊。Ashworth离职是曼联方面发起的,尽管俱乐部称之为“双方同意”。主教练的任命是Ashworth离职的一个重要因素,因为Ashworth推荐的人选与俱乐部最终选择的主教练不同。Ashworth和Barada在利物浦赛前发布会上关于滕哈赫续约的言论让Ratcliffe感到不满。Barada的影响力日益增强,这可能是精简组织结构的一种方式。 Carl Anka: Ashworth在试用期结束后只工作了五个月就离职并获得遣散费,这很糟糕。Ashworth在不同俱乐部的工作经历表明,他的能力在不同环境下表现不同。Jim Ratcliffe可能对Ashworth的工作方式感到失望,因为体育总监并非魔法师。曼联目前的问题更多的是俱乐部文化、环境、战略、投资和领导力,而不是个人能力。曼联对阵诺丁汉森林的比赛中,表现令人失望,尤其是在防守方面。阿莫林正在尝试不同的战术和球员轮换,但曼联的定位球防守存在问题。尽管曼联输球了,但他们的进攻依然具有威胁性,球员们相信他们的战术,尽管他们还没有完全掌握。曼联将经历一个动荡的时期,直到他们确定自己的目标。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Dan Ashworth leave Manchester United after just five months?

Dan Ashworth left Manchester United after five months due to a combination of factors, including disagreements over the appointment of a head coach and his lack of assertiveness in decision-making. Sir Jim Ratcliffe, the club's owner, was reportedly underwhelmed by parts of Ashworth's approach, leading to a mutual decision for him to leave.

What was the cost of hiring and then letting go of Dan Ashworth?

Dan Ashworth's hiring and subsequent departure cost Manchester United a significant amount, including the £3 million paid to secure him from Newcastle and potential severance pay. The club also spent five months on gardening leave before he officially joined.

How did Sir Jim Ratcliffe view Dan Ashworth's performance?

Sir Jim Ratcliffe was reportedly underwhelmed by Dan Ashworth's performance, particularly in his role in the head coach appointment process. Ratcliffe felt Ashworth was not assertive enough in pushing for specific candidates, leading to dissatisfaction with his contributions.

What role did Omar Barada play in the decision to let Dan Ashworth go?

Omar Barada, the club's chief executive, played a significant role in the decision to let Dan Ashworth go. Barada was instrumental in the appointment of Ruben Amorim as head coach, which Ashworth reportedly disagreed with. Barada's influence and relationship with Ratcliffe were key factors in the decision.

What was the reaction to Dan Ashworth's departure within the club?

Dan Ashworth's departure shocked many within Manchester United, particularly at Carrington, where he was regarded as the main figure leading the sporting side of the club. The mutual decision, while framed as amicable, left a gap in the club's leadership structure.

How did Manchester United honor Kath Phipps, the club's longest-serving staff member?

Manchester United honored Kath Phipps with black armbands, a minute's applause, and personal tributes from players during a match. Phipps, who served the club for over 55 years, was deeply loved and respected by everyone at the club, including former players like David Beckham and Ryan Giggs.

What were the key issues in Manchester United's 2-3 loss to Nottingham Forest?

Manchester United's loss to Nottingham Forest was marked by poor set-piece defending, a goalkeeping error by Andre Onana, and a lack of physicality in defense. The team conceded three soft goals, which undermined their overall performance despite some positive attacking play.

How did Ruben Amorim's rotation policy affect Manchester United's performance against Nottingham Forest?

Ruben Amorim's rotation policy, which saw several changes to the starting lineup, contributed to a lack of cohesion and defensive stability. The decision to substitute Bruno Fernandes with 15 minutes left also raised questions, as it disrupted the team's attacking momentum.

What challenges does Manchester United face in their upcoming Europa League match against Viktoria Pilsen?

Manchester United face a competitive Viktoria Pilsen side known for their functional tactics and unbeaten record in UEFA Cup games. The Czech team, led by experienced coach Miroslav Koubek, poses a threat with players like Pavel Schulz, who is in good goal-scoring form.

Chapters
The unexpected exit of Sporting Director Dan Ashworth after only five months is discussed. The reasons behind his departure are explored, focusing on potential conflicts and differing opinions regarding managerial appointments. The optics of this costly dismissal are also heavily criticized.
  • Dan Ashworth left Manchester United after five months.
  • His departure was described as 'mutual' but instigated by the club.
  • The decision was influenced by disagreements over managerial appointments.
  • The club's actions are deemed as having poor optics and costly.

Shownotes Transcript

After a tumultuous, albeit entirely precedented, weekend at Manchester United football club we break down two huge exclusives involving the team.

On Sunday The Athletic's David Ornstein, Adam Crafton, and Laurie Whitwell combined to reveal that Sporting Director Dan Ashworth would leave after just five months in the job. Meanwhile, Andy Mitten published a lengthy and wide-ranging conversation with club minority owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe.

We also take time, as everyone at Old Trafford did before the defeat to Nottingham Forest, to share tributes to the club's longest-serving staff member (perhaps ever), the much-loved Kath Phipps.

We just about found time to talk about some football, much of which wasn't great; but was it all that bad?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)