Episode 297: Eleanor Clifford
26:01 Share

As women, we're told to manage our health, track the numbers, bounce back fast. TIA Health is different. They're the only health care clinic designed to support women through every life stage, with both in-person and virtual care that's personalized, proactive, and focused on the whole you. At TIA, health isn't the end goal. It's the foundation.

They bring together primary care, gynecology, mental health, menopause and hormone support, longevity, skin care and more, all in one place. No more juggling multiple specialists or settling for one-size-fits-most care. TIA's board-certified clinicians build personalized care plans that support not just your body but your goals, so you can sleep better, feel stronger and live the life you want. Whether you're navigating perimenopause, managing chronic stress,

or just want a provider who actually listens, TIA is here to help you live bigger. And they accept most major insurance. Join the thousands of women redefining what healthcare can be. Book now at AskTIA.com. That's AskTIA.com to book today.

Fries.

Fresh for everyone.

In October 1536, the north of England was in open revolt. Tens of thousands of rebels had taken up arms against the banner of the five wombs of Christ, calling themselves pilgrims and demanding a return to the old ways. The king's new religious policies had stirred up more than sermons. This was war, and Eleanor Clifford, Countess of Cumberland, found herself caught right in the middle of it.

She was at Bolton Abbey, a quiet monastic retreat about 10 miles from Skipton Castle. With her were her young son and two of her sisters-in-law. It was supposed to be a safe place, far from court, far from trouble. But Eleanor, unfortunately, wasn't just any noblewoman. She was a niece of Henry VIII, and the rebels knew it.

When they found her, they made zero effort at politeness. Eleanor and her family were taken hostage. The insurgents sent word to her father-in-law at Skipton Castle, surrender the fortress or we'll hand these women over to the camp followers. And the implication was not subtle. It was violence against women as a political threat, and Eleanor, despite her royal blood, was expendable.

The standoff didn't last long. Her father-in-law, furious and alarmed, rode straight into the rebel camp and negotiated their release. Eleanor, her sisters-in-law, and her child were brought safely back to Skipton. The siege was lifted five days later. She didn't write about it. There's no first-person account, no dramatic testimony, but the fact that rebels saw her as valuable enough to threaten...

and the Earl risked so much to get her back, tells us something. Eleanor Brandon mattered, even if history has largely forgotten her. Hello, friend, and welcome back to the Renaissance English History Podcast, a part of the Agora Podcast Network and the original Tudor History Podcast, telling stories of Tudor England since 2009. I am your host, Heather, and I am very excited and thrilled that you are here with me today.

Thrilled sounds a little bit overenthusiastic, but really I am. You know, like you could be doing all kinds of stuff right now. You could be like out in the sun, at the pool, going to Target, walking the dog, watching the new season of The Gilded Age. I don't know. There's like a lot you could be doing and you are choosing to spend this time with me and I do not take it lightly. So thank you very much for that. It is my honor to be here with you.

So today, my friend, we are going to talk about Eleanor Brandon, a niece of Henry VIII, who has been largely forgotten. Let's get right into it. Eleanor Brandon was born into the very heart of Tudor royalty, but her name rarely makes it into the footnotes, let alone the spotlight.

She was the daughter of Princess Mary Tudor, the king's beloved younger sister, and Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk. That, of course, made her Henry VIII's niece. Her sister Frances went on to be the mother of Lady Jane Grey. Her cousin, Margaret Douglas, caused scandals and flirted with treason. But Eleanor? Eleanor got married, moved north, and vanished from the court's daily drama. Good for her, I say.

But when you look a little closer, her life actually wasn't particularly quiet at all. She was married at 15 in a ceremony attended by the king himself. She nearly died in a rebellion. She buried two of her three children, tragically. She lived far from the glitter of court, but she was close enough to its politics to appear in the king's will.

She left behind one letter, just one, that survives, but it is so intimate, so physical, and so immediate that you can practically hear her voice. And through that voice, we glimpse something rare, a woman at the edge of power, dealing with illnesses, marriage, motherhood, and mortal fear with zero spotlight on her. She wasn't there trying to change the world, but the world kept trying to press in on her anyway.

