EP82. 犯罪者可以有跟我一樣的「人權」嗎？｜劉珞亦 X 22位公民
公視主題之夜SHOW
Deep Dive
Why is it important to discuss the human rights of criminals?
Discussing the human rights of criminals is crucial because how a country treats its most marginalized individuals, including criminals, reflects its commitment to human rights. This discussion challenges societal norms and ensures that even those who have committed crimes are treated with dignity and fairness, which is essential for a just and humane society.
What are the main purposes of prisons according to the participants?
Participants identified three main purposes of prisons: punishment, isolation, and rehabilitation. Punishment serves as a form of retribution for crimes committed, isolation protects society by keeping offenders away from the public, and rehabilitation aims to reform offenders and prepare them for reintegration into society.
How do participants view the idea of 'luxury' prisons similar to those in Nordic countries?
Participants have mixed views on 'luxury' prisons. Some argue that such environments can aid in rehabilitation by treating prisoners humanely and preparing them for societal reintegration. Others believe that it may not align with societal expectations of punishment and could lead to public dissatisfaction and perceptions of unfairness.
What is the potential impact of streaming life in prisons 24/7?
Streaming life in prisons 24/7 could serve a dual purpose: it educates the public about the realities of prison life and could motivate prisoners to behave better under constant surveillance. However, it also raises concerns about privacy and the psychological impact on prisoners.
Why might some people prefer being exiled to a remote location over traditional imprisonment?
Some individuals might prefer exile to a remote location over traditional imprisonment because it allows them to avoid the negative influences and potentially corrupting environment of prisons. It offers a form of isolation that can be seen as a fresh start in a new setting, away from societal judgments and pressures.
- 台灣監獄現況與北歐監獄差距甚大
- 紀錄片呈現監獄工作者努力改善現況的過程
- 更生人、編輯、音樂工作者、工程師等不同職業的公民，從不同角度分享觀影心得及對監獄議題的看法
Shownotes Transcript