We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Terror, Propaganda and the Birth of the “New Man”: Experiences from Cuba, North Korea, and the Soviet Union

Terror, Propaganda and the Birth of the “New Man”: Experiences from Cuba, North Korea, and the Soviet Union

2017/10/16
logo of podcast Cato Event Podcast

Cato Event Podcast

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Andrei Ilarionov
A
Andrei Lankov
M
Marian Tupy
Y
Yuri Perez-Vazquez
Topics
Marian Tupy: 本讨论会旨在纪念/哀悼布尔什维克政变100周年,并探讨共产主义对世界造成的巨大社会灾难和人员伤亡。共产主义试图改造人的本性,创造一个没有自私和基本本能的“新人”,但由于人的本性并非一张白纸,因此需要大规模的宣传和恐怖来实现其目标。 Andrei Lankov: 朝鲜在金日成统治下建立了一个高度监控的社会,旨在完全控制经济和人民的行动。政府对经济进行完全的计划和配给,严格控制人民的行动,并通过人民班和家庭检查等手段进行严密监控。这种模式最终因其高昂的成本和不可持续性而部分崩溃,私有经济的增长逐渐削弱了政府的控制能力,但政府仍然选择性地执行某些旧法规以维持稳定。 Yuri Perez-Vazquez: 卡斯特罗政权通过恐怖、没收财产、大规模监禁和杀戮以及利用监视组织来监控每一个公民来维持其权力。政权通过将所有经济活动置于政府控制之下,使人民贫困,并以此来维持对社会的控制。卡斯特罗政权还利用宣传和教育,从小灌输对切·格瓦拉的崇拜,以培养对政权的忠诚和服从。 Andrei Ilarionov: 共产主义政权利用恐怖和宣传作为统治工具,不仅在国内实施,还将其输出到国外,对社会结构造成深远影响。从马克思到列宁,再到斯大林,共产主义的恐怖主义理论和实践贯穿始终。共产主义政权将社会划分为“有用的人”、“人民的敌人”和“需要改造的人”三类,并通过秘密警察等手段对社会进行严密控制。这种恐怖主义不仅在苏联国内实施,还被输出到其他国家,对社会结构造成深远影响。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did communist regimes aim to create a 'New Man'?

Communist regimes aimed to create a 'New Man' to transform human nature, eliminating selfishness, nationalism, and class consciousness, and instilling austere discipline, hard work, and a willingness to sacrifice for the common good, adhering to Marxism-Leninism.

How many people are estimated to have died due to communism between 1917 and the mid-1990s?

Between 80 million and 160 million people are estimated to have died due to communism between 1917 and the mid-1990s, with a killing rate of 150 to 300 people per hour for 78 years.

What was the primary goal of Kim Il-sung's regime in North Korea?

Kim Il-sung's regime aimed to create a society of total control, eliminating monetary economy and enforcing strict rationing, with the goal of transforming North Korea into an embodiment of Stalin's dreams, though possibly even more extreme.

How did North Korea's economy change after the collapse of the Soviet Union?

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, North Korea's state-planned economy fell apart, leading to a massive economic dislocation and the rise of a private economy, with 25-50% of GDP now produced privately and 80% of household income coming from private sources.

What role did propaganda and terror play in the Castro regime in Cuba?

The Castro regime used propaganda and terror to destroy traditional society and create a new man, targeting sectors of society with repression, confiscations, and incarcerations to maintain control and keep the population in fear and poverty.

How did the Soviet Union's system of terror and propaganda influence other countries?

The Soviet Union exported its system of terror and propaganda to newly conquered territories, applying similar methods of repression, confiscation, and control in countries like Eastern Europe, China, Korea, Vietnam, and Cuba, targeting government officials, religious leaders, and other social groups.

What were the estimated human losses due to terror and political repression in the Soviet Union?

The estimated human losses due to terror and political repression in the Soviet Union range from 34 million people, accounting for up to 22% of the USSR population in 1922, with total human losses due to all reasons possibly reaching close to 100 million.

How did the Cuban regime respond to the collapse of the Soviet Union?

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Cuba allowed small-scale free market reforms and attracted foreign investment, which helped mitigate the economic crisis until Hugo Chavez's Venezuela provided subsidies, allowing Cuba to revert to a similar economic model as during the Soviet era.

What is the current state of the surveillance state in North Korea under Kim Jong-un?

Under Kim Jong-un, North Korea has become more selective in enforcing old regulations, with control over domestic movement largely non-existent and bribes accepted for travel permits. However, control over the border with China has increased, and there is a crackdown on the spread of South Korean media to maintain stability.

What is the per capita income gap between North and South Korea?

The per capita income gap between North and South Korea is one of the largest in the world, with a ratio of 1 to 14 to 1 to 30, making it the largest gap between two countries with a shared land border.

Chapters
Communist regimes aimed to transform human nature, creating a 'New Man' who adhered to Marxism-Leninism. This 'New Man' would be selfless and free from base instincts. However, the incompatibility between communist ideals and human nature necessitated the use of propaganda and terror.
  • Communist regimes aimed to transform human nature into a 'New Man' adhering to Marxism-Leninism
  • The 'New Man' was envisioned as selfless and devoid of base instincts
  • The incompatibility of communist ideals and human nature led to the use of propaganda and terror

Shownotes Transcript

Communist totalitarian regimes that sprang up after the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917 did not aim simply to change social and economic relations between individuals and the state. They aimed to transform human nature in order to create a “New Man.” The New Man’s behavior and beliefs would adhere to the tenets of Marxism-Leninism. He would be free of selfishness and base instincts such as nationalism and class consciousness. He would be austere, disciplined, hardworking, and willing to sacrifice himself for the common good. But man is not a blank slate. The incompatibility of communist ideas and human nature necessitated a massive expansion of propaganda, to brainwash those who could be influenced, and terror, to eliminate those deemed irredeemable. Please join us as our panel looks at the means that the communist state employed and the continued application of those “novel” techniques today. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy) for more information.