We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Tamworth robbed of a trip to Tottenham and was Raya to blame for Arsenal's FA Cup loss?

Tamworth robbed of a trip to Tottenham and was Raya to blame for Arsenal's FA Cup loss?

2025/1/13
logo of podcast It's All Kicking Off!

It's All Kicking Off!

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
C
Chris Sutton
I
Ian Ladyman
Topics
Ian Ladyman: 我认为取消足总杯重赛对低级别球队是不公平的。像Tamworth这样的球队,如果在与英超球队90分钟内战平,原本可以获得在顶级球场进行重赛的机会,这不仅能带来巨额奖金,还能让球员体验在顶级球场踢球的感受。取消重赛后,低级别球队在加时赛中很难战胜实力更强的对手,失去了创造奇迹的机会。当然,我也理解取消重赛的原因,因为对于一些球队来说,重赛会增加赛程负担,造成球员疲劳和伤病风险。但对于像Tamworth这样的球队来说,足总杯的奖金对他们的财务状况至关重要,取消重赛剥夺了他们改善财务状况的机会。 我上周提出过一个建议,即在足总杯抽签后,让低级别球队可以选择主场或客场,这至少能让他们有机会通过主场优势获得更多收入。但这也很难实现,因为这其中存在很多灰色地带,比如两支球队实力差距悬殊的情况。 总而言之,我认为足总杯应该兼顾顶级球队和低级别球队的利益,取消重赛对低级别球队造成了不公平的影响,应该寻找更合理的解决方案。 Chris Sutton: 我同意Ian的观点,取消足总杯重赛对低级别球队是不公平的。这不仅剥夺了他们获得巨额奖金的机会,也剥夺了他们创造奇迹,在顶级球场与强队一较高下的机会。很多低级别球队都依靠足总杯的奖金来维持俱乐部的运营,取消重赛直接影响了他们的财务状况。 虽然我知道一些球队并不需要重赛,甚至重赛对他们来说是一种负担,但足总杯的意义不仅仅在于顶级球队的竞争,更在于低级别球队创造奇迹的故事。取消重赛,让足总杯失去了这种魅力。 我与一位低级别联赛的教练进行了交流,他表示,如果他的球队与强队战平,重赛将是他们最糟糕的结果,因为这会增加球队的负担。但这并不意味着应该取消重赛,足总杯是一个面向所有级别球队的赛事,足总有责任为所有级别的球队服务,而现在他们正在辜负像Tamworth这样的球队。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why was Tamworth's FA Cup match against Tottenham considered a betrayal of lower-league football?

Tamworth's match against Tottenham highlighted the FA's decision to scrap replays without proper consultation, which was seen as a betrayal of lower-league clubs. Previously, Tamworth would have earned a replay at Tottenham's stadium, potentially securing a significant financial reward. Instead, they lost in extra time, missing out on a chance for a lucrative replay.

What was the financial impact of Tamworth missing out on a replay against Tottenham?

Tamworth missed out on a potential £1 million payday by not securing a replay at Tottenham's stadium. This money could have been transformative for the semi-professional club, helping them financially and potentially saving the club from difficulties.

Why did David Raya's early movement during penalties draw criticism?

David Raya's early movement during the penalty shootout against Manchester United was criticized because it made it easier for penalty takers to adjust and score. His premature diving gave United's players an advantage, and his approach was seen as ineffective and poorly timed.

What was the outcome of the FA Cup match between Manchester United and Arsenal?

Manchester United defeated Arsenal in a penalty shootout after a dramatic match that ended in a draw. United's reserve goalkeeper, Altay Bayindir, was the hero, saving two penalties, including one from Kai Havertz, to secure the win.

Why is there frustration with the PFA's support for ex-players like Dean Windass?

There is frustration with the PFA because they have not provided adequate financial support for ex-players suffering from dementia, such as Dean Windass. Families often face long, arduous processes to receive help, while their loved ones' conditions worsen. Critics argue that the PFA should do more given the wealth in football.

What was the significance of Hayden Hollis' moment in Tamworth's match against Tottenham?

Hayden Hollis, a Tamworth defender, produced a moment of skill reminiscent of Maradona by bamboozling a Tottenham player with a clever turn. This moment, though not typical of his game, highlighted the spirit and determination of lower-league players in the FA Cup.

What was Ange Postecoglou's notable comment before the Tamworth-Tottenham match?

Ange Postecoglou remarked, 'Never judge someone by the house they live in. Some of the most unlikable people I've met live in some pretty nice houses.' This comment, made in response to questions about Tamworth's modest facilities, showcased his humility and perspective.

Why did Kyle Walker's potential departure from Manchester City become a talking point?

Kyle Walker's potential departure from Manchester City became a talking point after Pep Guardiola revealed that Walker had asked to leave. This decision was seen as surprising, given Walker's contributions to the club, but it reflects the ruthless nature of football and City's pursuit of maintaining high standards.

Chapters
This chapter discusses the controversy surrounding the FA's decision to scrap replays in the FA Cup. The debate focuses on the financial impact on lower-league teams who miss out on lucrative replays against Premier League opponents, contrasting this with the burden of extra fixtures on already stretched teams.
  • Scrapping replays disadvantages lower-league teams financially.
  • The debate includes the perspectives of lower-league managers and fans.
  • Alternative solutions like giving lower-league teams home/away choice are discussed.

Shownotes Transcript

Welcome back to 'It's All Kicking Off!'

In this episode, Ian and Chris discuss Tamworth's heroics in the FA Cup against Spurs, in a result that last year would seen them book a money-spinning replay at the Tottenham Hotspur stadium. This time around, they lost in extra time.

Elsewhere Man United continued their resurgence by knocking Arsenal out competition on penalties - but what was David Raya doing moving so early on the spot kicks!?

They also take a trip around the other talking points of the weekend, answer some listener questions, and Chris has his say on the PFA's support for ex-players, as Dean Windass this week opens up about his dementia diagnosis.

Presenters: Ian Ladyman and Chris Sutton

Producer: John Rogers

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)