cover of episode 153. 双城之战,狗尾续貂!

153. 双城之战,狗尾续貂!

2024/12/14
logo of podcast 美西螈与东方巨龙

美西螈与东方巨龙

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
东方巨龙
美西螈
Topics
美西螈: 第二季剧情存在诸多问题,例如角色动机不明确,人物转变突兀,剧情进展过快,第三幕剧情更是飞速发展,令人难以理解。蔚的角色崩坏,其转变缺乏逻辑,成为凯特琳的附属品,其行为与之前设定不符。凯特琳的角色转变也令人困惑,其与安贝萨的关系线有潜力但未充分展现。安贝萨、梅尔和黑玫瑰的故事线缺乏清晰度,观众需要自行拼凑剧情。杰斯杀死维克多的行为令人愤怒,尽管其动机可能合理。金克斯的故事线虽然有其亮点,但整体缺乏新意,其转变过程被杰斯的行为破坏。伊莎的角色设定单一,缺乏独立性,其存在意义仅仅是为了服务金克斯。总而言之,第二季的剧情存在诸多逻辑漏洞,人物行为不合理,主题也发生了偏移,从社会阶级矛盾转变为人类与人工智能的对抗,令人失望。 东方巨龙: 第二季剧情走向与《权力的游戏》相似,开头尚可,中间精彩,结尾潦草。剧情推动人物,而非人物推动剧情,导致人物行为不合理。编剧在创作过程中,思路存在困惑,结局已预设,导致剧情发展不合理。凯特琳在第二季中承载了大量的剧情点,推动了主线剧情发展,但其转变令人困惑。安贝萨和凯特琳的关系线有潜力,但最终没有被充分展现。金克斯的故事线虽然有其亮点,但整体缺乏新意,其转变过程被杰斯的行为破坏,伊莎的角色设定单一,缺乏独立性,其存在意义仅仅是为了服务金克斯。第三幕改变了剧集的主题,从社会阶级矛盾转变为人类与人工智能的对抗,缺乏深度。维克多与安贝萨合作的动机令人难以理解。总而言之,第二季的剧情存在诸多问题,主题空洞,令人失望。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did the second season of 'Arcane' receive criticism for its character development?

The second season of 'Arcane' faced criticism for its character development because many characters, like Vi, underwent abrupt and poorly explained transformations. For instance, Vi, who initially despised enforcers, quickly became one without sufficient justification, leading to a sense of inconsistency and forced plot progression.

What were the main issues with the third act of 'Arcane' Season 2?

The third act of 'Arcane' Season 2 was criticized for its sudden shift in themes, moving from a deep exploration of societal and class conflicts to a more generic 'humans vs. AI' narrative. This abrupt change felt disconnected from the earlier, more nuanced storytelling, leaving viewers confused and dissatisfied.

Why did the relationship between Caitlyn and Ambesa feel underdeveloped in Season 2?

The relationship between Caitlyn and Ambesa felt underdeveloped because the show failed to fully explore the complexities of their dynamic. While there were hints of mutual respect and manipulation, the narrative didn't provide enough context or development to make their interactions feel meaningful or coherent.

What were the strengths of 'Arcane' Season 2 despite its flaws?

Despite its narrative flaws, 'Arcane' Season 2 excelled in animation and music. The visual artistry, particularly in depicting the wild runes, was stunning, and the soundtrack, including songs like Pink the Town Blue, added depth to the storytelling. Additionally, the show's diverse representation of gender and body types was praised.

How did the character Jinx evolve in Season 2, and what were the criticisms of her arc?

In Season 2, Jinx's character evolved as she found a sense of purpose through caring for Isha, which helped her heal from her self-destructive tendencies. However, her arc was criticized for relying on clichéd tropes, such as the 'lone wolf finding redemption through a child,' which felt predictable and less impactful compared to her more complex portrayal in Season 1.

Chapters
本期节目,我们对《双城之战》第二季进行了深度剖析,从剧情、人物塑造、主题表达等多个角度,探讨了它为何让许多观众失望。我们一一分析了主要角色的转变,以及剧情节奏和主旨表达上的不足,并最终总结了其不足之处。
  • 第二季采用三幕放送方式,延长了观众的期待时间。
  • 剧情转折突兀,人物转变缺乏合理性,很多情节难以理解。
  • 第三幕剧情崩坏,主题表达混乱,与前两幕严重脱节。

Shownotes Transcript

《英雄联盟:双城之战 第二季 (Arcane Season 2) 》可能是有史以来最被期待的续作。

超一流的动画水准、跌宕起伏的人物命运、令人欲罢不能的故事剧情,这些曾紧紧勾住观众的元素,在第二季的展开中似乎离我们很近又很远了。

爱之深,责之切。今天这期节目,螈与龙从全线崩盘的结局出发,没有放过一个被编剧折磨至ooc的主要角色。不管是动机反复一百八十度大转弯的善变人,还是到处背锅拆散阖家幸福的工具人,亦或者是失去目标转型无头苍蝇到处乱飞的挂件人,今天的节目实现全罗列成就——变成人工智能逃不掉,就算是牺牲自我拯救他人也只能稍有善待。

吐槽归吐槽,《双城之战》仍然是绝对难忘的体验。虽然对第二季有诸多不满,我们还是从中收获了欢乐与力量,这样有趣且令人讨论欲爆棚的作品着实可遇不可求。在此诚挚邀请各位朋友一起上车,加入螈与龙的双城之旅吧!

【时间线】

[01:36] 开场白

[03:08] 第二季喜提权游烂尾大套餐

[11:44] i蔚er长叹:拿什么拯救你,彻底崩坏的蔚?

[22:23] 凯特琳的转变略显生硬?那就掏出凯蔚卖一卖!

[31:13] 脱节的梅尔:把主线当彩蛋写就是编剧失职

[39:58] 杰斯,我知道你有道理,但实在都是你的错!

[47:17] 金克斯丝欣慰:看女儿逐渐变好,努力幸福

[53:41] 反方辩手:不喜欢伊莎线,编剧吃我一炮!

[01:04:14] 第三幕剧情糟糕透顶,主题表达一塌糊涂

[01:18:01] 三个共识的优点:动画、音乐与女性塑造

[01:29:08] Closure:螈与龙的双城之旅就到这里

[01:32:07] 恰恰ChatChat来袭!新节目惊喜预告

[01:35:07] 结束语

【本期音乐】

Woodkid - To Ashes and Blood

陈奕迅 - 这样很好

【听友福利】

播客听友专属红包:在饿了么搜索「螈与龙」即可领取外卖红包!每日可领三次,顿顿叠加,餐餐优惠!(此活动长期有效)

【抢先订阅】

小螈与小龙的新节目即将与大家见面,欢迎猛戳下方链接抢先订阅,以便后续收到更新通知👇🏼

https://www.xiaoyuzhoufm.com/podcast/6757f1bd17cd5416adec0c8e

【支持我们】

爱发电搜索「螈与龙」或复制链接:

https://afdian.com/@yyl_yyl

【关于我们】

这是一束横跨太平洋的电波——我们从独特的人文和性别视角出发,关注流行文化议题及社会形态变迁。

【加入社群】

关注公众号「螈与龙」回复“听友群”即可添加小助手拉进VIP群哦,我们等着一个你!

Peace。