cover of episode Vol 21|教育为何永远迷人-乡村教育的酸甜苦辣

Vol 21|教育为何永远迷人-乡村教育的酸甜苦辣

2023/12/25
logo of podcast 认真听讲

认真听讲

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
大海
王总
西
西西
阿Q
Topics
西西: 我的乡村教师生涯始于只有17个学生的村校,后到镇上初中和重点学校,学生数量不断增加,但教学水平提升有限。我经历了从对自身教学能力的自信到怀疑的转变。特岗教师的经历并非都极其偏远,我的经历更接近城乡结合部。特岗教师报考门槛低,但竞争激烈,录取率不高。三年服务期内可以辞职,违约成本低。乡村学校卷成绩现象严重,即使教学水平低,也重视成绩。年轻教师缺乏教学指导和先进理念,教学方法落后。与学生的思想交流较少,价值感主要来自与学生互动。离开乡村学校并非单纯为了编制,而是为了家庭原因。在重点学校工作后,才开始与学生有思想上的交流。 大海: 乡村教师工作十年后的自我反思,对自身教学能力的怀疑。乡村学校的年轻教师流动性大,对学生造成一定影响,但带来不同外界信息。特岗教师是获得编制的一种方式,门槛低,但竞争激烈。特岗教师在乡村学校缺乏支持和培训,如同工具人,工作繁重,兼任多项工作。课后托管虽然带来负担,但比让学生放学后玩手机或回家更有利于学生成长。社会化教育在当下非常重要。 阿Q: 乡村学校调研引发对教育价值的反思,调研唤醒了最初的教育初心。调研中发现四川大山里乡村学校地理位置偏远,交通不便,学生缺乏城市生活经验。乡村学校的自然环境优越,但教学水平参差不齐。现在乡村学校有更多年轻老师,带来活力,老师流动对学生的影响,带来不同外界信息。特岗教师报考门槛低,但竞争激烈。乡村学校卷成绩现象严重,年轻教师教学方法落后,缺乏教学指导和先进理念。城市教育的精细化与乡村教育的对比,乡村孩子的原生态和教育的力量。教育的迷人之处在于改变学生对世界的认知。对天然力量和现代教育力量的理解。对早教班的看法,过度精细化教育会失去生命力。 王总: 讨论特岗教师辞职成本低。对课后托管的质疑,认为是学校转嫁责任。乡村学生沉迷网络和早恋现象严重,出现各种不良行为,例如观看黄色网站和传播不雅照片。对乡村学生教育的困惑,认为常识教育比学科教育更重要。在成绩导向的环境下,教师的困境。教师的自我保护和育人困境。未来几年教师工作压力加大,人口减少导致编制减少。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What challenges do rural teachers face in China, particularly in remote mountainous areas?

Rural teachers in remote mountainous areas face significant challenges, including limited access to resources, poor infrastructure, and a lack of professional development opportunities. Many schools are located in areas with no public transportation, requiring teachers to rely on private vehicles or motorcycles. Students often lack basic knowledge, such as understanding traffic signals, due to their isolated environments. Additionally, teachers frequently deal with low academic performance, with average scores in some schools as low as 30-40 out of 100. The high turnover of young teachers, who often leave after short stints, further exacerbates the instability in these schools.

Why do many young teachers in rural areas leave their positions quickly?

Many young teachers in rural areas leave their positions quickly due to the challenging working conditions, lack of support, and limited opportunities for professional growth. The high turnover is also driven by the fact that many teachers view these positions as temporary stepping stones to secure permanent teaching jobs in urban areas. Additionally, the low academic performance of students and the pressure to improve scores without adequate training or resources contribute to teacher burnout and dissatisfaction.

How does the 'Special Post Teacher' program in China work, and what are its implications for rural education?

The 'Special Post Teacher' program in China recruits teachers to work in rural and remote areas, typically for a three-year service period. After completing this term, teachers are often granted permanent teaching positions. The program aims to address teacher shortages in rural schools, but it has low entry barriers, with some regions not requiring teaching qualifications or specific degrees. While it provides a pathway for young teachers to gain experience and secure stable jobs, the program also faces challenges, such as high turnover rates and a lack of support for teachers, which can negatively impact the quality of education in these areas.

What are the social and cultural challenges faced by students in rural schools?

Students in rural schools face significant social and cultural challenges, including limited exposure to urban environments and modern technology. Many students have never visited cities and lack basic knowledge about urban life, such as traffic rules. Additionally, the influence of mobile phones and social media has created a disconnect between traditional rural values and modern digital culture. This has led to issues such as early exposure to inappropriate content, early relationships, and a lack of motivation to pursue education. The absence of strong family support and the transient nature of teachers further exacerbate these challenges.

