In Conversation: Critical Race Theory and Black Lives Matter
New Books in Critical Theory
Deep Dive
Why should Muslims care about Critical Race Theory (CRT)?
CRT helps understand how racism operates in institutions and society, addressing issues like systemic racism, intersectionality, and the disproportionate impact on Black people. Muslims, especially Black Muslims, are affected by these systems, making CRT relevant for understanding and addressing injustice.
Why are Black Muslims often seen as Black first before being recognized as Muslim?
This is due to ignorance about the rich history of Islam in Africa, where it spread through trade and was embraced willingly. The misconception that Black Muslims are converts rather than having a lineage of Muslims perpetuates this view.
Why do some Muslims reject Critical Race Theory as incompatible with Islam?
Some reject CRT because of its non-Muslim origins or perceived Marxist influences. However, Muslims should focus on the theory's ability to understand and address racism, which aligns with the Quranic imperative to fight for justice.
Why is there a disconnect between traditional Muslim scholars and young Muslims regarding CRT and Black Lives Matter?
The disconnect stems from a lack of nuance among traditional scholars and a growing alignment of young Muslims with left-wing values. This has led to debates where scholars adopt right-wing vernacular, further alienating young Muslims.
Why do some Muslims oppose participating in Black Lives Matter protests?
Some Muslims oppose BLM protests due to concerns about its stance on LGBTQ issues, family values, and perceived anti-Islamic elements. However, many young Muslims see the movement as a platform for justice and are willing to separate the slogan from the broader movement's ideology.
Why is the slogan 'All Lives Matter' seen as problematic in response to 'Black Lives Matter'?
'All Lives Matter' is seen as problematic because it derails the specific call for justice for Black people, who have historically faced systemic racism and police brutality. The slogan emerged as a response to BLM, attempting to undermine the urgency of addressing Black suffering.
Why do some Muslims argue against toppling statues like Cecil Rhodes or Churchill?
Some argue against toppling statues based on the Quranic injunction against abusing idols, fearing retaliation against God. However, these statues are not idols but figures celebrated for their contributions, making the argument less applicable.
Why is it important to teach colonial history in schools?
Teaching colonial history is crucial to understanding the full impact of Britain's role in slavery and colonialism. Many people are unaware of the historical figures' problematic actions, such as Churchill's comments or Gandhi's racism, highlighting the need for a decolonized curriculum.
Shownotes Transcript