We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Why Apple Fell Off: They Lost Taste!

Why Apple Fell Off: They Lost Taste!

2024/12/14
logo of podcast All-In Podcast

All-In Podcast

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
(
(未指名发言人)
Topics
近年来,苹果公司产品,特别是iOS系统,出现了一些严重影响用户体验的bug。我认为这反映出苹果公司在软件测试流程上的不足,缺乏有效的质量控制机制。 苹果公司似乎失去了曾经对产品设计和用户体验的敏锐“品味”,这在过去是其成功的关键因素之一。如今,他们更依赖数据分析来衡量产品的成功与否,但数据本身并不能完全替代对用户需求和审美趋势的深入理解。 缺乏“品味”作为支撑,又没有像其他科技公司那样建立完善的数据分析机制作为补充,导致苹果公司产品出现问题时难以及时发现和解决。 乔布斯和艾维的离职,无疑对苹果公司的产品设计和用户体验造成了影响。虽然公司内部可能仍然有一些人认为自己拥有良好的“品味”,但缺乏像乔布斯和艾维那样具有前瞻性和创新性的领导者,使得苹果公司在产品设计上失去了方向。 在科技行业,真正拥有对用户体验“品味”的人才非常稀少。仅仅依靠数据分析,并不能完全避免产品出现问题。即使是像Facebook这样的公司,也更依赖数据分析,而不是完全依靠“品味”来保证产品质量。 总而言之,苹果公司产品质量下降的原因是多方面的,既有软件测试流程上的不足,也有对产品“品味”的把握能力下降,以及对数据分析的过度依赖。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

My iPhone does not work. I'm sorry. I'm just going to say it. Okay. I don't know what happened. You upgraded your software. What happened? You're on iOS 18. It doesn't work. The phone bricks constantly. My photos app doesn't work. It is just really bad. And I think for a company of this scale, I don't understand how it does not go through a more complicated test harness that catches all of this. There's no arbiter.

of taste anymore, who is the backstop. - So I think taste is great if you have it, but there's only so many people on the planet that are gonna have cutting edge taste and be right. If you don't have taste, what most tech companies do is they use data. Data is something that's approachable and leverageable. Because Apple has the antibodies to using data to measure success with the user experience, to measure whatever success. - Hmm.

If you subtract taste even by a bit, you don't have the scaffolding that every other company would use. And so you see the worst of both worlds. That's a great take.

You go off the rails. You think that what happened is like when Steve Jobs isn't there and Johnny Ive isn't there, there's still a bunch of folks that probably think they have taste, but the real taste folks left and there's really no scaffolding left. The scaffolding you had at Facebook Meta, obviously, or the Google uses would catch some of this stuff without a doubt, like no doubt about it. You know that users are less thrilled and they'd use things less and you'd fix it.

And maybe even you take that to a stream, you never develop taste. Like I could argue that about Google or Meta. They don't really have taste. If you don't have that backstop, if the taste attracts even 10%, not all the way down, you're just not going to catch this stuff. And I think there's only like how many people in the world really have cutting edge technology user experience taste? I don't know too many. I would fund them right away. Brian Chesky might have it.

If I'm being really insecure, I would want to say, oh, yeah, no, we had a lot of taste at Facebook back in the day. But actually, we had so much scaffolding around data, probably because intuitively, we knew that that was way more reliable for us.