Anglerfish Ancestors Once Roamed The Seafloor
13:07 Share

This message comes from NPR sponsor Rosetta Stone, an expert in language learning for 30 years. Right now, NPR listeners can get Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership to 25 different languages for 50% off. Learn more at rosettastone.com slash NPR. You're listening to Shortwave from NPR. The first time I ever saw an anglerfish was on the big screen. It appeared first as a warm, glowing light.

I see a light. A light? Yeah, over there. I see it too. Rising out of the dark with bulbous eyes and pointy teeth, this fish gets a villain moment in the 2003 Pixar movie Finding Nemo. It's so pretty. Good feelings gone. And so ensues probably the best underwater chase scene in cinematic history ever.

I remember seeing this movie in the theaters. I was three in 2003. This is Rose Fauché from Rice University. And apparently when the anglerfish scene came on, I was so freaked out by it, I started crying.

crying and my mom had to take me out to the theater. But Rose has had a change of heart about anglerfish because this past year she did research about them alongside evolutionary biologist and ichthyologist Elizabeth Miller at UC Irvine. Now, Elizabeth says this moment in Finding Nemo, where Dory and Marlin are enthralled by the anglerfish's bioluminescent light,

is pretty accurate to how it happens in the deep sea. The idea is that the prey are drawn to the lure and they don't see the anglerfish attached to it and they get eaten. There are over 200 species of deep sea anglerfish. The one in Finding Nemo was modeled after what's known as the football fish.

But Elizabeth and Rose told me others look very different. Some are long and thin, like eels. Some are squat. Some have huge, prehistoric-looking teeth, while others have big eyes set far back into their heads.

And the majority of them live in the bathy pelagic zone, the deep, deep sea. It's a huge expanse of space in total darkness, high pressure, cold temperatures, food limitation. But in this zone that is so cold, so homogenous, and so devoid of sunlight, somehow the anglerfish still ended up looking very diverse. And researchers wanted to know why.

It is a mystery. It's not clear why one anglerfish species would be shaped one way while a different anglerfish species would be shaped a different way.

So today on the show, the big anglerfish mystery. Why do these science fiction-y fish look so different from one another? What spurred this divergence in anglerfish body shape and size? And what can that tell us about the deep sea as a whole? I'm Emily Kwong, and you're listening to Shortwave, the science podcast from NPR.

This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices, like full-service wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on Thinkorswim. Visit Schwab.com to learn more.

Support for NPR and the following message come from Edward Jones. What does it mean to live a rich life? It means brave first leaps, tearful goodbyes, and everything in between. With over 100 years of experience navigating the ups and downs of the market and of life, your Edward Jones financial advisor will be there to help you move ahead with confidence. Because with all you've done to find your rich, they'll do all they can to help you keep enjoying it.

Edward Jones, member SIPC. This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices, like full-service wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on Thinkorswim. Visit Schwab.com to learn more.

Alright, Rose and Elizabeth, the deep-sea pelagic anglerfish, what were the big question marks for you and what did you want to figure out? So we can look at images of anglerfish and it seems obvious to our eyes that they're different shapes, but we needed to quantify that variation so that we can analyze it in depth.

evolutionary framework. And what I mean by an evolutionary framework is understanding how all of that diversity evolved. Did it evolve very quickly? Did it evolve gradually? Those are the big questions. And Rose, at the time, you were an undergrad student at Rice University in Elizabeth's colleague's lab. Can you explain what you did on this project? What was your role? So my part of the project was learning

looking at the morphology of anglerfish skulls. I had to look up the skeletons of the anglerfish and then determine which bones are which and like the edges of all the bones and things like that. So I took the CT scans that we had of these anglerfish bones

And first I had to make them into like a 3D model. And then we have this very fun software that basically lets me put a little dot on the

on certain points of that skull model. We settled on, I believe it's 111 landmarks that I put onto each of these skulls. Yeah, I will say 111 points is a lot. It's even more difficult when you've got these fish that have such bizarre skulls. The work that Rose did is really tremendous and it was all done by hand. So you all set about building a family tree for anglerfish, right?

So cool. How do you even go about building something like that? So to back up a little bit, the big family tree is what links all of these species together. Yeah. And the methods to do this are the same for pretty much any organism. You extract DNA from the tissues of these specimens. What makes it difficult in the case of the anglerfish is getting those tissues. Right. This isn't a 23andMe situation. You can't just...

ask anglerfish to spit into a tube for you so you can collect their DNA. That's correct. And finding the fish is no small feat, as you can imagine. Um,

It relies on careful planning of people who regularly go out to sea to do surveys of fishes in general, not necessarily targeting anglerfishes, and making sure when an anglerfish is found that it's preserved in the proper way. It needs to be kept on ice and kept cold pretty much as soon as it's brought up. It needs to be preserved in alcohol and put on a shelf in a museum and that

That's the basis of the CT scans or the three-dimensional x-rays that we used. And then the tissues were the basis of the family tree. Okay. So while Rose was mapping all these three-dimensional x-rays, plotting points onto the skulls to see where the anglerfish were visually similar, it sounds like, Elizabeth, you were extracting the DNA and seeing where they were genetically similar. That's right. That's exactly right.

