Democrats already had Joe Rogan, who endorsed Bernie Sanders in 2020 and supports leftist policies. The issue is that the Democratic Party doesn't understand the media landscape, especially the YouTube and content creator ecosystem, which the right has invested decades and billions of dollars into building.
The right has invested heavily in influencer-driven media for decades, creating a network of funders, organizations, and collaborations like the Daily Wire and Barstool Sports. This ecosystem is supported by cross-pollination and outreach, which the left lacks. Additionally, progressive content creators, who dominate the left online, are often anti-capitalist and not aligned with Democratic Party interests.
Kamala Harris likely avoided Joe Rogan because of his vaccine skepticism and controversial views. However, engaging with such platforms is essential for reaching broader audiences, as seen with Bernie Sanders' appearance on Rogan's show, which was politically expedient despite criticism.
Progressive content creators often have anti-capitalist and anti-billionaire views, which conflict with the Democratic Party's reliance on funding from wealthy donors. Additionally, these creators are not interested in toeing the party line, making them less useful to the Democrats despite their cultural relevance.
Taylor Lorenz left The Washington Post after her editor, Mark Seibel, retired. She had always wanted to go independent and own her work, as she felt constrained by traditional media structures. Her decision was also influenced by the Post's internal changes and her desire to prioritize her own brand and career over institutional interests.
The right has built a comprehensive online media ecosystem, investing in influencer-driven platforms like YouTube and podcasts. They engage with content creators, court them, and integrate them into their broader political strategy, creating a network of influence that mobilizes voters and shapes narratives.
TikTok played a minor role in the 2024 election, primarily as a platform for discussion and debate. However, its political influence is suppressed due to government scrutiny, and it has pivoted away from overt political content to focus on entertainment and shopping.
The left struggles to engage with online creators because progressive influencers often challenge Democratic policies and are not aligned with the party's interests. Additionally, the left lacks the funding and collaborative infrastructure that the right has built over decades.
One take you may have heard after the election: Democrats need their own Joe Biden.
Taylor Lorenz disagrees. And Lorenz is worth listening to. For years, she has been a really sharp observer of social media and online spaces, and she built a high-profile career explaining the internet for audiences at places like the Atlantic, the New York Times and the Washington Post.
Now Lorenz is on her own, which is where she says she always wanted to end up. We talked about how and why she left the Post this year. And how she’s thinking about building her career without the advantages – and disadvantages — that come from working for a big organization.
But first we talk about the podcast election (which was also the YouTube election) and where she thinks the Harris campaign went wrong. And why she thinks liberals don’t need their own Rogan — and why they can’t get one, anyway.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)