We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Bluesky Scraper - DTNS 4905

Bluesky Scraper - DTNS 4905

2024/11/27
logo of podcast Daily Tech News Show

Daily Tech News Show

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
S
Scott Johnson
技术和媒体领域的主播和评论员,专注于分析最新的技术和媒体趋势。
T
Tom Merritt
知名科技播客主播和制作人,长期从事在线内容创作。
Topics
Tom Merritt 认为 Hugging Face 的机器学习管理员 Daniel Situmorang 发布的包含一百万条 Bluesky 公开帖子的数据集,虽然初衷是用于机器学习研究,但由于未经用户同意,违反了数据收集的透明度和同意原则,最终被删除。他认为,在没有新的法律法规的情况下,公开数据的抓取行为将持续存在,Bluesky 的做法是允许用户表达同意,这是一种折中的方案。 Scott Johnson 认为从公开网站抓取公开数据用于研究并不违法,Bluesky 对此无能为力,这引发了关于数据抓取的讨论。他认为抓取公开数据是互联网的固有部分,现在需要重新审视这种做法。他认为数据抓取用于研究是常见的,即使未被注意到。他认为 Bluesky 的回应是基于其平台的开放性,他们无法阻止数据抓取,但正在探索让用户表达同意的途径。他认为,如果想要一个开放的互联网,就必须允许公开数据被使用。 Scott Johnson 认为艺术家们对 OpenAI 使用他们的作品进行公关感到不满,这反映了 AI 与艺术家之间关系的复杂性。他认为艺术家们对 AI 工具的态度是复杂的,既认可其潜力,也担忧其负面影响。他认为艺术家们公开表达担忧是积极的,OpenAI 的回应过于官方化。他认为艺术家们感到不被尊重,因为 OpenAI 似乎只关注积极的反馈,而非实际的改进。他认为 AI 公司需要更好地与艺术家合作,倾听他们的反馈,避免将其仅仅视为公关工具。

Deep Dive

Chapters
The discussion revolves around the ethical and legal implications of scraping public data from social media platforms like Bluesky for machine learning research.
  • A dataset of one million Bluesky posts was scraped for machine learning research.
  • The creator of the dataset removed it due to backlash, highlighting the controversy around data scraping.
  • Bluesky's response emphasizes the honor system and the difficulty of controlling public data usage.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

If you want to stay off the date on the latest, take news and about five minutes subscribed the daily take adler es as D A I L Y, take headlines wherever you get your pocket.

Runs here from mid mobile with the Price of just about everything going up during inflation. We thought we bring our Prices down. So to help us, we've rought in .

a reverse auctioneer, which is apparently a thing that I4444 .

in mobile .

guy com slash switch, forty five dollars, up from payment to b to fifty dollars month, new customers on three months only taxes, export speeds lower before give B, C, D.

The holidays are all about sharing with family meals, couches, stories, grandma secret peachey recipe. And now you can also share a card with instincts, family cards, everyone can add what they want to one group card from wherever they are. So you don't have to go from room to room to find out who wants crawberry sauce, or whether you should get many marshmallows for the yams or collecting votes for sugar cookies versus shortbread. Just share a card and then share the meals in the moments. Download the installed APP and get delivery in his fastest thirty minutes plus enjoy free delivery on your first three orders.

Service fees and terms apply. Magic S W S got all issues to make your season extra. Mary believe you've got parties to attend the list to check. So D S W is taking care of the detail like gifts to make their eyes on the glow styles that brings joy to your world brand everyone wants like ug, nike, birkenstock and more and deals to make your budget right. Finds of perfect shoes for you and yours at A D S W store near you or S W 点 com pitch this you're in the garage.

hands covered in greece. Just finished ed up tuning your engine with a party you found on ebay and you realize, you know what, I can also use new bricks. So where do you go next back to ebay? And you've got ebay guaranteed fit.

You order apart. And if IT doesn't fit, send IT back, simple as that. So when you dive into your next car project, start with ebay. All the parts you need at Prices you love, guaranteed to fit every time ebay things people love.

Daily techno show is made possible by you listening right now, thanks to all of you, including paul boy, Kevin Morgan, paul tian, and bring a new patron. Jessica. Thank you, Jessica. On this episode of DNS blue sky is not big enough to have an AI controversy of the groups so fast OpenAI anger some artists who used to like IT and SONY loses a long time play .

station team star.