How does the lack of professional development for rural teachers affect education quality?

The lack of professional development for rural teachers significantly impacts education quality, as many teachers are not equipped with modern teaching methods or resources. Teachers often rely on outdated, lecture-based approaches, which are less effective in engaging students. Without proper training or mentorship, teachers struggle to address the diverse needs of their students, particularly in low-performing schools. This lack of support leads to frustration and burnout among teachers, further diminishing the quality of education in rural areas.

What role does the 'Special Post Teacher' program play in addressing teacher shortages in rural China?

The 'Special Post Teacher' program plays a crucial role in addressing teacher shortages in rural China by recruiting young teachers to work in remote areas. These teachers are often given permanent positions after completing a three-year service period, providing a pathway to stable employment. However, the program's low entry barriers and high turnover rates highlight the challenges of retaining qualified teachers in rural schools. While it helps fill immediate staffing gaps, the program's long-term effectiveness is limited by the lack of support and professional development opportunities for teachers.

How does the rural education system in China balance traditional values with modern influences?

The rural education system in China struggles to balance traditional values with modern influences, particularly due to the pervasive impact of mobile phones and social media. While rural students retain some of their natural, traditional upbringing, they are increasingly exposed to digital culture, which often conflicts with their rural environment. This creates a dual challenge: students are neither fully integrated into urban modernity nor able to maintain their traditional rural identity. Teachers and schools face difficulties in addressing these cultural shifts, as they lack the resources and training to effectively guide students through this transition.

What are the long-term implications of high teacher turnover in rural schools?

High teacher turnover in rural schools has long-term implications for both students and the education system. Frequent changes in teaching staff disrupt the continuity of education, leaving students without stable role models or consistent instruction. This instability can lead to lower academic performance and reduced motivation among students. Additionally, the constant influx of inexperienced teachers limits the development of effective teaching practices and professional growth within rural schools. Over time, this cycle of turnover perpetuates the challenges faced by rural education, making it difficult to achieve meaningful improvements.

Chapters
本期节目从主播阿Q在西南地区乡村学校的调研经历展开,探讨了乡村孩子的教育现状。调研发现,乡村孩子保留着珍贵的天然性,但同时也面临着现代教育的冲击和社会化教育的缺失。
  • 乡村学校地理位置偏远,交通不便
  • 乡村孩子缺乏城市生活经验,甚至不认识红绿灯等
  • 乡村学校普遍存在年轻教师多,教学方法落后等问题

Shownotes Transcript

画个重点,认真听讲。大家好,这里是“认真听讲”!

我们都是正在一线或者曾经在一线中小学工作的教育行业从业者,关注中小学及师范生教育问题,提供一些体制内体制外的视角,偶尔活泼,偶尔严肃,偶尔犀利。欢迎大家关注我们,期待大家的留言~

各位听众朋友们,大家好!本期我们邀请到了一位曾经在乡村特岗工作,后来有很凡尔赛成长经历的老师西西来分享她的成长之路~

🎙️ 主播:

大海(一个再接班主任的苦逼老师)

阿Q(一个从芬兰回来后学会了躺平的欢乐打工人)

王总(一个喋喋不休的语文老师)

🎙️嘉宾:

西西(一个曾经是特岗的一路打怪升级的老师~)

⏳ 主要内容:

本期剪辑师阿Q病了而且很懒而且当晚直出所以没有时间戳

前半段主要是关于阿Q在前两周的乡村学校调研的一些感悟(比如大山里的孩子真的保留了很珍贵的天然性,而在城市中随着教育的精细化反而让孩子失去最原始的生命力)以及对乡村特岗教师的一些不切实际的想象,但是在大家的批评(啊其实也没有啦哈哈哈)中逐渐回到现实情况的乡村教学——既很难完全融入城市,也回不到古朴的天然状态,而是几乎被手机里的世界所塑造,随之而来的是这些学生的教育和管理问题。

下半段起于王总和大海的不同观点,课后托管虽然给老师带来了负担,但是相较于让他们下课后刷手机或是回到没什么家庭教育的家里,是否会更有利于学生的成长?由此引申到在社会复杂程度大大提升的当下,我们是否应该更加重视这类乡村学生的社会化教育?但尽管有很多的问题,却不必充满悲观——坚定有力量的西西老师分享了她在狭窄道路中是如何走出一条宽阔大道的,也希望她的分享能够带给更多在自我拉扯中的老师更多的力量~