So let's talk about Eleanor Brandon, Countess of Cumberland, the king's niece, and a Tudor woman that history has largely, mostly forgotten. Eleanor Brandon was born sometime between 1519 and 1521, most likely at West Thorpe Hall, the Suffolk estate of her parents.

her mother of course was no ordinary duchess she had once been the queen of france married briefly to the aging louis the twelfth before returning to england having married charles the king's closest friend in secret

Eleanor was their second daughter after Francis, and her name stood out. Tudor royal women were usually Mary, Elizabeth, Anne, or Jane. But Eleanor's name may have been a diplomatic nod to Eleanor of Austria. She was the sister of Charles V, Queen of Portugal, and later would become the Queen of France.

If that's true, it was a name loaded with imperial significance and maybe a quiet signal of alliance, given that her father had been involved in negotiations with Charles V around the time of her birth.

Like her sister, Eleanor would have received a very elite humanist education. Girls in families like theirs were expected to learn French and Latin, to read scripture and to play music, perhaps the virginals or the lute. There's evidence that Eleanor could write in French, and she seems to have inherited her mother's sharp intelligence.

Her sister Frances married Henry Grey in 1533, and that same year Eleanor was betrothed to Henry Clifford, heir to the Earl of Cumberland. The Cliffords were a well-connected northern family, and there was also a touch of Plantagenet blood running through Eleanor's future mother-in-law, Margaret Percy. We actually just did a YouTube video this week on the Percy family and how they couldn't

stop themselves from rebelling. So you can check that out. I will add a link in the show notes. Anyway, Henry Clifford himself was tall, dark haired and unusually intellectual. He built an impressive personal library and dabbled in alchemy and astrology, which of course were eccentric hobbies for a man who was expected to lead border defenses.

They were married in 1535 at St. Mary-Ovary in Southwark, now Southwark Cathedral. Henry VIII actually went himself. Not every niece gets a king at her wedding, but Eleanor did, and her new life in the North was about to begin.

For most noble couples in the Tudor world, marriage didn't mean immediate independence. You were usually tucked in your in-law's household until the title passed down, if it ever did. But Eleanor Brandon and Henry Clifford had something different. In the months leading up to Eleanor's arrival, Henry's father, the first Earl of Cumberland,

ordered a rapid-fire renovation to Skipton Castle in North Yorkshire. He added a long gallery and two new towers, one of them octagonal, which was a fashionable and expensive architectural choice at the time. The construction was finished in under four months. It wasn't just practical, it was symbolic. The king's niece was coming north, and the family meant to show that they were ready to receive her in a royal style.

It was rare, almost unheard of, for a young couple to have their own establishment while their parents were still alive. But Henry and Eleanor were given real autonomy. They did spend some time at Skipton, but they seemed to have lived primarily at Brougham Castle in Westmoreland, closer to the Scottish border.

It was a quieter location, far from court, farther still from the endless maneuvering of London politics. But it seems to have suited Eleanor, who, even in those early years, may have already been struggling with poor health.

This marriage was more than just a dynastic win. It seems to have been a functional, even affectionate match. Eleanor's father, Charles Brandon, stayed closely involved, writing to the Earl of Cumberland about his daughter's well-being and sometimes even stepping in to manage financial arrangements on her behalf.

He once gently complained that Eleanor and her husband were living in an unhealthy country house and pushed for them to be moved back to Brougham, where she seemed to thrive a bit better. This was a woman who was building a life on the edge of the kingdom with real challenges lying ahead for her. So Eleanor, like we said, may have been living far from court, but she was still expected to show up when duty called.

In early 1536, just a few months after her wedding, she was summoned south to serve as chief mourner at the funeral of Catherine of Aragon. This was a political role, choosing who stood where, who carried which banners, who wept in which pews, this all sent a message. So it's telling that Eleanor, and not her older sister Frances, was the one who represented the family that day at Peterborough Castle.