This is the daily tech news for wednesday, november twenty seventh, twenty twenty four in los angles, sometimes amErica .

from studio animal house on .

sale in the city. Scot Johnson.

and get this out of the way right off top the show because a lot of times we're forget. And then people who aren't in the us. Get freak out. There's no daily technical show thursday or friday this week. We have holidays to very important holidays in the .

thanksgiving.

Well, thanksgiving is the lesser of the two. But then black, huge.

I was like, what's the second one? O right? Yeah, we have to eat tomorrow and then we have to buy on friday calories.

Yeah.

burn calories. It's it's the circle of life.

Uh, so you'll get daily to cart lines in the feed. Don't worry about that. You'll get some news and we'll for show on monday, but we still have to do this show. So let's start with the crickets.

Spotify is adding support for gemini on android, meaning that you can use natural language to ask your phone to find and play music. German I can connect the spotify APP to find a song by title or artist or album or playful name. IT can also start playing songs meant for a particular activity, if you so desire.

The future is so rolling out. But once fully functional, IT should work without needing to open, open up the spotify up at all. Spotify, the second non google APP after what's up to get german I integration.

None of these voice activated things ever get the band names I want them to play right. Was sara to us? I let.

Now they don't. Tiktok is now limiting which appearances affects users can access if they're Younger than eighteen. IT in list which ones. But we're talking about the beauty effects probably.

Tiktok also said that will increase how much information filters give users about what IT will change about their appearances you know you're getting into before you turn the filter on. Tiktok is also testing using machine learning to detect if the user might be Younger than thirteen, despite saying they aren't. When detected, the algorithms send that account to a human moderator to review and confirm that test will start in the U. K.

Rasper pii launched the compute module five is a single board computer with no ports useful for people making embedded applications. Technical notes that industrial and embedded companies make up seventy two percent of rasberry prize sales, at least as far as twenty twenty three. Computer model five has a quad core ARM core tex, a seventy six processor support for two four k display es with that h sixty hurt refresh rate, give a bit eternit wifi, bluetooth and starts at forty five dollars. Open my eyes.

Letting its employees sell about one and a half billion dollars worth of shares to soft bank. This is the soft bank wants to increase it's recent six point six billion dollar of funding round. They needed some creative ways to do IT because reasons in the financial world, soft bank CEO museo c. Sn supposedly pushed for the move to increase soft bank state a stake soft bank has previously invested in apple and qualcomm and alibaba, so a lot of people pay attention to what they invest in. And IT currently has stakes not only an open a eye, which is had for a while, but perplexity, as well as two other AI startups pull side and Green.

A us appeals court ruled that the treasury's office of foreign assets control, or o ac o fac, exceeded its authority by sanctioning tornado cashes immutable table smart contracts. The court says that these mark contracts can be considered property under U. S. Law and can be blocked under sanctions. Either the decision reverses a previous ruling and grants partial summary judgment to torture or cash users, enabling them to access the platform.

We've all been there scrambling for a last minute gift that doesn't feel last minute. With trade, you can send a coffee subscription directly to someone's in box in minutes. It's fast, easy and guaranteed to impress.

A trade subscription isn't just coffee, it's an experience. Every month, we'll get a new freshly roasted coffee perfectly matched to their taste from one of the top small batch roast in the USA, ready to cross that last gift of your list. Trade is offering their best savings of the year on subscriptions right now.

So had to drink. Trade, dark, calm, slashed. D, T, N, S, send a personalized coffee subscription in minutes.

Pitch this.

You're in the garage, hands covered in greece. Just finished ed up, tuning your engine with a party you found on ebay. And you realize, you know what? I can also use new brakes.

So where do you go next? Back to ebay? You can find anything there.

It's unreal wipers, headlights, even called erin tics. It's all there. And you've got ebay guaranteed fit.

You order a part. And if IT doesn't fit, send IT back, simple as that. Look, D I Y fixes can be major. Doesn't matter if it's just maintain or a major mod. You got IT, especially when things are guaranteed defeat.

So when you dive into your next car project, start with ebay, all the parts you need at Prices you'll love guarantee to fit every time ebay things people love when you're starting or scaling your company. Is security program demonstrating top notch security practices and establishing trust is more important than ever. Fanta automates compliance for I soo twenty seven O O one soc 2 gdpr and more, saving you time and money while helping you build customer trust.