And so from there, I use fancy statistical models. And basically, it tells me what the differences are from species to species and the significance of those differences as far as like how closely or distantly related the different species are. Wow. Okay. Rose, can you talk a little bit about how you and Elizabeth got access to all these specimens and CT scans? I heard all this was done with museum collections, kind of like...

an interlibrary loan but four museums? So all these different museums across the world have

like fantastic collections of fish that are basically just preserved in ethanol. And there is like an online database where you can search for, you know, whatever species of fish you're looking for and it will show you. And the fish world is actually, it's pretty small. It feels kind of like everybody knows everybody. And so if you ask nicely enough, they'll FedEx you fish that have been sitting in a jar since like 1965. Yeah.

And if you're a very lucky undergrad, you get to open up a package in lab one day and you're holding like one of the rarest fish on earth. Were you one of these lucky undergrads who got to do this? I did get to be an undergrad who opened up

Yeah.

Also, I'm sure it's shocking to hear, but 60-year-old fish sitting in ethanol do have a particular smell about them. Delicious. So you are going deep into anglerfish history, in a way, in looking at these samples. I want to go all the way back to the original anglerfish ancestor. What did that mean?

ancestor look like? The one that started it all. I'll give some context that anglerfish, the deep sea anglerfish we've been talking about are all part of this group with a scientific name, Lophia formis. Lophia formis. Yes. Okay. So the deep sea anglerfish, their closest relative within this broader group is a fish called the sea toad. The sea toad? Yes. That's another fun one to Google if you have access to Google the sea toad.

Oh, I am. I am. Coffinfishes. Is that another word for sea toads? Yeah, they look very grumpy. They're literally frowning. Exactly. And hanging out on the bottom of the ocean floor. Yep. Coffinfish is another word for them. So that's the closest living relative to the deep-seeing fish we've been talking about. And so what did the direct ancestor of the anglerfishes look like at

Most likely looked something like that sea toad, although perhaps something intermediate. We can't know for sure. But what it implies is that the broader group, Lophiformes, has always been in the deep sea in some capacity. But the more significant transition was off the seafloor and into the water column. Yeah. This seems like one of the biggest takeaways of your study. And it's amazing that anglerfish started from the deep sea.

from an ancestor that lived on the ocean floor and then made it into the water column to be the anglerfish that we know and love today. That's correct. The bathyplagic anglerfishes seem to have arisen from a deep-sea benthic ancestor, and it was this transition off the seafloor that spurred the evolution of all of these new shapes. And what does that tell us about, like,

the conditions of this part of the ocean that made that so? Like, is it just that they had to adapt super quickly in order to survive? I think the way to think about it is opportunity. They came off the seafloor into the water column, the bathyplagic zone, and presumably there are new ways of living, new ecological opportunities, even if we don't know necessarily what they are. And so they potentially evolved these new shapes to take advantage of those new opportunities.

Yeah. I want to ask you both one last question. Why do you think this is so important to study? How does it change how you think about this field of evolutionary biology? I think this is critical for our understanding of the conditions that diversity evolves in. We're used to thinking of biodiversity in terms of tropical rainforests and coral reefs, places that have a lot going on.

And we look at a place like the deep sea and we see the opposite of that. And what we're learning from the evolutionary history of the anglerfish is that that also might be a place where you can evolve a lot of biodiversity. And that's a totally new way of looking at that environment. Rose? Well, so I think especially...

Natural history and marine biology at this point in time can be...

a pretty devastating field to work in. You know, so much of what we do and what we think about is how much we are constantly losing that's already gone. But there's something about the scope of this project that felt positive and kind of like a nice reprieve from that. Yeah. I think a lot of this project was...

celebrating the biodiversity that we do have. And yeah, it's kind of nice to for once not be like, well, here's a thousand genuses about to go extinct. No, here's a thousand genuses being opportunistic hunters in the ocean. Yeah.

I love that. Well, thank you both so much for spending time with me and helping short wavers everywhere learn more about these incredible fish. It was my pleasure. Thank you. Thanks.

This episode was produced by Hannah Chin. It was edited by Burleigh McCoy and fact-checked by Tyler Jones. The audio engineer was Kweisi Lee. Beth Donovan is our senior director and Colin Campbell is our senior vice president of podcasting strategy. I'm Emily Kwong. Thank you for listening to Shorewave from NPR.

This message comes from Mattress Firm. Spring is the season for fresh starts, so start with better sleep. Mattress Firm sleep experts will match you with the right mattress for your best rest. Get matched at Mattress Firm's Memorial Day Sale and sleep at night.

This message comes from Allianz Travel Insurance. The family was all set for vacation until the phrase break a leg became a little too literal at last week's kickball game. Trip cancellation benefits can help when life sidelines your plans. Visit AllianzTravelInsurance.com.

Support for this NPR podcast comes from Zscaler. Reduce infrastructure costs by 90% and improve networking and security agility by eliminating firewalls and VPNs with Zscaler Zero Trust Plus AI. Learn more at zscaler.com slash security.