We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Episode 290: Bringing Older Children into the CM Method

Episode 290: Bringing Older Children into the CM Method

2024/12/6
logo of podcast A Delectable Education Charlotte Mason Podcast

A Delectable Education Charlotte Mason Podcast

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
E
Emily Kaiser
N
Nicole Williams
Topics
Emily Kaiser, Nicole Williams, Liz Cottrell: 本期节目讨论了将大龄孩子(无论之前是否接受过家庭教育或在传统学校学习)融入夏洛特·梅森教育法的常见问题。节目中分享了多种方法,帮助不同年龄段的孩子过渡到新的学习方式,并对家长在这一过程中可能面临的挑战和期望进行了探讨。 节目中强调了夏洛特·梅森方法的重点在于培养孩子成为独立思考、表达和学习的人,而不是单纯地追求知识的积累。因此,家长需要根据孩子的实际情况,调整学习内容和进度,并给予孩子足够的耐心和鼓励。 节目中还分享了具体的案例和建议,例如如何帮助孩子学习复述、如何培养良好的阅读习惯、如何调整学习内容的难度,以及如何处理孩子可能出现的不良学习习惯。 总而言之,节目旨在帮助家长们更好地理解和应用夏洛特·梅森教育法,并鼓励家长们以积极乐观的态度,陪伴孩子一起探索学习的乐趣。 Nicole Williams: 我分享了将我被收养的兄弟姐妹(在六年级左右回到家中)带入夏洛特·梅森教育方法的个人经验。我的兄弟姐妹们之前在不同的学校学习,经历了多次学校更换,这使得他们对夏洛特·梅森方法的适应可能更容易。其中一个孩子在学校成绩优异,但对夏洛特·梅森方法中不计成绩的复述练习感到不安。另一个孩子在高中最后一年回到家中,一开始很喜欢新的学习方法,但后来也产生过怀疑。我的哥哥在高中辍学后,通过了GED考试,并对夏洛特·梅森的教育方法表达了感激之情。他的经历说明,夏洛特·梅森的方法不仅仅是关于成就,更是关于帮助每个孩子发展他们的潜能,即使他们没有完成传统的学业。 Emily Kaiser: 我分享了我自己学习夏洛特·梅森方法的经历,以及我如何帮助我的孩子适应这种学习方法。我强调了家长需要根据孩子的实际情况调整学习内容和进度,并给予孩子足够的耐心和鼓励。我还分享了一些具体的建议,例如如何帮助孩子学习复述、如何培养良好的阅读习惯,以及如何处理孩子可能出现的不良学习习惯。 Liz Cottrell: 我主要参与了节目的讨论,并对其他两位主持人的观点进行了补充和说明。我强调了夏洛特·梅森方法的重点在于培养孩子的独立思考能力和表达能力,以及如何平衡朗读和孩子独立阅读。我还分享了一些具体的建议,例如如何帮助孩子克服对短课程的抵触情绪,以及如何处理孩子可能出现的不良学习习惯。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What are the key challenges when transitioning older children to the Charlotte Mason method?

Older children transitioning to the Charlotte Mason method face challenges such as adjusting to narration instead of traditional textbook learning, developing new habits like attention and observation, and adapting to a curriculum that emphasizes living books and short lessons. They may also struggle with the shift from grades and tests to a more holistic, interest-driven approach.

Why is narration a critical skill in the Charlotte Mason method, and how does it differ from traditional learning?

Narration is central to the Charlotte Mason method because it helps children internalize and articulate what they’ve learned, moving information from short-term to long-term memory. Unlike traditional learning, which often relies on memorization and regurgitation, narration requires children to think critically, visualize, and express their understanding in their own words.

How can parents help older children adjust to the Charlotte Mason method?

Parents can help older children adjust by starting with oral narration before moving to written narration, shortening reading assignments to allow for better comprehension, and explaining the philosophy behind the method. They should also be patient, provide grace during the transition, and avoid mixing traditional methods with Charlotte Mason practices to prevent confusion.