Plus, you can streamline security reviews by automating questionnaire and demonstrating your security posture with a customer facing trust center, all powered by venta AI. Over eight thousand global companies like a asian flow health and cora use venta to manage risk and prove security in real time. Our audience gets a special offer of one thousand dollars off venta at venter dot com slash D T N S. That's venter dot com slash D T N S. For one thousand dollars off.

Meet claude, the AI assistant from map prop c. That's transforming how organizations work. Imagine every person on your team having an expert collaborator who knows your company inside and out.

That's claud. When you upload company documents in a claud, you're giving IT the context to become your subject matter expert and deliver a student helpful responses. Clod helps engineers ship products faster, marketers craft compelling campaigns, and sales teams personalized our Richard scale from brainstorming execution.

Claude looks like a team may not at all empower every person in your organization with A I that's both powerful and protected. Your data stays yours by default. We never train our models on your company conversations in content, join leading enterprises already working smarter with claude, transform your organizations productivity, and visit anthropic dock com slash enterprise discover .

hydro the best cap secret and fitness hydro is the state of the art home role that engage eighty six percent of your muscles, delivering the ultimate full body workout in just one minutes. From advanced to beginner. Hydro has over five thousand classes, not worldwide, and taught by olympians .

and world class athletes for a thirty day risk free trial. Got a hydro dot com and use code row to say four hundred and seventy five dollars on a hydro pro roll that H Y D R O W come cold row.

Four or four media published article tuesday evening titled somebody made a dataset of one million blue sky post for machine learning research that that was the first post a machine learning librarian working at hugging face. Daniel then stream released to data set composed of one million blue sky post, complete with what they were posted and who posted them, intended for machine learning research.

Now then stream initially said, when share sharing the data set, this dataset contains one million public post connected from blue sky socials firehose API, intended for machine learning research and experimenting with social media. A data each post contains text content, meta data and information about media attachments and reply relationships. Now, van stran has since removed the data, said, due to some backlash of people saying you shouldn't have done this posting on blue sky quote, i've removed the blue sky data from the repeal.

Well, I wanted to support tool development for the platform. I recognize this approach. Violate principles of transparency and consent in data collection. I apologize for this mistake. Okay, so I thought this this would be a good jump in in off point to talk about what we how do we feel about scraping of data.

A blue guy obviously been in the news as of late because a lot of people have joined the network trying to figure out of its if it's their new eggs or a supplement to that type thing. But a scraping data is controversial. Scott, what do you think?

Well, I think that this is an interesting story because I think the natural function for a lot of people's to go up, here we go again. Another platform, and this one happens to have a moment of growth is going to to share your data. There's this sort of feeling right to jump on those those things.

And this is not what happening here at all, really. This is just a story about somebody who went to a public website that has public data, scraped that data and is now using IT for his research and and people are more going after that person than blue sky and blue skies response to sort of like, well, it's an honor system thing. There's not a lot, a lot we can do and I agree with them like it's just the internet.

There's stuff out there. You're going to go scrape IT and people are going to do IT with your with thor without your permission. We don't have laws to protect this if there need to be any at all anyway.

And IT is just the way of IT moving forward. So in this particular case, I I don't wanted to say it's so much to do about nothing even though what kind of is in some respects. But I think IT is good that IT does continually bring up this discussion of is how we want to do this.

Are we okay with this? Open and free data for a long time was just a built in part of the internet that was why was so great, and we all embraced that. Well, now we have an open and free internet that can now be scraped and used for other things, sometimes things that you'll have no credit in the work you did that IT got scrape or whatever IT is.

So there's questions now, right? We've changed the conversation has been tweet, and I think it's good to have IT as often as we need to have IT. But I think in this particular case, it's just illust of the idea that blue guide, twitter, anyone, nobody can really do anything about public data. And I don't think this guy had need like ill intent. I think everybody he's trying to do these studies right now, how much of money there are other versions of the same data sitting on somebody who's research derive and they're .

just not telling us, yeah just wasn't noticed. I mean, of course, I mean, the whole idea is social networks are a great way to understand human behavior. I mean, is that going to make the next large language model that's right for you? Biology may very, but is something that researchers are very interested in doing.

I don't know you some of the the sense from what loose guy said, which was basically like, hey, you know as you said, got honour system here. We just we can like that. That is if you do that, then that's on you.

We can we we're not onna, shut down the whole network. Just make sure that bad actors don't have access to this information. And I think depending on who you are, you might think that's the right thing to do or or not.

