We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Taking Stock of the Year in Adaptations

Taking Stock of the Year in Adaptations

2024/12/18
logo of podcast Book Riot - The Podcast

Book Riot - The Podcast

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
J
Jeff O'Neill
R
Rebecca Shinsky
Topics
Jeff O'Neill: 2024年是改编作品的高峰期,但改编作品的来源已经从热门作品转向了冷门作品。漫威电影宇宙正面临挑战,新内容的表现不如预期。 在电影方面,《沙丘2》和《爱在劫难逃》是2024年最成功的电影改编作品,《沙丘2》在艺术性和对电影的贡献方面优于《爱在劫难逃》,但后者在商业上取得了更大的成功。 在电视剧方面,《幕府将军》是2024年最成功的电视剧改编作品,《里普利》虽然是一部优秀的电视剧改编作品,但由于此前已有许多改编版本,其影响力受到限制。《龙之家族》第二季和《力量之戒》第二季虽然制作精良,但并未突破其核心粉丝群体之外的影响力。 一些改编作品未能达到预期,例如《空中霸王》电视剧改编未能达到预期,其节奏和人物刻画存在问题;《莫斯科绅士》电视剧改编未能成功地捕捉到原著小说的精髓,其节奏和人物刻画存在问题;《同谋者》电视剧改编未能成功,其故事情节和人物刻画存在问题;《唐人街内部》电视剧改编未能成功地捕捉到原著小说的精髓,其故事情节和人物刻画存在问题。 希望查尔斯·余能继续创作小说,而不是专注于电视剧创作。 Rebecca Shinsky: 流媒体平台已经改编了大部分热门作品,因此改编作品的来源开始转向冷门作品,这使得改编作品更加多样化。2024年漫改电影的表现参差不齐,一些取得了巨大成功,另一些则票房惨败。 《Wicked》电影是根据音乐剧改编,而音乐剧又是根据小说改编,因此它算作是二次改编,其成功主要归功于其音乐,而非其故事情节或改编本身。 除了《Wicked》,2024年最成功的电影改编作品是《沙丘2》和《爱在劫难逃》,《爱在劫难逃》电影改编虽然原著小说质量不高,但电影改编更易于接受,并且忠实于原著,获得了巨大的商业成功,但其缺乏娱乐性,使其难以获得持久的粉丝群体。 《回归》是一部优秀的电影改编作品,其演员阵容和故事情节都非常出色,成功地捕捉到了原著小说的精髓,并对其进行了精彩的演绎。 在电视剧方面,《帕奇门科》是一部优秀的电视剧改编作品,但其节奏缓慢和文化背景使其难以被大众接受。《慢马》第四季是一部优秀的电视剧改编作品,其质量稳定可靠。《三体》是一部有缺陷但仍值得观看的电视剧改编作品。 《阿盖尔》电影改编遭遇了票房惨败,其宣传与实际表现之间存在巨大差距。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What was the most commercially successful movie adaptation of 2024?

The most commercially successful movie adaptation of 2024 was 'It Ends With Us,' which earned $148 million at the U.S. box office against a $50 million budget. It also became number one on Netflix shortly after its streaming release.

Why is 'Wicked' considered a controversial adaptation?

'Wicked' is considered a controversial adaptation because it is based on the musical, which itself is an adaptation of Gregory Maguire's book. The film is more closely tied to the musical than the original book, leading to debates about its classification as a literary adaptation.

What was the most critically acclaimed movie adaptation of 2024?

The most critically acclaimed movie adaptation of 2024 was 'Dune Part 2,' which is expected to be a strong contender for multiple Oscars. It is praised for its cinematic quality and contribution to the art of filmmaking.

Which TV adaptation is expected to win multiple awards in 2024?

The TV adaptation expected to win multiple awards in 2024 is 'Shogun,' which is highly regarded for its production design, pacing, and acting. It is considered a frontrunner for Emmy awards.

What was the biggest box office disappointment in 2024?

The biggest box office disappointment in 2024 was 'Argyle,' which made only $45 million against a $200 million production budget. The film failed to meet expectations despite significant hype and rumors surrounding Taylor Swift's involvement.

Why did 'Masters of the Air' fail to live up to expectations?

'Masters of the Air' failed to live up to expectations because it lacked the cohesive storytelling and character attachment that made 'Band of Brothers' successful. The show focused too much on different characters each episode, making it difficult for viewers to connect with any single storyline.

What made 'The Return' stand out as a movie adaptation in 2024?

'The Return' stood out as a movie adaptation in 2024 due to its faithful yet fresh take on 'The Odyssey.' The film, starring Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche, was praised for its intense performances, particularly in the climactic scenes, and its ability to modernize the ancient story while maintaining its essence.

What challenges did 'Pachinko' face as a TV adaptation?

'Pachinko' faced challenges as a TV adaptation due to its quiet, character-driven narrative and the need for viewers to engage with subtitles. The show's slow pacing and lack of action made it a tough sell for mainstream audiences, despite its critical acclaim and faithful adaptation of the novel.

Why did 'A Gentleman in Moscow' fail to resonate with audiences?

'A Gentleman in Moscow' failed to resonate with audiences because it struggled to capture the book's unique tone and internal dialogue. The adaptation softened some of the book's sharper edges, and Ewan McGregor's performance, while solid, didn't fully embody the charm and complexity of the main character.

What was the sleeper hit of 2024 in terms of movie adaptations?

The sleeper hit of 2024 in terms of movie adaptations was 'The Wild Robot,' which received effusive praise from audiences and critics alike. The film, based on a beloved children's book, was a strong contender in the animation category and resonated deeply with families.

Chapters
Jeff and Rebecca discuss the state of literary adaptations in 2024, noting a shift from big-name properties to more backlist titles. They also mention the success of some adaptations and the failures of others. They also promote their own product, mytbr.co.
  • Shift from big-name properties to backlist titles
  • Success and failures of various adaptations
  • Promotion of mytbr.co

Shownotes Transcript

Jeff and Rebecca take a look at the hits, misses, and favorites from the year in literary adaptations.

Subscribe to the podcast via RSS), Apple Podcasts), and Spotify).

For more industry news, sign up for our Today in Books) daily newsletter!

Check out the Book Riot Podcast Book Page on Thriftbooks)!

Discussed in this episode:

Book Riot’s TBR)

The Book Riot Podcast on Instagram)

The Book Riot Podcast Patreon)

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)