Fishermen have reported hearing phantom piano music emanating from the bottom of Gardner Lake. This legend traces back to an event in 1895 when a house being moved across the frozen lake sank, leaving a grand piano behind. The piano remains at the lake's bottom, and its music is said to still be heard occasionally.
In the winter of 1895, Thomas LeCount attempted to move his house across the frozen Gardner Lake using skids and horses. The house, weighing about 28 tons, was left fully furnished, including a grand piano. However, the ice cracked, and the house sank after the lake's water level dropped due to a dam being opened. The piano remains submerged to this day.
The house sank because the dam at Falls Mill in Norwich was opened overnight, lowering the water level and creating a gap between the ice and the water. This caused the ice to crack, and the heaviest part of the house, including the chimney and kitchen, broke through and sank several feet into the water.
The sinking house became a spectacle, with people coming to see it, taking photos, and even ice skating around and through it. A postcard from Salem, Connecticut, captured the scene, and a reporter from the Day newspaper described the house as an ice house, with water frozen in its rooms and furnishings like the kitchen stove still in place.
The phantom piano music is believed to be a psychic impression or 'stone tape theory' of the intense emotions felt during the house's sinking. The event left a lasting impression on the area, and over time, stories of the piano's music became part of local folklore, with some claiming to hear it drift on the wind.
Welcome to New England Legends From the Vault – FtV Episode 94 – Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger visit Gardner Lake in Salem, Connecticut, on a quest to find the source of phantom piano music that’s said to emanate from the lake itself. What happened on this lake back in 1895? This episode first aired November 30, 2017.
Listen ad-free plus get early access and bonus episodes at: https://www.patreon.com/NewEnglandLegends)