I don't think people really let mean, let me rephrase this. There's a lot of people who are just against stuff because that's what you do. I'm against people collecting A I I wonder what percentage of people in the data set really objective, like if they were given the choice directly, really would have objected.

Uh, blue skies promise is that this is an open system where your posts can be migrated from server to server, right? It's it's a festival like approach, just like master on this is not really scraping. Scraping is when you go and you get a website, you scrape the data of IT.

This is using the API, the API that is meant to be open for people to access, post and be able to do something. It's one of the foundations of blue sky. So it's not just that blue guy is like, well, it's the honor system is not much we can do.

It's like this is how the system was designed. The other thing blue guy said was we are looking into ways to let users express whether they give consent, not so that someone who doesn't want to play by the rules can say, oh, well, i'll only use the post where someone is given consent to be trained on IT. Uh, I also don't know what damage comes from your public blue sky post being used in a machine learning a training data, but that's probably a versac for another day but if you want .

if if I were like, i'm sorry and here's my address and they're somehow also it's machine learning.

It's not like large language models. Usually people are like you're you're going to we imitate me. This is an a large language mental. It's a machine learning situation. So it's entirely different.

I just I did no, I don't want to go on and on and on about this, but it's the same thing i've been saying, which is it's not illegal. And my Scott set up very eloquently, if you want to open internet, you have to allow IT to be open to to be used. And I think blue guy has the right idea, which is like, let's give people a way to say whether they consent or not. So the people who want to respect that can but until we get a new law about whether a public data is uh, acceptable for you or what the rules around using IT should be, you're going to have a lot of these kinds of situations.

yes. Yeah I don't again, I don't even think this one is one that would prompt any of that nobody. He's going to go right? Kind is he's trying .

to play nice with people.

And yeah, this is one. This isn't like a turning point of.

The most important part of the story is the blue guys big enough that people got mad.

Yeah, that's actually kind of the hidden headline isn't IT, but it's big enough that now now we finally have an a controversy around another platform that wasn't one of the big ones we're always complain about. And that's interesting in its own little way.

But speaking of big eye companies that people get mad at, on tuesday, a group of artists had been given early access to OpenAIce so ra vi deo ge nerator. Released a version of the tour publicly on hugging face. This hugging face in another story, this version used their tokens are, in other words, the artist tokens, the artists who had been given private access to give anyone access to sora.

They essentially published a front, and they use their tokens. Their tool could only generate up to ten seconds of video at ten A D, P. Those ort, supposedly sorry, can generate up to sixty seconds.

Along with the release, nineteen artists wrote an open letter saying, and I quote, we received access to sorrow with the promise to be early testers, red teamers and creative partners. However, we believe instead we are being lured into art washing to tell the world that sora is a useful tool for artists. We are not your free bug testers, pr puppets, training data or validation tokens.

The artist also accused OpenAI of using them as unpaid labor, pointing out that the only compensation anybody would get was that a few of the testers would have their creations screened publicly. They added, we are not against the use of AI technology as a tool for the arts. If we were, we probably wouldn't have been invited to this program.

We are sharing this to the world in the hopes that OpenAI becomes more open, more artist friendly and supports the arts. And beyond pr stance, OpenAI responded by saying, like, look, this is still in development, is a limited number of artists with, but they have free access. We don't tell him what they can do, or even if they have to do anything.

They suspended all access to sort a temporary rely while they figured out how to shut down this public one and claim that only a few of the artists to sign this open letter were actually part of its early access program. It's got you're an artist. I'm curious what sense you get from this is these are people like we like A I this isn't an anti AI activist move. We are just mad at the way OpenAIs tr.

eating us we ll. It's it's a tear of the of this AI artist thing that I hadn't considered very, very much. And that is this kind of middle group where you, on the one hand, you have an extreme group over here, which I sometimes take my toe, which is, man, the stuff stinks.

Please stop doing IT. This is bad for the future, is bad for artists, all that sort of stuff. And then there's the other extreme where a is the future.

And this is all we're going to use. And forget about anything else. This is the new, and everything else is old in the middle.

There, though, there is some pretty reasonable, more centrist thinking folks who know that some of this technology not only is here to stay, but actually could be really beneficial, like they say in their own quote, beneficial to the yards, good tools for the arts. It's it's a tRicky thing to navigate because it's not simple. It's not just well, there's one things okay and other things okay.

Sometimes it's sorrow. Sorrow is as a as a product sora rather as a product may have lots of good points, the bad points and middle income. And that's I think kind of their point.

I think that this is a group. I trust their voices more than I would the other extremes. Um they either pro or way to anti the ones in the medal is the ones that are kind of putting rubble to the road.

They are also invited to this or at least some of them according to open eye. And I want to hear this is kind of what I do want to hear in these in these processes, not just that, well, we had some artisan nda. They all fit with the thing. And on the other end of this, you will get to hear where that they liked IT or not, and they promoted or they won't or whatever I liked that they're speaking up now if they have concerns, because if they have concerns, i'm way more interested in them having them than I am either of the other two extremes. So I see this is a good thing, and I think that open a eye's response is very corporate, but not in the spirit at which we are trying to get all this in right now.

Yeah, if he feels like these artists are saying you just wanted hear positive things for us and we were trying to tell you I didn't work very well.

That's what the pr pup t part of this sounded like to me because it's sort of like if you have a access to a tool that isn't available to anybody else, which you know we all do from time to time, it's like, yeah, I am your bug tester. I am contributing tear training data I mean, that sort of the part of being in a bear testy system, but I don't feel like being part of a pr machine is any handshake agreement that I ever have to have? I'm not exactly sure what the artists uh, thought that they needed to agree to or you know if if there was some sort of a shake down going on, I don't know, but but that's the part words like yeah if they this if this group really felt that way, then that would be something that you would push back on.

Feels like they don't feel respected because they're saying we don't have a problem with A I we might have you know some helpful things to say about whether this tool is useful or not, but they're not listening to us.

Yeah, I think that there is a general feeling among artists when IT comes to that side of what OpenAI is doing because their stuff is so multifaceted. A lot of these companies with that now it's not just, hey, we make images. These guys make videos more over here doing l EMS.

Everybody's doing kind of everything, and they trying to cater to this stuff. And part of that is they want to do tools. They require some form of, hey, that the community of artists, creators, filmmakers, whatever they're with us on this.

And so IT does fill a little P, R stunt if they're not actually taking feedback, if it's just being administered like A P R move. And even if IT isn't, even if open the eyes, intentions are are pure and every possible way. This is the area I just think that needs the most work in A I stuff is the artist and the engineers like coming up on time.

like you who wanted to participate on your side. There is a problem, even if it's not the majority of there is a problem.

Yes, yes, I saw something. I think they can find, they can find some common ground on this. But again, this illustrates we are at a junction point on some of the stuff, and it's interesting to see the pushback. Well.

if you have thought about something we talk about on the show, but you're not an A I who has access to our email address, well, humans here IT is feedback. A daily techne .

showed up up. IT took a lifetime to find the person you wanna. Ry, finding the perfect engagement ring is a lot easier at blue, ie. That com.

You can find or design the ring you've always dreamed of with help from blue miles jewelry experts who are on hand, twenty four seven answer questions and the easing convenience of shopping online for a limited time. Get fifty dollars off your purchase of five hundred dollars or more with code. Listen at blue nile that com, that's fifty dollars off with code. Listen a blue now that come right here for.

I guess, my friends ID. erie.

No, no, no, no, no, no. Honestly, when I started this, I had only have to do like four of these is unlimited to premium wireless for fifteen thousand. And how are there still people paying two or three times that much? So I shouldn't be victim blaming here.

Give me a try at mid mobile disco flash switch, whatever you're ready. Forty five dollars up from payment equivalent fifteen dollars per month. New customers on first three month plan only taxes and these extra speeds lower about forty gives details. Now i'm wondering how many A I um robots have sent us emails and we .

just don't know.

I don't know, have no idea.

Well, you don't know is sometimes you can kind of tell, uh, alright, so very, very different subject. Key player in the development of songs play station game console hey, you shed down is stepping down after thirty eight years with the company initiated was one of the original members at the playstation project back in one thousand nine hundred ninety three.

He also spared, headed the divisions license ene program, and in turn became a producer for major game titles like grand to remove. In two thousand, he became VP of sona computer entertainment america, followed by a role of senior vice president of sce worldwide o USA in two thousand seven. Finally, in two thousand eight, he became the president of c worldwide studios. So, uh, usha has been, or round the block, Scott Johnson, uh, what? What do the gamers make of this?

Well, i'm a huge fan of this ban on his legacy. I think that IT is notable to say that I think accurate to say that sony's current position in the worlwide electronics marketplace is directly affected by decisions that he and his team members made to make them a premiere brand in gaming at a time where there was a rapidity happening between two, three d all this sort of stuff.

