We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode DEBATE: Are there More than 2 Genders? | William & PepTalks Vs Andrew Wilson & SpeakeaZy

DEBATE: Are there More than 2 Genders? | William & PepTalks Vs Andrew Wilson & SpeakeaZy

2025/2/1
logo of podcast Modern-Day Debate

Modern-Day Debate

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Andrew
专注于解决高质量训练数据和模型开发成本问题的 AI 研究员。
S
Speakeasy
W
Will
参与《Camerosity Podcast》,分享1980年代相机使用经历的嘉宾。
Topics
Will: 我认为性别是一个光谱,并非只有男性和女性两种。性别认同是个人内心的感受,与性别表达和生理性别可以不一致。DSM-5 承认跨性别者存在性别焦虑症,但这并非精神疾病。性别肯定手术可以帮助跨性别者改善心理健康。社会排斥才是导致跨性别者抑郁和自杀的主要原因。我们应该尊重和支持跨性别者的权利,为他们创造一个包容和友善的环境。在体育运动中,我们可以使用更合适的指标来衡量公平性,例如力量、速度等,而不是仅仅依靠性别。在洗手间问题上,我们应该关注的是安全和舒适,而不是性别认同。如果有人因为使用与生理性别不符的洗手间而感到不适,我们可以采取其他措施来解决这个问题,例如增加无性别洗手间。 Speakeasy: 我认为只存在两种性别,基于生物学事实,性别与性不可分割。承认只有两种性别,根植于生物科学,提供了一种清晰而实用的方法来理解人类身份。模糊性别定义会造成混乱,例如在体育运动和法律领域。允许男性进入女性洗手间会增加性侵犯、恋童癖等风险,并助长性别间的性化。为了公平起见,体育运动应该根据性别进行区分。 Andrew: 我认为“他们/她们/我们”等代词及其对应的性别认同概念是无意义的,因为其定义过于模糊。性别认同的主观性使得建立一个有意义的分类体系变得不可能。“间性”并非第三种性别,而是一个包含多种性特征变异的统称。人类只有两种性别发育途径,因此只有两种性别。在体育运动中,男性通常具有生理优势,因此男性参与女子体育运动是不公平的。在洗手间问题上,我们应该考虑大多数人的舒适感,而不是少数人的特殊需求。允许跨性别者进入与其生理性别不符的洗手间会增加他人的不适感,并可能带来安全风险。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Link to tickets for Newark, NJ DEBATECON 5 on Feb-15-16th: https://www.eventcreate.com/e/debatecon5

DEBATECON 5 Crowdfund: https://igg.me/at/debatecon5

LINKS TO GUESTS: @escapewithspeakeazy @The_Crucible @PepTalksTV

Interested in debating on Modern-Day Debate? Here's a list of things we ask for from potential debaters when they email to make things go faster: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kdwtQrA7QevNev9Mjm4xKvHnTkJ7FY-rMLjqUhtZKmI/edit?usp=sharing

*Cameras are a necessity *No pre-recording your intro statement beforehand At Modern-Day Debate (MDD), our vision is to provide a neutral debate platform so everyone has their fair shot to make their case on a level playing field.

Consider joining our Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/ModernDayDebate ) or our channel as a member. Our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ModernDayDebate __________________________________________________________________ Modern Day Debate Discord: https://discord.gg/ModernDayDebate If James is hosting, the intro song will always be: MDD Theme [Featuring Brian & Travis] from Ye24: https://soundcloud.com/templecitystudios / @ThomCaliche If Ryan is hosting, you have to ask him what song is playing. _______________________________________________________________________________ RULES FOR CHAT -Chats flagrantly disrespectful toward speakers will receive a warning. *Attack the ideas instead of the person. -Chatters continuing the disrespect after a warning will be banned. -Chatters violating YouTube TOS are banned immediately. ______________________________________________________________________________________ DISCLAIMER The views shared by guests on Modern-Day Debate are not necessarily representative of the views of Modern-Day Debate, James, or any university he has or has had any affiliation with. I'm (James) a Christian. If you ever want prayer or just someone to talk to (specifically over voice chat on Zoom) after a horrible day, please reach out and let me know. [email protected] Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands)Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy)