We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode 238.  Is this the final chapter of the war in Ukraine?

238. Is this the final chapter of the war in Ukraine?

2025/1/10
logo of podcast Battleground

Battleground

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Alan Philps
P
Patrick Bishop
S
Saul David
Topics
Patrick Bishop: 我认为乌克兰目前的攻势是为了在未来的和平谈判中占据更有利的战略地位,争取更多的领土筹码。同时,俄罗斯在顿巴斯地区的攻势也并未停止,这显示出战争的复杂性和持续性。虽然俄罗斯的损失很大,但目前还不足以导致其战线的崩溃。美国对乌克兰的援助至关重要,如果援助停止,情况将会更加严峻。 在外交方面,泽连斯基积极主动地与特朗普政府沟通,试图塑造有利的和平谈判局面,并争取安全保障。他通过各种方式向特朗普示好,并试图影响特朗普的决策。 总的来说,乌克兰战争的未来走向充满了不确定性,这取决于多方力量的博弈,以及特朗普政府的具体政策。 Saul David: 乌克兰在库尔斯克地区发起了新的攻势,旨在扭转俄罗斯此前取得的进展。同时,俄罗斯在顿涅茨克地区的攻势也取得了重大进展,夺取了楚拉科沃,这使得俄罗斯距离波克罗夫斯克更近了一步。如果波克罗夫斯克失守,将对乌克兰的防御造成重大打击。 在和平谈判方面,关键在于美国能否向乌克兰提供可靠的安全保障。乌克兰需要的是切实的安全保障,而不是简单的停火协议。特朗普政府的态度和具体政策将对和平谈判的进程产生重大影响。 基思·凯洛格作为特朗普政府的乌克兰谈判代表,他的立场和计划将对未来的谈判产生重要影响。 Alan Philps: 我认为普京是一位技艺高超的战术家,而非战略大师。他目前的策略是利用西方的妥协来达到自己的目的,通过不断地拒绝西方的提议,来争取更有利的谈判地位。他并不急于与乌克兰进行谈判,而是希望通过拖延时间来削弱乌克兰和西方的力量。 俄罗斯的经济状况虽然面临挑战,但目前还能够维持战争。普京的国际地位受到了损害,但他仍然认为俄罗斯在国际格局中扮演着重要角色。他与中国的关系虽然密切,但也存在潜在的风险。 普京的垮台最终会到来,但他可能还会在权力顶峰待上几年。他的垮台方式难以预测,但各种潜在的风险都可能导致他的下台。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What is the current military situation in Ukraine as described in the podcast?

Ukrainian forces have launched a new offensive in the Kursk salient, aiming to reverse Russian gains made since August. The attack involves tanks and armored personnel carriers, with Russian forces countering using airpower and armor. Key areas of focus include Berdin, located 35 kilometers inside the Russian border, and the region northeast of Sudza. Both Ukrainian and Russian officials have confirmed the attacks, with the Kremlin dispatching General Yunusbek Yevkirov to the Kursk region in response.

Why is the capture of Churakovo significant in the Ukraine war?

Churakovo is a major milestone on the path to Pokrovsk, a strategic Ukrainian stronghold. Pokrovsk serves as a critical logistics base and transport hub for Ukraine's military, with multiple roads and railway lines intersecting there. The fall of Churakovo brings Russian forces within 35 kilometers of Pokrovsk, tightening the encirclement from the south. Losing Pokrovsk would severely hinder Ukraine's ability to move troops, provisions, and ammunition across the eastern front line, bringing the war closer to central Ukraine, including the city of Dnipro.

What are Zelensky's diplomatic strategies ahead of potential peace talks?

Zelensky is actively shaping the diplomatic landscape by signaling readiness for peace to Donald Trump, emphasizing his eagerness to engage constructively. He is also setting the agenda by proposing ideas that Trump could adopt, such as offering strong security guarantees. Zelensky has made media appearances, including a three-hour interview with a Russian-born podcaster, Lex Friedman, to appeal to Republican-leaning audiences. He has also hinted at concessions, such as limiting security guarantees to currently held Ukrainian territory, while stressing the need for cast-iron guarantees to prevent future Russian aggression.

What is Putin's strategy regarding peace talks with Ukraine, according to Alan Philps?

Putin is described as a consummate tactician who uses long-term Soviet and Russian negotiating tactics. He encourages Western proposals for peace talks, only to reject them and push for further concessions. For example, he initially suggested delaying Ukraine's NATO entry for 10 years, but now demands a total rejection of NATO membership and a veto on Ukraine's foreign policy. Putin aims to create a baseline for negotiations by accumulating Western concessions, which he can then use as a starting point if talks eventually occur. He believes Russia can sustain its position as long as oil prices remain above $60 a barrel.

What risks does Putin face in dealing with Donald Trump?

Putin risks provoking Trump, who is unpredictable and does not tolerate being disappointed. Trump has signaled that full support for Ukraine, including military and economic aid, could be used as leverage against Russia. Putin's strategy of delaying and rejecting peace proposals could backfire if Trump decides to escalate support for Ukraine, potentially tipping the balance in Ukraine's favor. Additionally, Putin's reliance on China and North Korea as allies could become a liability, as China may view Russia as increasingly dependent and less of an asset.

How secure is Putin's position domestically and internationally?

Domestically, Putin's position appears stable for now, as he retains control over the media and key power structures. However, the Russian economy is struggling, with significant price hikes for staples like potatoes, which could fuel discontent in the provinces. Internationally, Putin's standing has been dented by setbacks in Syria and Iran, but he sees growing support from pro-Russian factions in Central Europe. His reliance on China as a major ally is a double-edged sword, as it risks reducing Russia to a vassal state. While his downfall is inevitable, it is unlikely to occur in the next two years.

Chapters
A new Ukrainian offensive near Kursk has surprised observers. The aim seems to be regaining lost territory for leverage in peace negotiations, possibly anticipating a quicker resolution under a Trump presidency.
  • Ukrainian forces launched a new offensive near Berdin, Kursk.
  • The offensive involves tanks and armored personnel carriers.
  • The aim is likely to regain territory for leverage in peace negotiations.
  • The timing suggests an assumption that Donald Trump will push for peace talks.

Shownotes Transcript

With President Trump’s inauguration only ten days away speculation swirling around as to whether the last chapter in the Ukraine war is about to open. Together Saul and Patrick look at how Trump will approach this first great problem facing his leadership.

But they also turn to Russia and Putin in particular. To help them look at how things may play out inside the Kremlin they'll be talking to Alan Philps, longtime Moscow correspondent for

Reuters and the Daily Telegraph and veteran Russia watcher who gives his thoughts about how things may play out in the coming year.

If you have any thoughts or questions, you can send them to - [email protected]

Producer: James Hodgson

X: @PodBattleground

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)