BFG Podcast #149: 'Challengers,' writers intimidate PEN America, and a new memoir from Salman Rushdie
Book and Film Globe Podcast
Deep Dive
What is the main criticism of PEN America in the podcast?
PEN America is criticized for its members' refusal to participate in awards ceremonies and the World Voices Festival due to their stance on Israel, which is seen as prioritizing trendy social justice concerns over the organization's core mission of defending free speech.
What is Salman Rushdie's memoir 'Knife' about?
Salman Rushdie's memoir 'Knife' details his near-fatal stabbing in August 2022, his recovery process, and his reflections on freedom of speech. It also includes a 26-page imagined dialogue with his attacker, exploring themes of religious fundamentalism and the power of language.
Why does Neal Pollack find Salman Rushdie's memoir 'Knife' exasperating?
Neal Pollack finds 'Knife' exasperating because Rushdie spends a significant portion of the book detailing his medical recovery, including UTIs and physical therapy, rather than addressing broader issues of free speech and the current threats to it from progressive writers.
What is the central theme of the movie 'Challengers'?
The central theme of 'Challengers' is a love triangle involving Zendaya's character and two male tennis players, exploring their complex relationships, competitiveness, and unfulfilled dreams. The film blends romance, drama, and sports, with a focus on adult themes and emotional depth.
What are the criticisms of the movie 'Challengers' mentioned in the podcast?
The criticisms of 'Challengers' include its nonlinear narrative structure, which some find confusing, and the overbearing use of musical cues, particularly during the climax. However, the performances and the script are praised for their depth and maturity.
What is the controversy surrounding PEN America and the Israel-Hamas conflict?
PEN America has faced backlash from writers who accuse it of being too soft on Israel and not taking a strong enough stance against the Israel-Hamas conflict. This has led to protests, open letters, and the withdrawal of nominees from PEN's literary awards, culminating in the cancellation of the World Voices Festival.
How does Salman Rushdie address the issue of freedom of speech in 'Knife'?
In 'Knife,' Salman Rushdie reflects on the importance of freedom of speech but criticizes the growing trend among progressive writers to prioritize protecting vulnerable groups over defending free expression. He expresses concern that this shift undermines the values he has long championed.
What is the significance of the imagined dialogue in Salman Rushdie's 'Knife'?
The imagined dialogue in 'Knife' between Rushdie and his attacker is a philosophical exploration of the nature of violence, religious fundamentalism, and the power of language. It is described as a tour de force, showcasing Rushdie's intellectual and literary prowess.
What is the role of Zendaya's character in 'Challengers'?
Zendaya's character in 'Challengers' is a former tennis prodigy turned coach, who is deeply passionate about tennis but struggles with emotional intimacy. She becomes the focal point of a love triangle between two male tennis players, driving much of the film's drama and tension.
What is the broader critique of the literary community in the podcast?
The podcast critiques the literary community for its increasing intolerance of diverse viewpoints, particularly regarding the Israel-Hamas conflict. Writers are accused of adopting a single, rigid perspective and shutting down open debate, which undermines the principles of free speech and intellectual freedom.
- Rushdie's 'Knife' recounts his near-fatal stabbing and recovery.
- Pollack praises the book's vivid descriptions of physical and emotional trauma.
- Pollack criticizes Rushdie's limited discussion of free speech attacks from the left.
- Rushdie's silence on PEN America's actions is highlighted.
Shownotes Transcript