358 How Shallow Turns Reduce Safety in the Traffic Pattern with Dr. Catherine Cavagnaro + GA News
Aviation News Talk podcast
Deep Dive
Why are shallow turns in traffic patterns dangerous?
Shallow turns, often taught as a safety measure, can ironically increase stall-spin risk due to overshoots, especially when combined with excessive speed. A pilot maintaining high speed with a shallow bank angle will overshoot final, requiring a potentially dangerous skidding turn to correct. This is exacerbated by factors like crosswinds.
Why is a 30-degree bank angle considered safe and effective in traffic patterns?
A 30-degree bank only increases stall speed by about 7% in level flight, even less when descending, which is typical in a traffic pattern. This slight increase is far outweighed by the significant reduction in turn radius compared to a 20-degree bank (59% larger radius), allowing for tighter, more precise turns.
How does speed affect turn radius compared to bank angle?
Speed has a far greater impact. Doubling speed quadruples turn radius, while halving speed reduces it to a quarter. The relationship is squared (radius = velocity²/gravity*tan(bank angle)), highlighting the importance of airspeed management for precise turns.
Why do some CFIs teach shallow turns despite the risks?
Many CFIs fear stalls and overemphasize maintaining high speeds, mistakenly believing it prevents stalls. This perpetuates a cycle of overly cautious instruction, leading to larger, less precise patterns and increasing overshoot risk.
How can pilots determine wind direction and speed in the traffic pattern?
Observe runway alignment relative to drift on downwind. Drifting closer suggests a tailwind on base, while drifting away indicates a headwind. Other clues include ripples on lakes (wind pushes water towards the shore), smoke stacks, dust from plowing, and GPS ground speed vs. airspeed comparisons.
Why are circling approaches particularly challenging and accident-prone?
Pilots often misjudge their distance from the runway when circling at lower altitudes, leading to overshoots. Visual references used in standard patterns become inaccurate at lower heights. This is compounded by challenging weather conditions often associated with circling approaches.
Why is it crucial to nail airspeed during circling approaches and when accepting a tailwind landing?
Precise airspeed management is vital in these situations to maintain control and avoid overshoots. Adding extra speed due to nerves exacerbates the risks associated with tailwinds and circling approaches, which already demand careful planning and execution.
Why is entering the traffic pattern at high speed problematic?
High speeds increase turn radius dramatically, making it difficult to fit into the pattern and increasing the risk of overshooting or intruding into other aircraft's flight paths. This is especially dangerous at airports with parallel runways.
How can technology assist with traffic pattern awareness and safety?
Modern aircraft with traffic screens allow pilots to tag other aircraft and view their ground speeds, enabling better judgment of spacing and sequencing in the pattern. This real-time information helps prevent conflicts and ensures smoother traffic flow.
Shownotes Transcript