From Critics at Large: After “Wicked,” What Do We Want from the Musical?
The New Yorker Radio Hour
Deep Dive
Why is 'Wicked' resonating with audiences in 2024?
Wicked resonates with audiences due to its big emotions, themes of friendship and love, and its ability to evoke strong feelings. The film's memorable songs, especially 'Defying Gravity,' and the strong performances by Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo contribute to its emotional impact and popularity.
Why are jukebox musicals and IP grabs common on Broadway today?
Jukebox musicals and IP grabs are common on Broadway because they bank on audiences' nostalgia for old hits and capitalize on the popularity of beloved movies and stories. These productions are often seen as safer financial bets compared to original ideas, which are riskier and less frequent.
Why does 'Wicked' feel so long to some viewers?
Wicked feels long to some viewers because it runs for two hours and 40 minutes, which is considered excessive by many. The film's pacing and the inclusion of many slower, less engaging scenes contribute to this perception.
Why does 'Joker: Folie à Deux' fail as a musical?
Joker: Folie à Deux fails as a musical because it lacks energy and feels joyless. The songs, mostly covers of older tunes, do not integrate well with the plot, and the film's overall tone is unengaging. The addition of musical elements does not enhance the story but rather detracts from it.
Why is 'Emilia Pérez' an interesting contrast to 'Wicked'?
Emilia Pérez is an interesting contrast to Wicked because it deals with serious topics like cartels and gender transition, and it uses music to heighten the emotional and dramatic aspects of the story. Unlike Wicked's more traditional musical approach, Emilia Pérez incorporates the everyday sounds of Mexico City into its songs, creating a unique and immersive experience.
Why have musicals evolved from review-style shows to story-driven productions?
Musicals evolved from review-style shows to story-driven productions to provide deeper character and plot development. This shift began in the late 1920s with shows like Showboat, which tackled serious issues like race and social inequality. By the 1940s, musicals like Oklahoma integrated songs more closely with the narrative, making them crucial to character and plot development.
Why is 'Hamilton' considered a significant innovation in musical theater?
Hamilton is considered a significant innovation in musical theater because it combines diverse musical styles, including hip-hop, rap, and traditional show tunes, to tell a historical story. Its ability to engage young audiences and create a sense of excitement and community in the theater is unparalleled, making it a cultural phenomenon.
Why are some critics concerned about the homogenization of musicals?
Some critics are concerned about the homogenization of musicals because many contemporary productions, including Wicked and Hamilton, feature a similar style of R&B-influenced vocals and slick harmonizations. This trend can prioritize vocal acrobatics over storytelling, leading to a lack of diversity and innovation in the genre.
Why are R-rated musicals like 'A Strange Loop' and 'Teeth' seen as the future of the genre?
R-rated musicals like A Strange Loop and Teeth are seen as the future of the genre because they push boundaries and address mature, complex themes. These productions challenge traditional norms and offer a deeper, more realistic engagement with contemporary issues, making them a potential vanguard for the evolution of musical theater.
- Wicked's movie adaptation is a two-part film.
- "Wicked" is taking up a lot of cultural oxygen.
- Audiences are loving "Wicked Part One".
Shownotes Transcript