And they're dealing ahead with the intendo, which looked like a pretty good partnership for a long time. He was also involved in that. Um I think them recognizing that man, we really just want to like hook our wagon to this wagon and just be part of another person's wagon.

Or do we want to be our own frequent video game wagon? And they chose the latter and the rough. A lot of fathers like intendo, I don't think ever forgiven for IT, but IT created one of the most recognizable brands in the history of gaming.

Commented earlier. We're just got final word. We've been saying this for decades, but final word that the police station two is the largest selling or the most selling console in the history of consoles.

Hundred and sixty million councils were a wide nobody. He's quite done that. We had thought this was true, but I guess so only finally confirmed IT.

And that's just part of his legacy, his his approach illness. This guy's willing to go on anybodies podcast, talk anything they want to talk about. Always very open, always extremely friendly. He seemed like somebody who was connecting to the audience and not just a corporate sea sweet executive who keeps far away from everybody else. That impression was was always there during those those thirty eight years.

And while SONY has had certainly had its up and downs and its bumps here and there for the most part, I think his leadership and leadership like IT within the company has kept them in a really great place. They are in a bit of a crossroads now. And a lot of people talk about this, what sonedex ture look like, what is the future of hardware and physical media and all these kind of questions, game preservation, these are all questions that will hat zoning as much as any other company trying to navigate this particular part of the of the industry.

Y's time scale. But he is, he is, without doubt, one of the most influential characters in the history of gaming, and he'll probably be heavily missed there. I mean, I think in recent years, that was not a lot of hands on directly, but there are a lot of times during the history of of this company, including playstation, once launched police station tools, pivotal launch three in the problems they had, and then crawling back to a leadership position in the face of microsoft, multibillion nightmare company, trying to come steal some other ground.

I think you gotta give IT to him for for navigating a lot of that stuff. So know when one am a little super sad because it's just like old guard going away but also gets well done. You entered the company in your twenties .

and ah sixty states, thirty old. He's been on the team for thirty one years. I mean.

that's a lot. He's been with the company sence eighty six, so even got to feet that with whatever the ck they're working on prior to this and knowing that he was there before, playstation became a thing and was responsible for what was happening with the intendo playstation, which SONY was building for nintendo and then scrap like what what a wide range of being there for IT, right? Like desi st.

sane. But I think he deserves the break. And I hope that gorillas, former CEO, forgot his name. He'll be taking over, and they're very capable also.

So at the feeling that, that would be a good piece of leadership remaining, no, like the people that make the horizon zero dog games. But yeah, he's a dude. We're all we're going to think pretty fondly on.

And there's people like this in almost all of these cases. We think this way about certainly about mea moto over and intendo and and people at x box and founders and that sort of thing. But this is sony's version of that. And even though SONY doesn't ay, they don't play much in this celebrity game as that as much as other game companies do, it's still hard not to recognizing further contribution.

A lot of people were mentioning the video uh, that he did shortly after microsoft horrible twenty thirteen announcement and and that is probably my favorite memory of him. There is the thing that I know most about him um IT was if anybody doesn't recall, microsoft had an announcement where they talked about you know being able to share your digital games and I was considered to be a very complex thing of like only have three shares and you have to be on same network when you authorize blot bloody bloody law ah and you should do a video where is like here's how you share a SONY play station game and then there's like ten seconds of step one and then IT comes back to any hands IT to another guy who goes thanks and that's a they just smile and .

that's the end of IT yeah, they really took advantage of that. Microsoft dropped the ball. They picked up the bonded really well that generation.

They're being asked similar questions now because the landscape has changed, unfortunately. Microsoft, right a but a bunch of this, they just did IT wrong and did IT in the wrong timing. So we'll see how they navigated moving forward. But you can't one of the piece of this, I am, I imagine you can't deny the effect this guy had on one aspect of gaming and that as third party relationships, they existed under intendo, but they were stringent and hard and difficult to navigate.

If you're a third party gave not under the direct umbrella and tando IT was a pain SONY, made that way easier and still had high quality standards and just made its a third parties were as crucial to console success as anything under the hood. So you props to him for that as well. Yes, alright.

let's pretty shout strong with the male bag.

