We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 19: Bret Weinstein - The Prediction and the DISC

19: Bret Weinstein - The Prediction and the DISC

2020/1/18
logo of podcast The Portal

The Portal
AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
B
Brett Weinstein
E
Eric Weinstein
Topics
Eric Weinstein: 本期节目的核心是讲述其弟弟Brett Weinstein的学术生涯，以及其在科学界遭遇的阻碍。Eric Weinstein认为Brett Weinstein是一位杰出的生物学家，其研究成果具有重要意义，但却被学术界低估。他认为Brett Weinstein在Evergreen州立学院的经历以及其公众形象掩盖了他的真实成就。他希望通过本期节目，让Brett Weinstein讲述其真实经历，并帮助他重回学术界。 Brett Weinstein: Brett Weinstein讲述了其在Evergreen州立学院的经历，以及其在学术研究中遭遇的阻碍。他承认其在Evergreen州立学院的经历使其获得了公众的关注，但也对其学术生涯造成了负面影响。他认为其研究成果具有重要意义，但却被学术界低估。他详细讲述了其研究生阶段的研究，以及其研究成果被学术界忽视的原因。他认为同行评审制度存在缺陷，并对一些知名科学家的评价表达了不满。 Richard Dawkins: Richard Dawkins对Brett Weinstein的评价未能充分肯定其在生物学领域的贡献。 Carol Greider: Carol Greider对Brett Weinstein的研究成果的评价存在前后矛盾之处。她最初对Brett Weinstein的研究成果持否定态度，但在获得诺贝尔奖后，却在诺贝尔演讲中表达了对其研究成果的肯定。她对Brett Weinstein的研究成果的评价以及其行为，体现了学术界中存在的思想压制现象。 George Williams: George Williams对Brett Weinstein的研究成果给予了高度评价。 Leonard Hayflick: Leonard Hayflick对Brett Weinstein的研究成果给予了肯定。 Bob Trivers: Bob Trivers是Brett Weinstein的导师之一，对Brett Weinstein的学术能力给予了肯定。 Richard Alexander: Richard Alexander是Brett Weinstein的导师之一，对Brett Weinstein的学术能力给予了高度评价。 Sam Harris: Sam Harris对Evergreen州立学院事件的评论帮助Brett Weinstein认清了事件的荒谬性。

Deep Dive

Chapters
Eric Weinstein introduces the episode, highlighting its importance and the unconventional nature of the interview with his brother, Brett Weinstein.

Shownotes Transcript

All of our Mice are Broken. On this episode of The Portal, Bret and Eric sit down alone with each other for the first time in public. There was no plan.

There was however, a remarkable story of science at its both best and worst that had not been told in years. After an initial tussle, we dusted off the cobwebs and decided to reconstruct it raw and share it with you, our Portal audience, for the first time. I don't think it will be the last as we are now again looking for our old notes to tighten it up for the next telling. We hope you find it interesting, and that it inspires you younger and less established scientists to tell your stories using this new medium of long form podcasting. We hope the next place you hear this story will be in a biology department seminar room in perhaps Cambridge, Chicago, Princeton, the Bay Area or elsewhere. Until then, be well and have a listen to this initial and raw version.

Our Sponsors:

Quip: Getquip.com/portal

Wine Access: Wineaccess.com/portal

Indeed: Indeed.com/portal

Blinkist: Blinkist.com/portal

See omnystudio.com/listener) for privacy information.