Frances may have been pregnant at the time or recovering from a recent birth, but there's still another possibility. Henry might have considered Eleanor the right level of royal for the occasion. Frances was the senior niece, was perhaps tied too closely to court ambition, and was

Eleanor was quieter, less politically entangled, more neutral, an acceptable presence at a queen's funeral without making it feel like a dynastic statement. Remember, at this time, Henry was married to Anne Boleyn. Catherine was not on his good list. He didn't want to have Catherine

have this state funeral that was too fancy, too much, because he was really still mad at Catherine and might have been a bit happy and relieved that she was gone. But he still needed to honor her as what he saw as the Princess Dowager, the Dowager Princess of Wales, and someone who was the aunt of Charles V. So he needed to give her a certain amount of pomp and circumstance, but maybe not enough for the senior niece, right? LESLIE KENDRICK

After this visibility, Eleanor's name actually vanishes from the official court record. She's not listed among the ladies at Prince Edward's christening in 1537. She didn't attend Jane Seymour's funeral. She also wasn't among the elite women who welcomed Anne of Cleves in 1540.

Her sister Frances, by contrast, was there for all of it. Now, one explanation might be Eleanor's health. Her father wrote more than once about her frequent illnesses and made specific requests to her in-laws for healthier accommodations. So it's possible that her absence wasn't her kind of eschewing her duty or anything like that. It might have just been physical. ♪

Speaking of Tudor women doing extraordinary things, both quietly and dramatically, we spend a lot of time talking about them at TudorCon. And believe it or not, TudorCon 2025 is just 100 days away. You can grab your ticket either online or in person right now at englandcast.com slash TudorCon. We still have a couple of spots. I think we have about 10 spots available for in-person tickets.

Or you can come online. You can use the code EARLYWORD to save $15 off of your online ticket. The online event isn't just a regular Zoom call. You get all the talk streamed live, of course, with a host. So you can ask questions and interact with the speakers. You have all of the entertainment streaming. You get recordings of everything. There's an online community where you can connect with other Tudor fans. There's actually online games like trivia and stuff that

just for the online attendees. So it's a really special time. Englandcast.com slash TudorCon to come either in person or online. And if you're coming online, use that code EARLYBIRD to save $15 off of your online ticket. And of course, the early bird prices are still in effect for the in-person tickets too. Englandcast.com slash TudorCon.

Alright, back in the 1540s, while her sister stayed close to court, Eleanor was increasingly rooted in the North, settled into a rhythm of family life, letter writing, and, as we'll see next, moving through some devastating personal losses.

Then, in the autumn of 1536, Eleanor's life took a terrifying turn, which we talked about in the opening. England's north was rising up in protest against the king's reforms. Monasteries were being dissolved, traditional faith was under threat, and resentment toward the central government had reached a boiling point. It was called the Pilgrimage of Grace, and it became the largest rebellion of Henry VIII's reign. We've done lots of episodes talking about it. I can link to them in the show notes as well. Eleanor was now about 17 years old.

staying at Bolton Abbey about 10 miles from Skipton, along with her young son and two of her sisters-in-law. The idea was to keep them out of harm's way while Skipton was fortified, but it didn't work because the rebels found them. They stormed the Abbey, took the women and child captive, and sent this message to Eleanor's father-in-law, surrender Skipton or your daughter-in-law, her child, and the other women will be handed over to the camp followers. And the

The threat was to violate and enforce them with knaves unto my lord's great discomfort. There is zero ambiguity in that phrase. This was violence against women deliberately threatened as a weapon of humiliation. These rebels knew exactly who Eleanor was. She was the king's niece, and that made her valuable symbolically and strategically.

