Note from Elie 5/23: Letitia James Started It, but Trump's Payback Isn't the Answer
09:30 Share

Support for this show comes from Pure Leaf Iced Tea. When you find yourself in the afternoon slump, you need the right thing to make you bounce back. You need Pure Leaf Iced Tea. It's real brewed tea made in a variety of bold flavors with just the right amount of naturally occurring caffeine. You're left feeling refreshed and revitalized, so you can be ready to take on what's next. The next time you need to hit the reset button, grab a Pure Leaf Iced Tea. Time for a tea break? Time for a Pure Leaf.

Hey everyone, Ellie here, wishing you a happy Friday. Happy Memorial Day, Friday. Hope you have a really nice long weekend, restful long weekend ahead. It's graduation season. It's prom season. We've got both of those coming up in my house. I said this, I think two years ago when my son, my older son graduated. Now my youngest child, my daughter is on her way to graduating in a couple of weeks. They don't prepare you for this part as a parent. I mean, there's plenty about what to expect when you're expecting and what it's like to have a baby and all that.

But the thing that nobody really writes about or gets you prepped for is when the kids leave the house. So I'm dealing with it my ways. I'm flipping through old videos. Do people do that? I'm going back to videos from when they were

three and five and all that. It seems like a different lifetime. Anyway, those of you who are experiencing this as well, I'm sure there are a lot of you out there. I think a lot of our listeners are around the age I'm at and have children around the age of mine. I hear you, I'm with you. It's not easy, but it's also a time to be happy and celebrate. Okay, those are my deep thoughts. Now onto this week's piece. Hope you enjoy. Please send your thoughts, questions, and comments to lettersatcafe.com. ♪♪♪

It's a fact beyond reasonable dispute that Letitia James weaponized her official power as New York's attorney general to pursue Donald Trump for political purposes. It's equally clear that the Trump administration is now targeting James for payback. The downward spiral of prosecutorial retribution has begun and there will be no winners.

James started it when she ran for New York AG and won in 2018, primarily on an explicit platform of vote for me, fellow resistance warriors, and I'll nail Donald Trump. James tweeted that if elected, she would be leading the resistance against Donald Trump in New York City. She solicited campaign donations by vowing to take down the president. Before she had access to any evidence,

James declared conclusively that Trump, quote, engaged in a pattern and practice of money laundering and, quote, can be indicted for criminal offenses. The day after she won office, still having seen no actual evidence, the new AG exalted, quote, we're going to definitely sue him. We're going to be a real pain in the ass. He's going to know my name personally, end quote. For what?

Who knows? Just something. James did sue Trump, of course, and she won for the moment. After a circus-like bench trial focused on Trump's habitual overvaluation of his assets in bank loan applications, New York State Judge Arthur Angoran found Trump civilly liable for fraud and slammed him with damages amounting to over $500 million, including continually mounting interest. During the trial, James made a series of whispers.

wildly inappropriate out-of-court statements that would ordinarily get a prosecutor fired. At one point, she publicly branded Trump and his family members as liars while they were testifying. Despite the judge's verdict, James' theory of liability was so flimsy that it barely concealed her previously acknowledged motivation to stick one to Trump by any means available. The purported fraud victims...

were multi-billion dollar banks who were repaid in full on their loans to the Trump organization and made millions in profits through interest payments. Unsurprisingly, a New York appellate division panel voiced pointed skepticism of James's victimless case and seems poised to either substantially reduce the verdict or to throw it out altogether.

Just months after the verdict, Trump won the 2024 election, a result that was in some immeasurable but significant part a popular rejection of the overkill tactics deployed by James and other prosecutors who filed criminal charges against him. Before and after he won, Trump, like James,

made no secret of his passion for blood sport. He constantly vowed retribution on the campaign trail against his prosecutorial and judicial tormentors, including by name James N. N'Goran. And now his administration is working hard towards that ignoble goal. On April 13th, about a month ago, seemingly out of nowhere, Trump posited on social media that James was, quote, a totally corrupt politician and, quote, a wacky crook.

The very next day, Trump-nominated Federal Housing Finance Agency Director Bill Pulte sent a formal referral letter to the Justice Department. Pulte wrote that, quote,

White House advisor Stephen Miller offered an inflammatory take that paralleled James's uninformed, conclusory declarations years before. Miller said, quote, she is guilty of multiple significant serial criminal violations.

Pulte's allegations focus on two properties. First, he claims that in 2023, James bought a property in Virginia and falsely claimed in the paperwork that it would be her primary residence, which would result in lower interest rates. And according to Pulte's referral, James repeatedly certified falsely that a five-unit building she owns in Brooklyn contains only four units. Certain favorable loans are available only to owners of buildings with four or fewer units.

James has denied wrongdoing. An AG's office spokesperson called the investigation, quote, weaponization and declared that James, quote, will not be intimidated by bullies no matter who they are. James herself publicly dismissed the allegations as baseless.

James's personal attorney, Abby Lowell, who has made a career representing high-profile political players, including Hunter Biden, offered an impassioned but nuanced response in a letter to Attorney General Pam Bondi and the Justice Department. Lowell concedes that James's paperwork did contain certain mistaken statements,

but argues that they were both inadvertent and insignificant. Lowell explains that James was helping her niece buy the property in Virginia and that James had made clear elsewhere in the paperwork that the home would not be her primary residence. And Lowell notes that the property in Brooklyn was in fact used as a four-unit dwelling, not five, and that official city paperwork at certain points stated that the building had four units.

The FBI confirmed this week that they're on the case. Director Kash Patel said during a Fox News interview, which apparently is how the administration now makes its formal announcements. This case, I can tell you, is being handled by our professional pros who are subject matter experts reporting directly to headquarters.

Well then, our professional pros, they got the heavy hitters on this one. James has again displayed dubious ethical instincts in her response to the pending inquiry. She has inexplicably chosen to use the resources of her public office, the AG's office, to respond to the investigation. James issued a statement through the AG's official spokesperson, and she reportedly plans to use state funds to cover at least some of her legal expenses. This is a dreadful,

idea. By dragging the AG's office into her personal mess, James has made some of her colleagues into potential witnesses and subjected them to subpoenas. Prosecutors might ask the AG's spokesperson, for example, what James initially said to him or her about the allegations. There's no privilege there. And it's unclear how the AG can justify using New York state taxpayer money to fund her personal criminal defense.

I have no idea if James ultimately will find herself on the other side of an indictment. The former prosecutor in me sees Pulte's allegations as something more than frivolous, but decidedly less than compelling at this point. Then again, Trump has openly pined for a payback prosecution, and it's hard to envision Bondi and the Justice Department denying him the thrill of retribution in the name of measured prosecutorial discretion.

If the feds do indict James, they're going to have a hellacious time convicting her. The evidence as we currently know it is decidedly mixed, whereas prosecutors must ultimately prove criminal intent beyond a reasonable doubt. And James remains a popular political figure in New York who has twice been elected comfortably to statewide office as AG in 2018 and then in 2022. It'll be tough finding a jury willing to convict her unanimously.

James was wrong to target Trump politically from her perch as AG, but that gives Trump no license to pay her back with an equally ill-motivated prosecution. Weaponization is no antidote to weaponization. James started this retributive mess, but this is no way to end it. Thanks for listening, everyone. Stay safe and stay informed.