What are the benefits of bringing older children into the Charlotte Mason method?

Bringing older children into the Charlotte Mason method can reignite their love for learning, help them develop critical thinking and communication skills, and expose them to a wide range of interests. It also fosters a deeper connection to the material and encourages lifelong learning, even if they start later in their education.

How does the Charlotte Mason method address the unique needs of older children who are new to the approach?

The Charlotte Mason method adapts to older children by focusing on their maturity and ability to grasp complex ideas while still building foundational skills like narration and observation. Content is tailored to their age level, but skill development may start at a simpler level to ensure they master essential techniques before progressing.

What role does habit training play in transitioning older children to the Charlotte Mason method?

Habit training is crucial for older children transitioning to the Charlotte Mason method, as it helps them develop skills like attention, perfect execution, and observation. These habits are cultivated through consistent practice in lessons, such as copywork and nature study, and are essential for adapting to the method’s demands.

How does the Charlotte Mason method differ from traditional education in terms of expectations and outcomes?

The Charlotte Mason method focuses on cultivating a love for learning and a broad range of interests rather than measuring success by grades or test scores. It emphasizes the development of the whole person, encouraging children to care deeply about many subjects and to think independently, rather than simply accumulating knowledge.

What practical adjustments should parents make when introducing older children to the Charlotte Mason method?

Parents should adjust by starting with shorter reading assignments to build narration skills, focusing on oral narration before written, and gradually introducing more complex material. They should also avoid mixing traditional methods, explain the purpose behind each practice, and provide ample time for children to adapt to the new approach.

How does the Charlotte Mason method foster a sense of connection and bonding between parents and children?

The Charlotte Mason method fosters bonding through shared experiences like nature study, read-alouds, and discussions. These activities create a sense of collaboration and mutual discovery, helping both parents and children develop a deeper appreciation for learning and each other.

What is the significance of short lessons in the Charlotte Mason method, especially for older children?

Short lessons are a cornerstone of the Charlotte Mason method because they help maintain focus and prevent mental fatigue. For older children, these brief, concentrated sessions allow them to engage deeply with the material without feeling overwhelmed, making the transition to a new method more manageable and enjoyable.

Chapters
This chapter introduces the topic of transitioning older children into the Charlotte Mason method, highlighting the common challenges and concerns parents face when introducing the method to children who have prior schooling experiences. It sets the stage for the discussion by acknowledging that the focus is on children as individuals and not on curriculum novelty.
  • Common challenges of introducing the Charlotte Mason Method to older children.
  • Focus on children as persons, not curriculum novelty.

Shownotes Transcript

This Charlotte Mason podcast episode is a re-aired, re-visit to a common question we receive: bringing children into the Mason method from previous school experiences. What are the approaches that help children of various ages transition, what are realistic expectations, and how do we help them adjust to a different way of doing lessons?

)

"The success of such a school demands rare qualities in the teacher––high culture, some knowledge of psychology and of the art of education; intense sympathy with the children, much tact, much common sense, much common information, much 'joyousness of nature,' and much governing power..." (Vol. 1, p. 178)

"Our aim in Education is to give a Full Life.––We begin to see what we want. Children make large demands upon us. We owe it to them to initiate an immense number of interests. Thou hast set my feet in a large room; should be the glad cry of every intelligent soul. Life should be all living, and not merely a tedious passing of time; not all doing or all feeling or all thinking––the strain would be too great––but, all living; that is to say, we should be in touch wherever we go, whatever we hear, whatever we see, with some manner of vital interest. We cannot give the children these interests; we prefer that they should never say they have learned botany or conchology, geology or astronomy. The question is not,––how much does the youth know? when he has finished his education––but how much does he care? and about how many orders of things does he care? In fact, how large is the room in which he finds his feet set? and, therefore, how full is the life he has before him?" (Vol. 3, p. 170-171) 

I Buy a School, Marion Berry)

(Contains affiliate links)

ADE at HOME 2025 {Virtual} Conference)

Living Book Press)

ADE Teacher Training Videos)