This wasn't empty bluster against Eleanor. These same rebels had already dragged abbots from their monasteries, forced local landowners to swear oaths at knife point. There's a really harrowing scene in Wolf Hall where Cromwell learns of a man that he had sent north who was tied in pigskin and thrown to the dogs as punishment. Now, this is fictional, but it's not out of step with the kind of brutality that

people were experiencing in the North at the time. A lot of times we hear about things like rebellions and it's like, oh, that might have been fun, like a protest or something. And it was not like that at all. This was real violence threatened against her. And a lot of people were experiencing this violence.

Not to say I don't understand what the Pilgrimage of Grace was about. Clearly, I understand. And they had a lot of good points and there was a lot that was that was moving them. But it was a very, very violent rebellion. And the reprisals also were equally violent with 200 people executed. The leader was hanged in chains. It was not a good time for anybody.

So the Earl of Cumberland did not hesitate. He rode straight into the rebel camp at Bolton, and he demanded their release. Somehow, possibly thanks to his local connections and his status, he was able to pull it off. The women and the child were freed and returned to Skipton, and the rebels gave up their siege just five days later.

Eleanor never left a written account of what happened, but the records speak volumes. Rebels used her as leverage, and her father-in-law risked everything to save her. And when her own father, Charles Brandon, heard the story, he wrote immediately to the Earl, if there was any way to bring Eleanor south to his household, here I trust she shall be out of danger. She didn't go south. She didn't return to court.

But this episode proved just how much her presence, even so far from London, still matters.

Ahorra en grande cuando compres cinco o más de tus favoritos. Simplemente compra cinco o más artículos participantes y ahorra un dólar en cada uno con tu tarjeta.

Fries, fresh for everyone. As women, we're told to manage our health, track the numbers, bounce back fast. Tia Health is different. They're the only healthcare clinic designed to support women through every life stage, with both in-person and virtual care that's personalized, proactive, and focused on the whole you. At Tia, health isn't the end goal. It's the foundation.

They bring together primary care, gynecology, mental health, menopause, and hormone support, longevity, skin care, and more, all in one place. No more juggling multiple specialists or settling for one-size-fits-most care. TIA's board-certified clinicians build personalized care plans that support not just your body, but your goals, so you can sleep better, feel stronger, and live the life you want. Whether you're navigating perimenopause, managing chronic stress,

or just want a provider who actually listens, TIA is here to help you live bigger. And they accept most major insurance. Join the thousands of women redefining what healthcare can be. Book now at asktia.com. That's asktia.com to book today. You ever finish a hike, a workout, or just a nonstop day juggling everything and think, okay, I need a snack and a nap? Yep.

Same. But before you crash, how about a dairy-powered recharge? Milk, yogurt, cheese, they're not just tasty comfort foods, they're tiny nutritional powerhouses. You're getting complete protein to rebuild muscle, carbs to give you an energy boost, and natural electrolytes like potassium and sodium to help you stay balanced and bounce back faster. And hey, chocolate milk after a workout?

It's a game changer. Your body will thank you and so will your taste buds. Even better, it's all super convenient. Shelf-stable milk and on-the-go yogurt packs are perfect for your gym bag, diaper bag, backpack, whatever your adventure looks like today. It's one of the easiest choices you can make for your health. So next time you're fueling your everyday or something more epic, fuel up with something real and satisfying. Find your favorite dairy products at your local grocery store today.

Now, by the early 1540s, Eleanor had faded from the royal spotlight, but her role as wife and mother had taken center stage. She gave birth to three children. Her first two were sons, Henry and Charles, and both died young. Charles died in infancy, and Henry lived only to about age three. They were buried side by side in the Clifford family vault at Holy Trinity Church in Skipton, the same church where Eleanor herself would be buried just a few years later.

Only her daughter, Margaret, born in 1540, survived into adulthood. It's likely that Eleanor named her after her mother-in-law, Margaret Percy. Margaret would go on to marry Henry Stanley, the future Earl of Derby, and have four sons. But despite the promise of that match, the marriage broke down, and Margaret later came under suspicion for allegedly predicting Elizabeth I's death through astrology. But we will have to save that story for another time.

