We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Maguire header beats Leicester as Dorgu debuts (on the right!)

Maguire header beats Leicester as Dorgu debuts (on the right!)

2025/2/10
logo of podcast Talk of the Devils - A show about Manchester United

Talk of the Devils - A show about Manchester United
AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Andy
REAL AF 播客主持人，专注于讨论和分析时事新闻和政治事件。
C
Carl
Topics
Carl:我对阿莫林买入左边后卫却让他打右边后卫,并在半场休息时换下他的做法感到困惑。在新闻发布会上,没有人问阿莫林为什么半场休息时换下多尔古。多尔古在比赛中站在右侧,阿莫林一直在与他交流,指示他如何跑位和防守。我曾认为阿莫林让多尔古在右路是为了方便指导,下半场可能会换到左路,但最终他半场就被换下了。阿莫林说他并非有意安排多尔古在右路,只是注意到卢克·托马斯那边有些空档,认为通过多和多尔古交流会有帮助,并提到多尔古只和球队进行了三次训练。我不希望再看到多尔古打右边后卫,我认为阿莫林把事情复杂化了。阿莫林很会说话,但他让事情变得比实际更复杂。阿莫林经常让球员踢不擅长的位置,这让人觉得他把事情搞复杂了。曼联很难将球从本方禁区运到对方禁区边缘,而阿莫林希望通过三后卫和边后卫来完成这一任务。达洛特更喜欢用他的强力脚,这导致他在控球时需要额外的触球,从而减缓了进攻速度。曼联的中场球员不擅长带球推进。最简单的解决方案是让边后卫能够舒服地用他们的强侧脚接球,并让边锋上下跑动。阿莫林似乎在让事情变得比实际更困难。阿莫林的一些战术决策更像是忠诚度测试,而不是明智的战术选择。阿莫林在替换利桑德罗·马丁内斯方面做得不错,让马斯拉维踢左中卫。阿莫林知道如何解决一些问题,但同时也制造了一些额外的问题。 Andy Mitten:阿莫林善于沟通,但比赛结果却往往不如人意。多尔古在糟糕的上半场表现中并非最差,他展现了一些速度和双脚能力。曼联最终晋级了,我们不应该对多尔古过于苛刻。除非阿莫林下周安排奥纳纳打10号位,否则球迷们对多尔古的位置安排感到困惑。阿莫林认为他可以采用类似于滕哈格的战术,但他希望直接改变体系,并承认今年会很困难。曼联球迷对球队的现状感到失望,并经常提到球队的体系问题。加纳乔替补上场改变了比赛,他像一个真正的边锋一样发挥作用。曼联的体系并不稳定,进球不多,阿莫林可能需要时间来证明他的体系是正确的。曼联在杯赛中取得了一些成绩,但球队的表现仍然令人担忧。阿莫林的体系在正确的情况下会非常精彩和有效,我们在葡萄牙体育队身上看到了这一点。阿莫林的战术风格需要聪明的球员和高水平的比赛理解力。阿莫林的战术风格不适合曼联的历史和现有球员的风格。如果一切顺利,阿莫林的战术会很棒。曼联在老特拉福德的表现很糟糕,经常被实力较弱的球队压制。球迷希望看到球队踢得精彩,否则球票需求会下降。

Deep Dive

Chapters
The podcast discusses the controversial decision by Manchester United's manager, Ruben Amorim, to play the new left-sided winger, Patrick Dorgu, on the right wing during his debut. The panelists analyze Amorim's explanation and the tactical implications of this choice, referencing Wyscout data and comparing it to past managerial decisions. They debate whether this was a strategic move or an overcomplication of the game.
  • Ruben Amorim's decision to play Dorgu on the right wing was questioned by many.
  • Amorim's explanation was that he wanted to be closer to Dorgu to coach him.
  • Wyscout data revealed Dorgu had played more games on the left.
  • The panelists discussed whether this decision was an overcomplication of the game.

Shownotes Transcript

Harry Maguire was the hero at Old Trafford on Friday night as Manchester United progressed to the fifth round of the FA Cup in entirely uncontroversial fashion... well, that's not entirely true.

Yes, it was offside, but that's not the controversy we're talking about. What we want to know (as do many listeners) is why Ruben Amorim played his new left-sided winger on the right!

Patrick Dorgu played 45 minutes at right wing-back before he became a half-time substitute for Alejandro Garnacho, with the Argentinian injecting pace and purpose into what had been a dour performance. Meanwhile, his compatriot Lisandro Martinez is facing up to a long rehab after confirmation of an injury to his anterior cruciate ligament.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)