Ryan had some thoughts on our gdi conversation yesterday about the seven point four terabytes of mobile data on the Rogers five g surface used by people at Taylor swift in toronto, o's Roger center. Ryan says it's quite probable that Rogers owns the das or distributed intense system in the Rogers center. All major venues and entertainment complexes use dedicated mobile network designs to maintain service quality during events.

Most are independently Operated. The one in the minnesota state fair is run by mp slash neck level, but others may be Carrier owned or Operated. It's possible that Rogers was reporting the entire data usage in the stadium.

It's a good point where we were speculating on whether there was more than seven point four terabytes considering that there are other Carrier besides Rogers. But ryan, maybe right that the seven point four terrific, maybe all the data because Rogers was run in the das. So thanks for that, right? And good .

point indeed. And thanks to you, Scott Johnson as always, a the day before turkey day um you know where we find your latest us well.

there's a lot of good stuff happening in prog band to come because of the holiday. Things are a little bit goofy in terms of when things dropped, but I want to mention a monthly show that I do with greg street, if that names familiar. He used to be a very big shot, an important fellow, epl z ard entertainment for much of the formative years of world, world craft development.

He is now, since then, went to riot and then left riet and now works her his own company. They found a got fantastic pixel castle. Anyway, he and I worked together on a monthly podcast called ward on the street and his last name, street, and we talk about what they're doing.

Basically, IT is an attempt to do something very different in the gaming business. Be transparent from day one about everything that happens in developing an emo in twenty twenty four. And I am finding IT, even as the host who knows a lot of the stuff, absolutely fascinating. I think you'll enjoy IT to, if you haven't checked that out, go to frog band to come flash street or look for a word on the street where ever you get your shoes.

Now, listen, I know singles day is the biggest shopping day of the year. Nari happened on november eleven, but black friday is no swatch. And we are located in the united states.

So U S, S, A, patriotism. We're doing a sale at the D, T, N, S. Store, twenty five percent off your order if you use the code RAM at checkout because it's easy to remember and it's something we all want more of RAM R, A, M.

Twenty five percent of your order. And sky, thank you for making that that soa can glass art for us. We wanted to make that glass that's in the shape of a kind of old, tiny and fun. And you .

kill that man, I suspect, will have some more cool stuff from me and collaboration on that store as well. But yeah, those are really cool. Like they look like a can, like a soda, but they are glass. I don't know when that happened as a thing.

as a human made. Yes.

but it's red. I super like IT buy.

You can buy just as the glass, so you can get IT with the the wooden top and straw. So here you drinking IT like a soda too. But yeah, that are, you did just makes me crave seberal la.

And that was the idea is going old school forties time, which is always the thing.

I think about time. I mean, isn't he's still for his tom, no.

he's he's out in that decade. He belonged in one thousand nine hundred forties. I mean, I don't want that we wouldn't have. But I mean, we go back in time. We will find tom mir walk around on the for door, a drink in one of these.

drinking a says and and talking about or know the baton bomb lady way.

It's daily technique showed on flash store. And use the code RAM to get twenty five percent off your order. Patrons stick ground for the extension of your patron.

You get more show. Good day. internet. We're going to talk about how more than half of english language linked in posts show signs of being A I generated. And is that a bad thing we will discuss.

You can catch our show alive money to friday. We're alive at four P M. eastern. That's twenty one hundred UTC.

You can find out more at daily technical show at dot com at slash life. We are offer the U. S.

Thanksgiving holiday, but will be back on monday with bEllies full of turkey, with Alice on sherton joining us. Talk to them. The D, T, S.

family of .

podcasts.

helping each other understand club you have. Enjoy this.

We all have dreams, dream home renovations, dream vacations or sending our kids to their dream colleges.

But finding .

straight forward ways to turn those dreams into realistic goals, that's what things get tRicky. Marrow understands that. That's why with a dedicated marrow adviser, you get a personalized plan and a clear path ford, and having the bullets you're back helps your whole financial life move with you.

So when your plans change, marrow is with you every step of the way. Go to ml dot com slash bullish to learn more marrow, a bank of amErica company. What would you like the power to do?

Investing involves risk. marylin. ch. Peer finder. r. Investment visor member.

S. I P C. Every idea starts with a problem. Movie Parkers was simple. Glasses are too expensive. So they set out to change .

that by designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers theory.

able to offer prescription I wear that's expertly .

crafted and unexpectedly ly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and customer acid. And they started at just ninety five dollars.

including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff. Stop by a warby Parker store near you.