In 1542, Eleanor's father-in-law died and her husband officially became the second Earl of Cumberland. That made Eleanor the Countess, though it likely didn't change much about her daily life. They were already well-established at Brougham Castle and had long since taken on the responsibilities of the title.

She had another major loss in 1545 when her father, Charles Brandon, died. In his will, he left both Eleanor and Francis 200 pounds worth of plate, a decent sum, but not an extravagant one. He, of course, had remarried after Mary Tudor's death and had other children, other sons to consider at this point, but the fact that he left her this amount of plate still showed that Eleanor, for all of her distance from court, was still very much his daughter.

She also remained on good terms with her stepmother, Catherine Willoughby. While her sister Frances pursued court favor and was very politically ambitious, Eleanor's connections stayed domestic, rooted in family, in correspondence, and in gifts. A bit of a quieter version of Tudor womanhood.

The only surviving piece of Eleanor Brandon's voice comes to us from a letter that she wrote on February 14, 1547, Valentine's Day, though she was not feeling at all romantic. She was sick and scared and writing from her lodge at Carlton. She writes, "'Since your departure from me,' to her husband Henry, "'I have been very sick, and at this present my water is very red, whereby I suppose I have the jaundice and the ague both.'"

It is a blunt physical letter, no courtly language, no flourishes. She describes pain in her side and her back, a total lack of appetite, and pleads with him to send for Dr. Stevens, for he knoweth best my complexion for such causes. She signs it simply by your assured loving wife, Eleanor Cumberland.

It's the letter of a woman who has already felt the bite of life, childbirth, rebellion, the deaths of two sons. But the letter's personal, no servants speak for her, no titles soften her plea, just Eleanor asking her husband to act quickly because she knew instinctively that this wasn't just a passing illness. She didn't recover. According to her descendant, Anne Clifford, Eleanor died toward the end of November 1547 at Brome Castle.

Other records give September 27th as the date. Either way, she was still only in her 20s. She was buried at Holy Trinity in Skipton in the same vault as her sons.

Years later, when the tomb was opened in the 17th century, observers noted that her skeleton was very tall and large-boned, and that her hair had retained the chestnut color so often associated with the Tudors. That final letter tells us what no chronicle or court rule could. Eleanor Brandon was human, vulnerable, and conscious of her fragility. And in her last known words, she wasn't looking for any favor or glory, just some relief.

Eleanor's death hit her husband hard. So hard, in fact, that some believe he died too. Anne Clifford, their descendant and one of the great chroniclers of the Clifford family history, tells us that after Eleanor's death, Henry Clifford fell into what seemed like a deathly collapse.

He was laid out on a table, covered in velvet and presumed dead, until someone noticed the faintest signs of life. They quickly administered hot cordials inwardly and outwardly, and slowly he revived. But he was far from well. According to the story, he spent weeks being nursed with milk from a wet nurse, literally suckled back to health, and then he lived on asses' milk for several months after that.

It's one of those Tudor stories that sounds a little too strange to be true, but Ian Clifford clearly believed it. And either way, it shows just how deeply Eleanor's loss affected him.

After that, Henry withdrew. He largely abandoned court life, and he focused on reading and collecting books and his rather esoteric hobbies, alchemy and natural philosophy. He kept an impressive personal library at Skipton, and by the end of his life, his interests leaned more towards symbols and spirits than politics and power. Eleanor's death seems to have changed her husband completely.

Eleanor's daughter, Margaret Clifford, born around 1540, inherited more than just a noble name. She inherited proximity to the throne, and in Tudor England, that was as much of a liability as it was a privilege. We've talked about that a lot. After Eleanor's death, Margaret became a political asset. John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland, tried to arrange a marriage between her and his son Guilford. Yes, that Guilford, who later would marry Lady Jane Grey.

When that plan fell through, Margaret was betrothed to Guilford's uncle, Andrew Dudley. That match also never happened, thanks to the spectacular collapse of the Dudley family after Lady Jane Grey's nine-day reign.

Ahorra en grande cuando compres cinco o más de tus favoritos. Simplemente compra cinco o más artículos participantes y ahorra un dólar en cada uno con tu tarjeta.

Fry's. Fresh for everyone. Epic views. Waterfall mists. Summit sunsets. It's all better outside. And with all trails, you can discover the best of nature with over 450,000 trails around the world. Download the free app today and find your next adventure. Instead, Margaret married Henry Stanley, Lord Strange, and the future 4th Earl of Derby in 1555.

Mary I and Philip of Spain were actually present at the wedding, so this shows that Margaret was still firmly within the fold of royal favor. But the marriage eventually soured, the couple lived apart, and Margaret's nearness to the throne made her dangerous in Elizabeth's eyes. She was actually accused of using astrology to divine the queen's death and identify her successor, which was an act that was, of course, considered treasonous. She spent several years under house arrest,

a soft kind of imprisonment. She died in 1596, never fully trusted and never far from suspicion. So Eleanor Brandon, she did not scandalize the court. She didn't make a bid for the crown or end up in the tower. She didn't convert, flee, or plot. She simply lived and died young.

She spent her adult life far from London in the castles of the North out of the gossip and spectacle that immortalized so many of her relatives. She left behind no grand political movement, no surviving portraits with firm attribution, and only one personal letter. There is a portrait that a lot of people think is of her. It's disputed. I'm going to use it as the cover art for this episode because, you know, when you look her name up and when you look at her on Wikipedia and in other references...

That's still the portrait that's used, but I should note that it is disputed as well. She was remembered more for her death than for anything she said or did while she was alive. But in her lifetime, Eleanor was eighth in line to the English throne. She was held hostage by rebels. Her name appeared in the king's will. She bore children. She survived sieges and she died loved.

She might not be a Tudor figurehead, but she was part of the machinery that kept the dynasty turning, and her story is worth telling. So we will leave it there for right now. Eleanor Brandon, Eleanor Clifford, really interesting woman, and I hope you enjoyed this little dive into her life.

Remember, TudorCon tickets are available at englandcast.com slash TudorCon. You can either come in person. The early bird price is still valid. That's what's up there now. Or you can come online. Use the code early bird to save $15 off of your ticket. All right, my friend, thank you so much for being here with me, for spending this time together. If you want to get in touch, you can always hop into the Tudor Learning Circle. That's TudorLearningCircle.com. It is a social network without all of the drama of social media.

but with all of the goodness of Tudor history. So TudorLearningCircle.com, I'm in there most of the time. You can subscribe to me on YouTube. If you're listening to this on YouTube, go ahead and leave a comment and tell me what you think about Eleanor Clifford, what you thought about this episode. Or you can leave a comment wherever you are listening, Spotify, Apple, wherever. I do enjoy reading your comments and your feedback.

You can also, of course, sign up for my newsletter at englandcast.com slash newsletter. I send out mostly weekly emails with Tudor news, updates from the Tudor world, updates from all of the stuff that's going on in my part of the Tudorverse, and book reviews and more. I say mostly weekly because I keep it pretty much weekly during the school year, but in the summer it all falls apart because...

Those of you who are moms with children in school will know that in summer, everything falls apart. And it's just a battle to keep going on any kind of sense of normal schedule. So we don't always get those emails out weekly in the summer, though we do try to during the rest of the year. Anyway, englandcath.com slash newsletter for that. All right, friend, I will be back with you very soon. Have an amazing week. And thanks for being here with me. I'll talk to you soon. Bye-bye.

is

Fries.

Fresh for everyone. When you think of skyrocketing brands like Aloe, Allbirds, or Skims, it's easy to credit their success to great products, sleek branding, and brilliant marketing. But here's the overlooked secret.

The real magic lies in the engine behind the scenes, the business powering their business. For millions of brands, that engine is Shopify, making selling seamless for them and shopping effortless for us. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout Alo Yoga uses.

Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash retail, all lowercase. Go to shopify.com slash retail to upgrade your selling today. shopify.com slash retail.